3 ms·
There are problems with FTPT, but all voting systems are simply compromises between certain mutually exclusive criteria, all of which are generally desirable. Y
by baddox 14y ago
There are problems with FTPT, but all voting systems are simply compromises between certain mutually exclusive criteria, all of which are generally desirable. You can't have all the desirable characteristics at the same time, as demonstrated by Arrow's impossiblity theorem and the Gibbard–Satterthwaite theorem. Sure, FTPT has some disadvantages, but trading it for something like instant run-off voting introduces some new disadvantages. It's insufficient to argue that FTPT is strictly inferior. You really just have to argue for which criteria you think are more important. The third link is a great comparison of many different voting systems and criteria.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrows_impossibility_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrows_impossibility_theorem
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibbard%E2%80%93Satterthwaite_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibbard%E2%80%93Satterthwaite_t...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_instant_runoff_voting_to_other_voting_systems#Voting_system_criteria http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_instant_runoff_vo...
- studentrob 14y agoMost important to me would be a condorcet winner, something we do not have in FPTP (ftfy)
- baddox 14y agoWhy do you value the Condorcet criterion so much, especially since a Condorcet candidate might not even exist?
- harshreality 14y agoFPTP and IRV for single-winner elections are completely compromised, due to tactical voting (and lack of fairness to third parties) in common scenarios. I don't think you can support your claim that other systems are just as bad. In every informed discussion of voting systems I've ever encountered, FPTP and IRV are considered inferior to voting systems like Condorcet variants [1] or Range Voting [2] [3]. Preference between condorcet and range voting is a lot more murky. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_system#Compliance_of_selected_systems_.28table.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_system#Compliance_of_sel... http://rangevoting.org/rangeVcond.html http://rangevoting.org/rangeVcond.html [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condorcet_method http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condorcet_method [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Range_voting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Range_voting [3] http://rangevoting.org http://rangevoting.org
- baddox 14y agoUnfortunately, I believe all voting systems are subject to tactical voting, because of Condorcet's paradox. Please correct me if I'm wrong. edit: I forgot to mention that all voting systems are subject to tactical voting, except for ones which are dictatorial or non-deterministic (and those are generally considered nonviable systems).
- harshreality 14y agoRange voting at its worst turns into approval voting. RV is not an ordered list voting system, so Arrow's theorem, the Gibbard–Satterthwaite thorem, and Condorcet's paradox do not strictly apply. For ranked ballot voting systems, there's a difference in what kinds of tactical voting are possible, and in how likely it is for tactical voting to improve your perception of the outcome (baysian regret comparison of honest vs tactical voting). Ranked voting systems are not all equivalently bad simply because they're each subject to some kinds of tactical voting. I think Condorcet is promising (among all the ranked-ballot methods) because the Condorcet principle is easy to agree with. The choice of cycle-breaking method is where the fault lines appear, but new cycle-breaking methods could attract a consensus.