You're absolutely right. Everyone harps on pie charts for being awful for element-to-element comparisons. This mainly stems from Tufte's work and experiments fr

You're absolutely right. Everyone harps on pie charts for being awful for element-to-element comparisons. This mainly stems from Tufte's work and experiments from Cleveland and McGill. However, in part-to-whole relationship tasks, pie charts can outperform bar charts, since in bar charts there is no true "whole". (In addition to Few's post, Kosara has more on this: http://eagereyes.org/criticism/in-defense-of-pie-charts http://eagereyes.org/criticism/in-defense-of-pie-charts)