3 ms·
I run four weekly e-mail newsletters dedicated to programmers (in the JS, Ruby, HTML5, and 'general' spaces) with a total circulation of around 80,000 and Launc
by petercooper 14y ago
I run four weekly e-mail newsletters dedicated to programmers (in the JS, Ruby, HTML5, and 'general' spaces) with a total circulation of around 80,000 and Launchbit occasionally sells ads for me (though I'm doing more direct now, it seems).
My long term average open rates are 50.6%, 54.2%, 52.5% and 58.1% respectively - that's for weekly, curated news. They certainly drop a little over time and I've discovered two of the key reasons so far: people skipping some weeks due to e-mail overload and increasingly strict spam filtering.
What's a little annoying about this at first is that e-mail advertising is typically sold by CPM. So let's say I have 20k subscribers on a list and I can sell for $20 CPM (not unrealistic at all in e-mail).. that's $400. But that's $400 whether my open rate is 20% or 60%.
The most eagle eyed advertisers will ask for historical click rates and open rates but you'd be surprised how many don't. So in a way I'd rather charge per click but this doesn't seem to be accepted practice in e-mail right now.
Last, I've not found the word "free" to be too much of a problem. It's pretty common in mails and doesn't appear to be much of a trigger unless you all-caps it or add exclamation marks (e.g. FREE!!)
What absolutely massacred one issue of a newsletter, though, was the "Do You Really Want to Be Making This Much Money When You're 50?" post that did the rounds on HN recently. I included it and that issue's open rate fell by over half! Why? It's about as spammy a title as you could get and set off a ton of bells. So now I do even more spam analysis with each issue I send ;-)
BTW, I'm always happy to answer questions about the e-mail newsletter game, so feel free. I could probably ramble here all day about it. It's fun!
- nedwin 14y agoGreat post. Where do I find great lists to send news to and advertise on (aside from LaunchBit)?
- hippo33 14y agoThis is another property owned by LaunchBit, but perhaps this is what you're looking for: http://www.newsletterdirectory.co/directory/ http://www.newsletterdirectory.co/directory/ It can help you find lists to get in touch with.
- duck 14y agoI've found the same thing about the word "free" and exclamation marks. Gmail especially seems to be tightening down in the last month or two - I've avoided the spam folder with Hacker Newsletter for the most part, but I'm seeing more and more valid newsletters ending up there lately.
- ajtaylor 14y agoI've been subscribed to your HTML 5 and JS newsletters for a couple months now. The content has been great overall. Enough so that I'm asking you where I can signup for the other two newsletters. :)
- petercooper 14y agoGreat! :) http://rubyweekly.com/ http://rubyweekly.com/ is the Ruby one and http://statuscode.org/ http://statuscode.org/ is the one for programmers generally (covers algorithms, general advances in the field, generic tools, language agnostic articles, etc.)
- ajtaylor 14y agoSigned up! I don't use Ruby much, but I'm curious to see what I can steal from Ruby back to Perl. :) BTW, you should include links to the other 3 lists on all the websites. I see that statuscode.org and rubyweekly.com have it now, but when I checked the JS site earlier I couldn't find a link.
- petercooper 14y agoTechnically they're at https://cooperpress.com/ https://cooperpress.com/ but the whole idea of them collecting together as related newsletters hasn't quite gelled yet. It will take a little bit of work to do it right. BTW, there's a Perl Weekly as well which was inspired by the Ruby one. I don't run it but it's at http://perlweekly.com/ http://perlweekly.com/ and follows a similar formula to mine.
- ajtaylor 14y agoThis is a massively late reply, but I've been signed up for the perl weekly newsletter from its inception. Thank you for mentioning it though! I'm sure Gabor is grateful for the link. :)
- sarah2079 14y agoWhat's the best way to check your text to see if it will set off spam filters?
- petercooper 14y agoMailChimp has two methods. They have something called Inbox Inspector (powered by Litmus) that can both show you visuals of your e-mail in various clients but also has about 10 different spam filters to test against. They also have something called "Delivery Doctor" which does a quicker check but is more a safety valve than anything super useful. More generally, http://emailsuccess.com/ http://emailsuccess.com/ is a new service that you can send your e-mail to and it'll produce a report on all the problems, both technical and content-wise. I only just tried it for the first time and it gave a great report. There's also http://spamcheck.postmarkapp.com/ http://spamcheck.postmarkapp.com/ which is a JSON-accessible API to which you can send a mail and it'll run checks. Alternatively, you can just paste your message into the page.