3 ms·
If I translate Harry Potter to another language and change all the names, the resulting book clearly expresses the same ideas as the original.
by cubefox 8mo ago
If I translate Harry Potter to another language and change all the names, the resulting book clearly expresses the same ideas as the original.
- Marsymars 8mo agoYes, I agree. But "expresses the same idea" isn't the benchmark, "ideas expressed in the same way" is the benchmark. A translated work is "ideas expressed in the same way", a translation doesn't change that. See e.g. this question/top answer on stackexchange, it details pretty well how plot can't be copyrighted using Harry Potter as an example: https://writing.stackexchange.com/questions/3928/on-copyright-laws-and-plots https://writing.stackexchange.com/questions/3928/on-copyrigh...