3 ms·
Duh. Base a model on polling data and you are only as good as your polling data. If the election is swung by cheating this time (as evidence suggests has happ
by btilly 14y ago
Duh. Base a model on polling data and you are only as good as your polling data. If the election is swung by cheating this time (as evidence suggests has happened plenty of times in the past), polls will be spectacularly wrong. Incorporate everything else you can think of and you get only a bit more accurate.
However the question is this. Do you have anything more accurate? I've had the experience on NPR of hearing pundits going on at length about what states matter. And it was less informative than a glance at http://www.electoral-vote.com/ http://www.electoral-vote.com/ is.
So no, it is not perfect. Nobody, particularly Nate, says that it is. But we don't have anything better.
- jeffdavis 14y agoSo what does he add to the conversation? We can all see the electoral map. It's just a question of which polls you believe (or want to believe).
- mikeryan 14y agoThe five thirty eight model is actually based on accounting for accuracies in the polling data. It take's a poll's historical accuracy into account when weighing its impact on the model. This is where he gets an additional degree of accuracy as opposed to straight poll aggregation. So it actually does "choose" which polls to believe...
- mayneack 14y agoYes. Unbiased != more accurate. If, for example, there is a poll you KNOW is doing something wrong, you should down-weight it. A pure polling average there would be wrong. However, once you start weighting polls, people start criticizing the way you do it.
- jtfairbank 14y agoCheck out http://electionanalytics.cs.illinois.edu/ http://electionanalytics.cs.illinois.edu/ for an alternative to Nate Silver. It uses bayesian analysis and dynamic program to come up with a deterministic snapshot of the election. It is based on the polling data, so if the data is off the snapshot will be off, but otherwise it seems to provide a great snapshot of the Election.
- mkr-hn 14y agoI think that's the same method Nate Silver uses. edit: I just looked at your comment history. Repeating the same comment over and over is going to cause problems.