3 ms·
I suspect water could be considered a special case, since it is so immediately necessary. What if, instead, we were talking about bread? Assuming that rich pe
by jlgreco 14y ago
I suspect water could be considered a special case, since it is so immediately necessary.
What if, instead, we were talking about bread? Assuming that rich people are fairly rare, then raising the price of bread high enough to be expensive but not so high that people cannot pull enough cash out of their pocket to pay for it, then the effect seems to me like it should be an approximation of a ration.
Clearly if Donald Trump gets to the store first and buys all the bread then nobody else would have any, but he could do that no matter the price. So long as the price is painful but feasible for anyone to afford, everything should work out more or less okay.
If the price is so high that nobody but Donald Trump can afford the bare minimum necessary, then there is certainly an issue, but I suspect raising prices that high would not be very effective.
- eru 14y agoEven water is not a special case. If you want to help people, give them extra cash. (There might be some justification for putting in some extra-windfall tax, though. I am not sure.)
- fr0sty 14y agoBut water is not really a special case, though. Tap water is nearly free and bottled water is >$1/gal. so the markup during a disaster is >100x.
- jlgreco 14y agoI only consider water a (potential) special case because it is one of the few things that, in the event that it really is unavailable, people will start dropping dead pretty quick. Bread, fuel, generators, etc... these are all things we can afford to be relatively dismissive of and just say that price caps are unneeded/bad. That may also be the case with water, but I don't feel comfortable saying that with my limited knowledge.
- fr0sty 14y agoFair enough. My point is we balk at a 200% increase in the price of gasoline but won't blink at a 100000% increase in the price of water. Also consider that @ $1 per 16oz bottle you are paying $8/gal for essentially tapwater that was bottled and driven in from out of state. But try to sell a gallon of gas for $5 and you are some kind of monster...