3 ms·
I think you're rewriting history here. CP/M was there long before Microsoft's dominance took off, powering machines from multiple companies (including the ones
by beagle3 14y ago
I think you're rewriting history here.
CP/M was there long before Microsoft's dominance took off, powering machines from multiple companies (including the ones you listed). In fact, MS DOS 1.0 was a re-branded QDOS, which was highly inspired by (as in, an incompatible but extremely similar to) CP/M.
It was Microsoft's execution, NOT innovation, that gave them the lead. And IBM's lack of foresight, giving Microsoft control of the PC market.
- WalterBright 14y agoCP/M, in turn, was highly inspired by DEC's PDP-11 operating system.
- protomyth 14y agoTechnically, but not business model-wise.
- prostoalex 14y agoIBM lacked foresight only in retrospect and we can laugh and point fingers only because we know the outcome. In any given year the company of that size probably has access to a hundred various technologies that have not been market-tested. No company has a record of picking winners and losers perfectly, most companies need to concentrate, and hence the whole market for mergers & acquisitions exists. IBM actually rode the PC market quite nicely and exited it via sale to Lenovo quite timely as well.
- beagle3 14y agoIndeed. I was not implying that they were stupid or that anyone else would have seen it better; just stating the fact that they did not anticipate what ceding control of the OS market to Microsoft would mean. From what I've read, IBM didn't pay much attention to this decision - they considered MS-DOS 1.0 a "stop-gap" measure to make the PC-g useful (original IBM-PC model, later followed by XT, jr and AT) while they were getting a real operating system (CP/M 86) ready. In fact, IBM's original PC-g seems like it was almost an afterthought ("oh, Apple implies there actually is a market for a personal business computer? let's put a leg in this market, just in case"). The original design had very little IBM in it - it was very close to Intel reference designs for the 8088, using available off-the-shelf components (the main non-intel parts were a Motorolla CRT controller, a NEC floppy disk controller which was backward compatible with an older Intel floppy disk controller; unlike Apple's Woz-designed Video adapters and disk controllers).
- WalterBright 14y agoIBM mounted a major marketing campaign for the PC when it was introduced, and it made a big splash. It sure didn't look like an afterthought. When I bought my IBM PC, there was CP/M-86 (in an IBM box) on the shelf right along side PC-DOS (IBM branded MS-DOS). PC-DOS was $40, and CP/M-86 was (I don't recall exactly) $180. Everyone bought PC-DOS because of the price. The company I worked for at the time did buy a copy of CP/M-86, so I had a chance to work with it for a while. I saw nothing at all to recommend it over PC-DOS. It was not a "real" operating system any more than PC-DOS was. CP/M-86 failed because it was way, way overpriced. There was no conspiracy against it, and it was not technically superior.
- beagle3 14y ago> It sure didn't look like an afterthought. I don't remember the marketing around it; I believe you they made a splash. But technically, it didn't look like IBM spent a lot designing it. > there was CP/M-86 (in an IBM box) on the shelf right along side PC-DOS (IBM branded MS-DOS) That was after IBM PC was already a hit. When it was introduced, and for quite a while after, only PC DOS was available. > I saw nothing at all to recommend it over PC-DOS. It was not a "real" operating system any more than PC-DOS was. That is correct. Also, when CP/M-86 was finally introduced, it had no software (all CP/M software at the time was 8080 or more commonly Z-80), whereas PC-DOS=MS-DOS had already amassed a nontrivial software catalog. > There was no conspiracy against it, and it was not technically superior. I totally agree, never said it was. But I do remember reading that the IBM thought process was that CP/M-86 was the "serious" operating system, since CP/M had business software already (wordprocessors, payroll software - don't remember if VisiCalc was already ported to CP/M at the time), whereas PC-DOS was a newcomer, and therefore cannot be taken seriously (except as a stopgap measure).
- WalterBright 14y agoThere was a selection of CP/M-86 software for a while from companies that hedged their bets and developed for both systems. This ended when they noticed nobody bought those versions. I'm not sure just when CP/M-86 was released by IBM, but it was there when the IBM PC with the 64K mobo and 180K floppy appeared, which is when I bought mine. Many CP/M people did buy CP/M-86 at first, but they threw it under the bus shortly thereafter. Some of them tried to extoll its virtues to me at the time, but they were clearly disappointed by it.
- brudgers 14y agoThey're valid points. I believe that Microsoft's business model benefited from the fact that it sold an OS which did not require manufacturer customization. It allowed hardware manufacturer's to focus on supply and demand and avoid the software development process, e.g. Dell could grow without acquiring software development expertise. At the time, Microsoft was not trying to monetize the toolchain in the conventional manner Digital Research was pursuing.