3 ms·
It's not a legal incompatibility; FreeBSD has never shipped modified GPL software anyway to my knowledge (beyond things like patches to cleanly-separated ports
by ajross 14y ago
It's not a legal incompatibility; FreeBSD has never shipped modified GPL software anyway to my knowledge (beyond things like patches to cleanly-separated ports that can be distributed independently under the GPL).
It's a philosophy thing. The new provisions in the GPLv3 (principly the counter-tivoization requirements which prevent shipping integrated devices without reprogrammability) are seen as unacceptable to the FreeBSD team. So they simply ruled against the license, which means that recent versions of gcc are unusable and they need to look elsewhere for a modern compiler.
That's the official answer. The cynical answer is that they've always hated the FSF and their dependence on GNU software, and are finally jumping ship now that there's a non-copyleft compiler available for them to use.
- chongli 14y agoWhat kind of non-reprogrammable, integrated device would ship with a compiler?
- ajross 14y agoThey wouldn't. Most situations where GPL exclusions are enforced are still willing to include a modern gcc toolchain. But still, it's FreeBSD's distro, and they get to write the rules. And clang is a modern, attractive compiler. The feud may be dumb but the choice isn't.