6 ms·
Little Brother is watching: San Francisco PD relying on citizens with cameras
- Apocryphon 14y agoThe late Flip video camera would be perfect for this sort of activity.
- kbuck 14y agoI don't really like the parallel the title here draws between "big brother" and people filming with their own cameras. The difference between the city having cameras everywhere and citizens filming is that the city would be recording everything, where citizens with cameras will likely only furnish video of crimes. You aren't being watched all the time, but if you decide to do something like smash a bus window, you deserve to be turned in. It'd be the same as the cameraman serving as a witness, except that they have concrete evidence so they don't even need to appear in court. When I composed this comment, the submission title was: "Little Brother is watching: San Francisco PD relying on citizens with cameras" (which doesn't match the current article title).
- mvzink 14y agoWhat I thought of was Cory Doctorow's book Little Brother, which posits the inverse of this situation (a "techno-geek rebellion") rather than draw a parallel: "Big Brother is watching us, but who's watching back?" or something like that.
- greggman 14y agoI've often wondered if I could record traffic violations and upload them somewhere where the policen could act on them. I haven't done it because I'd be worried about retribution and because I doubt the police would act. Examples, cars going 65-70 in a 50mph zone. The the San Francisco Bay area Between Oakland across the Bay Bridge all the way to Candlestick park is a 50-55mph zone but lots of cars drive 70 all the way. I don't know how hard it would be to compute their speed relative to mine from the video. Easier examples, cars turning right from a left lane. Cars tailgating. Cars changing lanes without signaling. Cars changing lanes while crossing an intersection. Cars cutting people off. Cars passing on the right on a 1 lane street, essentially driving as though it's a two lane street. I'm not trying to be a snitch. I'd just like the roads to be safer. People who break traffic laws are effectively risking your life. That's not cool.
- rndmize 14y agoA lot of this sounds like typical congested city problems, and I don't know how much reporting it would do. I would hope the cops have better things to do than watch videos of people tailgating or changing lanes without signalling, frankly (as much as these may annoy me). That said, you could get a dashcam and send whatever particularly egregious incidents you run across to the cops by mail, probably.
- Karunamon 14y ago>I would hope the cops have better things to do than watch videos of people tailgating or changing lanes without signalling, frankly (as much as these may annoy me). Agreed, but I'd imagine you could hire people who had that as their primary job, and then make serious bank on the resulting fines. I can't imagine a single driver who hasn't seen some twit driving like a maniac and thinking "where's a cop when you need one"?
- ojbyrne 14y agoIt's funny, but I most often feel the urge to do this when I see police doing similar things. Because that's even less cool, but also more noticeable. I know others who feel a similar sense of outrage.
- stretchwithme 14y agoAnd the PD has always relied on citizens with eyes. Cameras are just more reliable.
- stretchwithme 14y agoI think this is a good trend. The more criminals understand that they will be caught, the sooner they will be off the street and/or learn to behave. I see this trend going even further though. A lot of people have suspicions about crime before it even takes place. A person standing in front of a car and looking around to see who's watching, for example. What if they could report suspicion and have that alert property owners and police before a crime occurs? Such suspicion should not be used to hassle people. That person waiting by the car may be meeting the owner and looking for his approach. But knowing that people have suspicions can allow property owners to turn on lights and do other things to communicate that the chances of being caught are not low. Cops could also use suspicion data to decide where cops should be when there is no crime. Better to hang out on a block where suspicions are high than where there is no crime. Over time, I can see them discerning between suspicion that precedes actual crime and false suspicion and get even better at predicting where they should be.
- DanBC 14y ago> I see this trend going even further though. A lot of people have suspicions about crime before it even takes place. A person standing in front of a car and looking around to see who's watching, for example. > What if they could report suspicion and have that alert property owners and police before a crime occurs? Neighbourhood watch schemes are not new. They do, rarely, have problems. > Dispatcher: Are you following him? > Zimmerman: Yeah. > Dispatcher: Okay, we don't need you to do that. > Zimmerman: Okay.
- stretchwithme 14y agoAnytime someone starts carrying a gun around and acting like a cop without being trained or uniformed as a cop, there's going to be problems.
- naww 14y agoAnytime someone starts carrying a gun around and acting like a cop while being trained and uniformed as a cop, there's going to be problems, if you film them.
- naww 14y agoI don't see why they use civilians to look and screen videos. Hope they have a watchmen for watchmen and informed officers who know about taping police on work. Isn't this bit off Hacker News 'thou?
- grecy 14y agoRihanna is nice enough to take a photo of herself smoking an illegal substance, post it on her own Twitter feed, and no action is taken by the police. Double standard?
- il 14y agoHave you been to San Francisco? Nobody's getting arrested for that here. No double standard, some laws are enforced more than others. This is about property/violent crimes, not snitching on victimless crimes.
- ojbyrne 14y agoThe last 3 presidents have publicly admitted to that particular crime. So obviously...
- anigbrowl 14y agoNo victim making a complaint, not obvious which jurisdiction the action took place, not a crime in all jurisdictions.
- vellum 14y agoPot smoking in Cali gets you a citation at best. It's not obvious where she was, and SF's not going track down alleged pot smokers. All the actions mentioned in the article were violent acts and felonies.