3 ms·
> what are you hoping to get out of this comment? Rando here. It gives a signal on the account’s other comments, as well as the value of the original comment (
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
> what are you hoping to get out of this comment?
Rando here. It gives a signal on the account’s other comments, as well as the value of the original comment (as a hypothesis, albeit a wrong one, versus blind raging).
- john_strinlai 9mo ago>"It gives a signal on the account's other comments," fair enough. i typically use karma as a rough proxy for that, especially when the user has a lot of it (like, in this case, where the poster is #17 on the leaderboard with 100,000+ karma). you dont get that much karma if you are consistently posting bad takes. >as well as the value of the original comment (as a hypothesis, albeit a wrong one, versus blind raging). i dont see, in this case anyways, how or why that distinction would matter or change anything (in this case specifically, what would you change or do differently if it was a hypothesis or simple "raging"?), but im probably just thinking about it incorrectly.
- TheBicPen 9mo ago> you dont get that much karma if you are consistently posting bad takes. I wonder how true that is. While this site doesn't have incentivize engagement-maximizing behaviour (posting ragebait) like some other sites do, I would imagine that simply posting more is the best way to accrue karma long-term.
- john_strinlai 9mo ago>I would imagine that simply posting more is the best way to accrue karma long-term. i definitely agree, which is why i use it as a rough proxy rather than ground truth, but i have my doubts that you can casually "post more" your way into the top 20 karma users of all time.
- tptacek 9mo agoI think a lot of people are overreading this and really all that's happened here is that I was out at a show last night and was really foggy when I woke up and asked a question clumsily. It happens!
- john_strinlai 9mo agoyeah, absolutely, i was not intending to start some big inquisition against you or anything. just like you were genuinely trying to understand where pjmlp was coming from, i was genuinely trying to understand what you would get out of an answer to your question (or, like, what the next reply could even be other than "ok, cool").
- tptacek 9mo agoOh, yeah, no, you're fine, this is on me.