4 ms·
That consent of portrayed parties is impossible. What is the solution there?
by chabes 7mo ago
That consent of portrayed parties is impossible.
What is the solution there?
- trollbridge 7mo agoPortray fictional characters?
- Retr0id 7mo agoThere are 8 billion humans, any fictional human is going to look almost exactly like at least one real human.
- trollbridge 7mo agoHow about obviously fictional portrayals then? Somewhat cartoonish or anime or artistic etc
- Retr0id 7mo agoThe caricatures drawn by newspaper cartoonists, for example, are still recognisable portrayals of someone specific.
- wolvoleo 7mo agoYes but for bullying purposes this is not useful. You're not going to try generating a pic 8 billion times till you get it right.
- Retr0id 7mo agoI'm sure the odds go up a lot once you describe the characteristics you want
- _fizz_buzz_ 7mo agoShouldn’t it be possible for AI to filter out that a request is made to portray a real person? That seems almost like a trivial task for a good model. I am sure every now and then something will slip through, but I bet one could make it very close to 100% effective.
- Retr0id 7mo agoI can see how it'd be trivial to block known celebrities, but how do you handle everyone else?
- XorNot 7mo agoI mean a realistic take is to simply not use source images containing people at all. AIs have been able to invent fictional people longer then they've been able to modify existing images.
- wolvoleo 7mo agoDo you need to? It doesn't know everyone else. Or at least it shouldn't.
- rrr_oh_man 7mo ago> trivial to block known celebrities see here for one example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47370100 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47370100
- TheOtherHobbes 7mo agoAI development has become an excuse for ignoring consent. Of course it's possible to filter out requests. But culturally with X, it's not remotely likely, unless compelled by regulation with teeth.
- nitwit005 7mo agoConsider the difference between "Generate an image of Emma Watson", "Generate an image of Hermione", and "Generate an image of a female hogwarts witch and student". We're getting less and less specific, but those are all likely to get you an image of Emma Watson. Your filter has to pick out that, while they did not ask for a specific person, the practical result is likely to be the same. That's going to be tough to get near perfect.
- wolvoleo 7mo agoYou can just forbid using existing images as a source and describe them purely by text.