4 ms·
It's not just you. Ten years ago, There were a number of posts that I would disagree with but upvote anyway, because they made me think. I haven't seen that i
by AnimalMuppet 8mo ago
It's not just you.
Ten years ago, There were a number of posts that I would disagree with but upvote anyway, because they made me think. I haven't seen that in a long time. That kind of writing has disappeared.
What did that kind of writing look like? It stated a position, and gave reason to believe/accept that position, usually fairly concisely. Instead, now we see either just a bare statement of position (usually rather shrill), or appeal to authority.
The other thing we see much more is zealotry. Too many people are here to push an agenda, not to have a conversation. To steal a phrase from Patrick McClure, they're in "transmit-only mode". That's not a conversation even if you're in it. And if you're not in it, it's like walking into a war zone. Why would I want to go there? I'm not going to learn anything from either side. (OK, I might learn what their talking points are. But as a general rule, all sides' talking points are propaganda, and that's not worth listening to.)
I don't want to be in the middle of a propaganda war. I want reasonable conversations where people say interesting things. I used to find that here. I still do, sometimes, but far less often than I'd like.
- dalmo3 8mo ago> they're in "transmit-only mode" Being on HN for "only" about 6-7 years this is something I've always found quite bizarre, comparing to old forums. Discussions here die after roughly 16 hours. Because there's basically 4 entry points, front/new/past/ask, sorted by recent-ish, for millions of users, as opposed to themed sections and threads, everyone is incentivised to say what they want then move on. Comments are disposable. If you're not here every day religiously, you're not part of the discussion. Even if you are, but live in a timezone too distant from the US, by the time you get to read the most popular threads they're already obsolete. Hell, I don't even know if you, the person I'm replying to, will read this.