3 ms·
> maybe you shouldn't be lecturing "patriarchal backward societies"? It's perfectly fair to criticize modern Iran. Particularly when it comes to mis-allocating
by JumpCrisscross 8mo ago
> maybe you shouldn't be lecturing "patriarchal backward societies"?
It's perfectly fair to criticize modern Iran. Particularly when it comes to mis-allocating its skilled population and history.
Look at it from the perspective of fitness: if Iran had let these women study and work freely, and had invested its resources in growing its economy instead of a dud of a nuclear programme, might it–not Israel–be the region's hegemon?
> That's why developing countries have many STEM graduates
Number of scientists and engineers per capita is directly propotional to GDP per capita [1].
[1] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/GDP-per-capita-vs-number-of-scientists-and-engineers-per-million-people_fig2_358835259 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/GDP-per-capita-vs-number...
- lurkercodemnky 8mo ago> Number of scientists and engineers per capital is directly propotional to GDP per capital [1]. I meant the fraction. Do you have a plot of number of college gradutates on the same axes? I am sure it will be a steeper line.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> meant the fraction Decent hypothesis, but not substantiated. In 2020 the fraction of graduates who were STEM in China was 41%, Russia 37%, Germany 36%, Iran 33%, India 30%, and France 26% [1]. If we take the eleven countries in that article's GDP per capita, we find no statistically-significant relationship. [1] https://cset.georgetown.edu/article/the-global-distribution-of-stem-graduates-which-countries-lead-the-way/ https://cset.georgetown.edu/article/the-global-distribution-...
- lurkercodemnky 8mo agoThanks for correcting me -- the correlation is weaker than I would expect; though I will stand by my original commentary on the broader cultural issues. It would be interesting to contrast how much of them are STEM vs other "real world degrees" that get a job (accounting, hotel management or whatever) vs the "liberal arts" degrees. > The WEF report identified China, India, the United States, Russia, Iran, Indonesia, and Japan as the top seven STEM graduate-producing countries in the world. I think the US (and probably Germany too) is an outlier here because of the number of immigrants who arrive to study STEM degrees.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> think the US (and probably Germany too) is an outlier here because of the number of immigrants who arrive to study STEM degrees "About 30 percent of STEM degree holders living in the United States are immigrants" [1]. So sigificant as a fraction of immigrants. But not particularly meaningful to the trend. (I suspected the effect you hypothesise might exist within countries. But alas, higher-income households produce more STEM graduates [2].) [1] https://spectrum.ieee.org/stem-immigration-diversity-gaps#:~:text=30%25%20of%20STEM,the%20U.S.%20workforce. https://spectrum.ieee.org/stem-immigration-diversity-gaps#:~... [2] https://www.brookings.edu/articles/economic-inequalities-among-college-graduates-are-linked-to-college-major-choice/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/economic-inequalities-amo...
- nixon_why69 8mo agoIran did suspend the nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief. What happened to that deal again?
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> Iran did suspend the nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief. What happened to that deal again? It got torn up, which is a shame. That said, Tehran made the choices to (a) resume work on a nuclear weapon, (b) endorse Hamas and the October 7 attacks, (c) half ass their negotiations in Geneva and now (d) attack all of their neighbors. Those were major miscalculations. Layered on top of lots of little ones, e.g. ordering Hezbollah to blow its armory on symbolic rocket attacks. The JCPoA was a good deal. That doesn't make the current regime in Iran a smart actor.
- nixon_why69 8mo agoIts damned if you do, damned if you don't as long as Israel effectively dominates USA middle east policy. If they negotiate, the deal gets torn up at best, or they get attacked during negotiations at worst. If they maintain any sort of self-defense capability, that's seen as a threat to Israel. If they shoot back after we bomb 150 schoolgirls, they're the aggressor.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> damned if you do, damned if you don't as long as Israel effectively dominates USA middle east policy Sort of. Israel is the Middle East's regional hegemon. And America is a superpower. Picking both as national enemies was and remains a strategic blunder. > If they negotiate, the deal gets torn up at best, or they get attacked during negotiations at worst Again, the deal getting torn up is sad. But it's within the context of decades of antagonism towards powerful enemies. And nobody serious (other than Iran and Oman) seem to be claiming that Iran was open to giving up its nuclear ambitions in Geneva. > If they maintain any sort of self-defense capability, that's seen as a threat to Israel They literally chant death to Israel and fund the likes of Hamas and Hezbollah who want to eradicate it. (Weapons aren't inherently offensive or defensive, though they can tend to be more useful as one versus another. Ballistic missiles and nuclear bombs are closer to inherently offensive than inherently defensive.) > If they shoot back after we bomb 150 schoolgirls, they're the aggressor Nobody serious claims this. What they are doing by shooting back (and not surrendering) is continuing a losing cycle of violence. The only thing looser than America's theory of victory in this war is Iran's. Note: when Iran started shooting at Bahrain, Oman and Azerbaijan, it was the aggressor. Someone shooting at you doesn't mean carte blanche for blowing up non-belligerants.