4 ms·
What baffles me is that legitimate banks actually do hire incredibly shady-sounding third party outfits with names like "Cardmember Services" or "Card Services"
by marssaxman 14y ago
What baffles me is that legitimate banks actually do hire incredibly shady-sounding third party outfits with names like "Cardmember Services" or "Card Services" to handle credit card customer support. I once inadvertently dodged a genuine fraud-investigation call from my bank for weeks because it sounded like such an obvious scam. I don't understand why they don't draw the connection: scammers like this only work because the banks prepare the ground and make the call seem plausible.
- _delirium 14y agoThis practice screws up attempts to instill good online security habits in people, too. For example, Citibank's normal domains are citi.com and citibank.com, but then it sends email links to the super-fake-sounding accountonline.com, which is apparently where its actual ebanking services run (you get redirected there even if you login at citi.com). Even worse is when banks send out "cloaked" links, where the anchor text in the email shows their actual domain name, but the HREF target is n23uiahsf8das9fda.somethingelse.com.
- smsm42 14y agoThe n23uiahsf8das9fda.somethingelse.com is probably a third-party marketing tracking service. Since Citi would never allow marketing company run their tracking service on citi.com and since users won't be eager to click on n23uiahsf8das9fda.somethingelse.com link, they don't have much choice. On the question of how then legit marketing emails differ from phishing - I have no idea. I just never click on any of those links. If I need to do something on my bank's site, I just log in there directly and do it.
- tmhedberg 14y agoSince Citi would never allow marketing company run their tracking service on citi.com and since users won't be eager to click on n23uiahsf8das9fda.somethingelse.com link, they don't have much choice. They do have a choice. They could choose not to "track" their customers in this way.
- smsm42 14y agoWell, there's a legitimate marketing need to know how many people read your communication and how many were interested in what it says (as expressed by clicking on the link). After all, what's the point of communicating if nobody's listening or nobody cares?
- bediger4000 14y agoBank of America's Cardmember Services sounds very remarkably like "Rachel" or "Ann" in their approach on the phone. They won't (they say they can't) give out even the last 4 digits of the credit card number you're in trouble about. I too have dodged cards that I'm 49% certain were legitimate.
- antidoh 14y agoI got a survey from a company that Wells Fargo had hired, to see if my recent visit was satisfactory. It smelled legit, but my policy is to never respond to any email from my bank, I only communicate via my online account where I'm logged in, or by a call that I make. After that email I logged in (separately), and sent them a message saying the above. They responded quickly and automatically that yes, the 3rd party email was legit. Really, banks should just pretend that email was never invented.
- maxerickson 14y agoI got an email from Chase welcoming me to a new account. It was legit, but I hadn't opened an account. When I called in, the rep assured me it must be spam. Their abuse department emailed back to me verifying that they had sent it, but that no account was using my address anymore (it had the right DKIM, so I was a bit paranoid; looking back, I'm not sure what trouble it would case me).