3 ms·
did you write this with an LLM?
by r_lee 8mo ago
did you write this with an LLM?
- baq 8mo agoYou’re talking to someone’s clanker
- short_sells_poo 8mo agoI find the fact that people can't even be bothered to put their own thoughts into text and communicate via an LLM to be the most grotesque and dystopian aspect of this new AI era. It looks like we are going to have large numbers of people whose entire personality is projected via an AI rather than their own mind. Surely this will have an (likely deleterious) effect on people's emotional and social intelligence, no? People's language centers will atrophy because the AI does the heavy lifting of transforming their thoughts into text, and even worse, I'm not sure it'll be avoidable to have the AIs biases and start to leak into the text that people like this generate.
- baq 8mo agoThese aren't even their thoughts, it's just a bot let loose. I remember the first time I suspected someone using an LLM to answer on HN shortly after chatgpt's first release. In a few short years the tables turned and it's increasingly more difficult to read actual people's thoughts (and this has been predicted, and the predictions for the next few years are far worse).
- rcruzeiro 8mo agoThe hyphen instead of an em dash suggests a human (though one could simply replace em dashes with hyphens to make the text more “human-like”).
- petcat 8mo agoI've seen skills on the various skillz marketplaces that specifically instruct the LLM-generated text to replace emdashes with hyphens (or double-hyphens), and never to use the "it's not just <thing>, it's <other thing>" phrasing. Also to, intentionally introduce random innoccuous punctuation and speling errors.
- rcruzeiro 8mo agoI do wonder if the way people speak is starting to change because of LLMs. The “it’s not just” thing (I forgot the name for it) is something that used to be a giveaway, but I am now seeing more and more people use it IRL. Perhaps I am just more vigilant towards this specific sentence construction that I notice it more?
- AlecSchueler 8mo ago> The build was never the expensive part. The review, the edge cases, the ongoing maintenance But everything up to that hyphen was pure slop.
- rob 8mo agoNo it doesn't. That bot's comment and every comment under its profile 100% reads like an LLM to anybody that has seen enough of them. I already knew that one was a bot before even clicking the profile. See enough of them and the uncanny valley feeling immediately pops out. Even the ones that try to trick you by typing in all lowercase. An em-dash might have been a good indicator when LLMs were first introduced, but that shouldn't be used as a reliable indicator now. I'm more concerned that they keep fooling everybody on here to the point where people start questioning them and sticking up for them a lot of times.
- rob 8mo agoIt's a bot that posted a link to its "Runframe.io" website in the first couple of comments even though the account is ~4 days old. Dan said yesterday he was "restricting" Show HN to new accounts: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47300772 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47300772 I guess he meant that literally and new accounts can still post regular submissions: https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=advancespace https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=advancespace That doesn't make too much sense to me, or he hasn't actually implemented this yet.