5 ms·

> Consider Brazilian jiu-jitsu, which is certainly not safe but is very grounding What :D? I would say BJJ is an exceptionally safe martial art in that you can

> Consider Brazilian jiu-jitsu, which is certainly not safe but is very grounding What :D? I would say BJJ is an exceptionally safe martial art in that you can spar at 90-95% and not get hurt at all. Muay Thai or boxing sparring gives you regular bruises in comparison. At least that’s my experience.

Smaug123 7mo ago
Sure, for a martial art it's pretty safe - still in a different league from (say) bouldering or lifting, though! And in solo sports, you can almost completely set your own safety budget, whereas in martial arts there's a large irreducible lump of danger from "the other person lacks the control to do something safely". The only other person I know in person who does BJJ who I didn't meet at BJJ is a brown belt, and just got a four-month leg injury during a routine rolling session; I myself am only just over a five-month chest injury that was probably from someone very heavy simply throwing himself down on top of me when I didn't react in time (obviously he shouldn't have done that, but I can't control what other people do). Also how on earth are you managing not to get bruises at BJJ?! My legs are covered in them after pretty much every session just from sustained pressure.
- throw-qqqqq 7mo ago
  Wow okay. Maybe my club is “gentle”, I’ve never had a single injury from BJJ. I’ve had some from lifting weights. I see your point about solo sports. > Also how on earth are you managing not to get bruises at BJJ Oh I get “finger marks” on the arms for sure, but never got a black eye or a nosebleed from BJJ. I got that quite regularly from boxing and muay thai/MMA training.
  - Smaug123 7mo ago
    Fair enough, I got three black eyes within my first three months! The injury situation definitely gets better as you improve and when you train with more skilled people.

5 ms·

> Consider Brazilian jiu-jitsu, which is certainly not safe but is very grounding What :D? I would say BJJ is an exceptionally safe martial art in that you can

by throw-qqqqq 7mo ago

Smaug123 7mo ago
Sure, for a martial art it's pretty safe - still in a different league from (say) bouldering or lifting, though! And in solo sports, you can almost completely set your own safety budget, whereas in martial arts there's a large irreducible lump of danger from "the other person lacks the control to do something safely". The only other person I know in person who does BJJ who I didn't meet at BJJ is a brown belt, and just got a four-month leg injury during a routine rolling session; I myself am only just over a five-month chest injury that was probably from someone very heavy simply throwing himself down on top of me when I didn't react in time (obviously he shouldn't have done that, but I can't control what other people do). Also how on earth are you managing not to get bruises at BJJ?! My legs are covered in them after pretty much every session just from sustained pressure.
- throw-qqqqq 7mo ago
  Wow okay. Maybe my club is “gentle”, I’ve never had a single injury from BJJ. I’ve had some from lifting weights. I see your point about solo sports. > Also how on earth are you managing not to get bruises at BJJ Oh I get “finger marks” on the arms for sure, but never got a black eye or a nosebleed from BJJ. I got that quite regularly from boxing and muay thai/MMA training.
  - Smaug123 7mo ago
    Fair enough, I got three black eyes within my first three months! The injury situation definitely gets better as you improve and when you train with more skilled people.