5 ms·
There was some discussion about the $50K challenge last week, and I still don't think anything can happen without industry buy-in. It's mostly a policy and peop
by rhizome 14y ago
There was some discussion about the $50K challenge last week, and I still don't think anything can happen without industry buy-in. It's mostly a policy and people problem, and the only technical barrier I've been able to identify is that Caller ID can still be forged.
The whole situation bears an interesting contrast to the battles over anonymity on the Internet, where the telephone industry is trying to preserve the ability of their customers (telemarketers) to avoid detection.
- wpietri 14y agoI watched the webcast of the Robocall summit, and it was fascinating. It was clear that most of the telephone industry really hates phone spammers. An AT&T guy was saying that evil robocall outfits often forge the numbers of their existing customers, causing AT&T no end of headaches. Plus they get a ton of complaints from call receivers. I am sure that the major carriers would shut down phone spammers in a heartbeat if it were easy. Looks like the FTC now has the videos from the summit up on the web: http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/workshops/robocalls/ http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/workshops/robocalls/ Anybody seriously interested in the problem should check out the videos. There's a lot of good stuff in there about the technical issues. And there are some interesting technical solutions as well.
- smcguinness 14y agoI work at the lone automated calling company that represented the "industry " at FTC Robocall Summit(http://www.call-em-all.com http://www.call-em-all.com) and we are interested to see what solutions to this problem might come from this. We definitely would love to have a solution to where we could guarantee that no illegal calls are being made (Recent Blog Post: http://blog.call-em-all.com/3-reasons-we-are-excited-about-ftc-robocall-challenge/ http://blog.call-em-all.com/3-reasons-we-are-excited-about-f...). We have our own internal checks but something which can be implemented on a higher level would be great for us. The reality is that with the mix of old tech and new tech (read VOIP), tracking who is really making the call is very hard right now (timely and costly). Scammers knowingly break the law and unfortunately, a list of people saying don't call isn't going to stop them from scamming.
- rhizome 14y agoSo what amount above zero has the industry spent time and/or money in order to combat this problem, possibly to prevent their industry being killed by the bad companies? Does the legit part of the industry support unspoofable CID or any other technical restriction? Has your company publicly suggested any solutions?
- smcguinness 14y agoWe haven't proposed any solutions at this time, but we feel that a method in which we can utilize certificates or authentication is potentially the way in which is the least disruptive to the current infrastructure. But the infrastructure is the real problem. So many switches around the country are so old that hops through the network are very difficult to track and make any innovative technology solution hard to implement fully.
- jerf 14y agoI can't imagine how to solve the problem in an acceptable manner. Without something like certificates and encryption, some concept of identity, you're just not going to get anywhere, and I'm about fifteen miles into the "unacceptable" territory with that suggestion ("hey, guys, let's just rewrite the entire infrastructure from the very bottom!"). Your primitives are broken, any system built with them will be broken, and it's going to be more years before people are ready to even think about that.
- dhugiaskmak 14y agoCaller ID can still be forged Can anyone explain, or point to a resource that explains, why this is still the case in 2012? Is there some technical reason why this is the case, or do the phone companies make enough money off of scammers and robocallers that there's no incentive for them to fix it?
- pyre 14y agoI don't know the technical details, but I know this is trivial to do if you have Asterix setup to manage your POTS line.
- viraptor 14y agoActually you cannot spoof a number on your own pots line. At least not a standard end-user line, because that one's connected directly to your telco and is bound to one specific id. But if you have a trunk with your own control channels (so basically you and telco assume trust between each other and that you provide correct information) you can publish any numbers you want. It's quite popular with the internet telephony providers to relax the rules a bit. Basically some allow you to check the "I promise not to break the law, believe the data I send" and will accept any caller id you want. Since there's no way for one telco to verify other telco's source numbers, everyone else has to believe your caller id too.
- stephengillie 14y agoWhy can email headers still be spoofed?
- barrkel 14y agoBecause you don't have to pay for it.
- objclxt 14y ago> Can anyone explain, or point to a resource that explains, why this is still the case in 2012? This wikipedia article has a reasonable summary: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing