8 ms·
OpenBSD 5.2 released
- mrweasel 14y agoI love the simplicity and consistency of OpenBSD and everytime Ubuntu changes things like networking or startup script I want to switch out all our servers.
- protomyth 14y agoI have used OpenBSD for our servers for a while. It is super easy to setup (except for the brief fun of partitioning). I did switch to FreeBSD with ZFS for our samba server because of the partition size limits on OpenBSD.
- dmm 14y agoOpenBSD has had FFS2 since 4.2 in Nov 2007. FFS2 doesn't have any functional partition size limitations.
- papsosouid 14y agoDon't you still have to fsck those FFS2 partitions though? That becomes a real problem with very large filesystems. I have been out of the loop for like 7 years now, but I didn't think openbsd offered background fsck or journalling?
- protomyth 14y agofrom: http://www.openbsd.org/faq/faq14.html#LargeDrive http://www.openbsd.org/faq/faq14.html#LargeDrive --------------------------------------------- FFS vs. FFS2 Using FFS, OpenBSD supports an individual file system of up to 231-1, or 2,147,483,647 blocks, and as each block is 512 bytes, that's a tiny amount less than 1T. FFS2 is capable of much larger file systems, though other limits will be reached long before the file system limits will be reached. The boot/installation kernels only support FFS, not FFS2, so key system partitions (/, /usr, /var, /tmp) should not be FFS2, or severe maintenance problems can arise (there should be no reason for those partitions to be that large, anyway). For this reason, very large partitions should only be used for "non-system" partitions, for example, /home, /var/www/, /bigarray, etc. Note that not all controllers and drivers support large disks. For example, ami(4) has a limit of 2TB per logical volume. Always be aware of what was available when a controler or interface was manufactured, and don't just rely on "the connectors fit". Larger than 2TB disks The MBR system used on PCs only directly understands disks up to 2TB in size. fdisk(8) will typically report a disk size of the real size modulo 2TB, so your 2.7TB disk (sold as 3TB) will show as around 700GB in fdisk(8). This does not in any way hinder OpenBSD's ability to utilize larger disks, as the MBR is used only to bootstrap the OS, once the OS is running, the file systems are defined by the disklabel, which does not have a 2TB limit. To use a larger than 2TB disk, create an OpenBSD partition on the disk using fdisk, whatever size fdisk will let you. When you label the disk with disklabel(8), use the "b" option to set the OpenBSD boundaries (which defaulted to the size of the OpenBSD fdisk partition) to cover the entire disk. Now you can create your partitions as you wish. You must still respect the abilities of your BIOS, which will have the limitation of only understanding fdisk partitions, so your 'a' partition should be entirely within the fdisk-managed part of the disk, in addition to any BIOS limitations. --------------------------------------------- ZFS on FreeBSD was just a bit easier (for me) for our Samba PDC. Otherwise, I use OpenBSD.
- dmm 14y agoYes, you still have fsck them. It sucks.
- 4ad 14y agoUnfortunately not. The file system is the achilles' heel IMO.
- jnazario 14y agoi think the comment is about the archaic interface to the disk partitioning that openbsd uses in the installer. it confuses a lot of people. (former openbsd user, committer, and book author. no, i don't use it any more.)
- protomyth 14y agothe tool is a bit of a pain, but they have an autogen now. It really doesn't take me long, but it is a might bit confusing for new people.
- danielweber 14y agoThat's awesome. I'd been using a script that emitted all the "right answers" that I would then paste into the installer, mostly because of that.
- gnu8 14y agoI still don't understand this criticism of OpenBSD. I managed to use the installer to set up a fully partitioned OpenBSD system circa version 2.7 as a stoned highschool freshman. I think some people just have trouble using computer programs that require them to use a keyboard and read the documentation.
- jnazario 14y agomaybe. took me a few minutes but honestly it got in a number of peoples' ways the first time they saw openbsd's installed way back in the day, and they were no dummies. this is ~1999 mind you, i have no idea since about 2004 what openbsd has been like to install.
- meaty 14y agoSeriously it's not that hard.
- protomyth 14y agoTrue, it really isn't. It is just different and a little weird with commands like 'a a'. After the first time you know all the letters and what partitions to lay down.
- mrweasel 14y agoPartitioning in OpenBSD seems a lot simpler in OpenBSD compared to to FreeBSD, but that might just be me. Not a huge problem in any respect, you don't do it that often.
- ams6110 14y agoParticulary in the last few releases, the installer will do the partitioning for you, and do it reasonably well, an of course you can always override it.
- meaty 14y ago+1 for this. Until recently I had an OpenBSD machine which had an initial install date some time in 1997. I rarely had to change any configs when upgrading. Virtually painless. It was my home mail and db server and was running on an ancient Compaq Pentium Pro 200 with 128Mb of RAM. It got replaced with Debian due to a complete hardware failure and I already had a Debian CD lying around and couldn't be bothered to download an OpenBSD ISO.
- 3amOpsGuy 14y agonginx made it into the base install? That's another fairly significant, at least in my mind, vote of confidence for nginx.
- sarnowski 14y agoNginx now overtakes the default Apache 1 as the new httpd on OpenBSD. In the process of integrating it, OpenBSD already gave back patches for more security (like chroot support). I am very excited about that decision.
- Rovanion 14y agoAny specific reason why they used Apache 1 instead of Apache 2. I guess the obvious answer would be security but, in what way?
- chrissnell 14y agoOpenBSD has maintained their own hardened fork of Apache 1.x for years. I think that switching to 2.x would be a monumental effort for them and set them back quite a ways in terms of security. I think that nginx is a great move for OpenBSD.
- bonetruck 14y agoLast I knew, it was less about the effort, more about the license. And if you really need/want Apache 2, it's available in the ports tree and as a package. #> pkg_add apache-httpd
- tobiasu 14y agoThe Apache License 2.0 was not acceptable.
- dchest 14y agoWhat do they use to launch CGI? Did they write something custom?
- 14y ago
- dfc 14y agoActual Release Notes: http://www.openbsd.org/52.html http://www.openbsd.org/52.html Detailed Changelog: http://www.openbsd.org/plus52.html http://www.openbsd.org/plus52.html Lyrics for 5.2 Song "Aquarela do Linux": http://www.openbsd.org/lyrics.html#52 http://www.openbsd.org/lyrics.html#52
- voodoochilo 14y agobtw, love bsd but i think that the whole bsd familiy would gain immense traction within common users if there were a simpler (graphical) install process.
- throwaway54-762 14y agoOpenBSD finally got multi-core threading for userspace programs, huh? Welcome to 2003[0]. (And people say BSD is still alive.) [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_POSIX_Thread_Library https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Native_POSIX_Thread_Library
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tobiasu 14y agoLame attempt. Sun shipped M*N and 1:1 threading in Solaris 2.2 (1993). HP-UX followed in 1997. You're like a grammar Nazi unable to spell check his own posts.
- tytso 14y agoSure, 1:1 threading is in fact very old technology. Which makes it all the more astounding that the *BSD's haven't managed to get that technology implemented in their systems until now.
- tobiasu 14y agoFreeBSD, NetBSD, DragonFly and OpenBSD do not share the same kernel...
- throwaway54-762 14y agoBut they share a common, non-restrictive source license. OpenBSD could have imported 1:1 threading from FreeBSD, which added it earlier.
- zdw 14y agoOpenBSD has a huge anti-NIH sentiment. This can be a good thing, as bringing in code from others = bringing in their bugs as well. For example, rather than import the quite huge Intel formulated ACPI stack, they have one of the only non-Intel, non-Windows one out there. See also their reimplementations or forks of SSH, NTP, SMTP, BGP, etc. all done with a security focused mindset.
- webber89 14y agoI'm confused about something. OpenBSD is supposedly one of the most secure OSs in existence. So how is it possible that I cannot find any digital signatures for the downloadable ISOs? I've been searching all over Google and the mirrors, but nothing has come up. One person has suggested to just order a CD set from them, but I don't think that's a good solution. Having a secure verified copy of an OS should not require ordering a physical "gold master" set of discs to compare against. I mean, we have all the necessary crypto, and anyone can use it. Generate a GPG/PGP signature of the install ISO and that's it, you're done. A lot of people do it - Debian, Ubuntu, CentOS, all the big names... I mean seriously, even Arch Linux people do it, and until recently they didn't have package signing (now they do). I'm not complaining or criticising OpenBSD, I'm just wondering about their attitude to this aspect of security. I would be very happy if anyone could elaborate on the topic.
- papsosouid 14y ago>Generate a GPG/PGP signature of the install ISO and that's it, you're done. And you are getting that signature from the same place you are getting the binaries you are worried about being tampered with? They don't bother with security theatre because they aren't interested in being performing artists.
- tptacek 14y agoHuh? The signing key isn't kept online, unlike the binaries. You "remember" OpenBSD's key once, and can detect if someone tries to replace it with a different key. You thought you were being witty with this "performing artists" stuff, but really this is just florid ignorance.
- statictype 14y agoI think his point was that many people keep the signature in the same place as the actual binaries (most directories of builds of OSS I've seen have a tarball and a corresponding hash in the same listing). I'll admit I'm probably ignorant about this, but I don't see the point in that. If someone can compromise the binaries, they can also modify the signature files that are sitting in the exact same place.
- RexRollman 14y agoI wish this was installable on the new Chromebooks. I would LOVE to have OpenBSD installed on a 3G connected device.
- jrockway 14y agoInstalling all the GUI stuff from ports is kind of painful and mostly defeats the security guarantees anyway. OpenBSD is the perfect OS for a router. Everything else is like trying to put square pegs in round holes. Use FreeBSD on the desktop if you don't like Linux. But I find Debian to be the easiest-to-use desktop OS. (Unlike Ubuntu, they don't randomly ruin everything every 6 months, which is kind of nice. But it still stays up to date with changes that actually matter.)
- 4ad 14y ago> Unlike Ubuntu, they don't randomly ruin everything every 6 months, which is kind of nice They ruin everything every 2-3 years instead. Not sure which one is better.
- papsosouid 14y ago>Installing all the GUI stuff from ports is kind of painful and mostly defeats the security guarantees anyway There is no security guarantee, and installing KDE on openbsd gives you better security than installing it on linux. That argument makes no sense at all. >Everything else is like trying to put square pegs in round holes. That makes just as little sense. It is a generic unix-like OS. It runs generic unix-like software just like every other generic unix-like OS. Lots of people run openbsd for lots of things, and find it perfectly suitable. The only thing limiting it to routing is your imagination.