5 ms·
They already said they are just going to put commercial airtraffic beacons on the drones. Of course then certain law enforcement types who feel they are above
by ck2 14y ago
They already said they are just going to put commercial airtraffic beacons on the drones.
Of course then certain law enforcement types who feel they are above any law (ie. most of them) will disconnect or disable them.
After they accidentally kill people it will be written off as the cost of enforcing the law, ala the nightmare of the TSA which everyone seems to put up with for some unknown reason.
Remember this phrase in a few years "drones, oh well what can you do, fact of life, they make me feel safer".
BTW, federal courts have already said it's legal for cops to put cameras on your property without a warrant, so a drone is just an extension of that.
Hopefully the video on the drones won't go accidentally missing after they raid the wrong home and kill your dog while they arrest you for resisting arrest.
- fartjetpack 14y agoThis type of fear mongering is crazy.
- _djo_ 14y agoThe FAA will never allow police departments to fly these things without air traffic transponders like ADS-B. Saying that the police will disconnect or disable them is a red herring. Again, how is a drone functionally different for law enforcement purposes to a helicopter with a surveillance turret? All the points you've made apply just as much to the latter platform as to the former.
- ck2 14y agoThe resource cost and limited availability for a helicopter ensures proper use. Drones will have no such natural restrictions - there will be dozens per city. Ever notice what happens when you give cops a tool - say for example a taser or pepper spray? It immediately gets put on the front line, used constantly to escalate things. To assume drones won't be abused is just willful ignorance.
- _djo_ 14y agoThe resource cost and limited availability constraints for helicopters that apply now will not necessarily apply in future, which means that the surveillance they provide will become far more persistent. I am not assuming drones won't be abused, in fact I assume they will be. See my other comments on this post for my views on the undesirability of persistent police surveillance. But as I pointed out with my reference to vehicle-mounted optronic masts, that surveillance will happen with or without drones, so the focus should be on the surveillance and not on the drones. As an aside, you failed to back up the claim that the 'commercial air traffic beacons' would be disabled.
- ck2 14y agoIt's not a claim but an educated guess - here's why: Commercial traffic beacons are extremely easy for hobbyists to listen in on and decode - and that's going to annoy cops because people are going to know when they are being watched, just like a weather-alert radio. There's one super easy way for them to "fix" that little problem, because they know they are untouchable. I'd guess future generations of top-shelf radar detectors might have traffic beacon decoders in them and then use a wifi network to your cellphone to download/share the IDs.
- _djo_ 14y agoNonetheless, there's no way the FAA would permit that to happen, especially not with the huge hurdles that users are having to jump through to get the FAA to permit the use of UAVs in civilian airspace. It's already dirt-simple to track ADS-B broadcasts along with smartphone apps that display the aggregated data.
- mindslight 14y agoSo police will demand that the FAA works to implement "secure ADS-B", using a secret key with tamper proof transponders. Police departments won't go rogue for very long, but disconnecting the tracking is a good metaphor to demonstrate the actual motives at play.
- jsight 14y agoI find parts of this comment to be unnecessarily paranoid. One of the major challenges for getting UAVs into the national airspace system is to integrate them with existing air traffic rules and systems. Beyond that, I don't see them physically being treated much differently from traditional police helicopters. I don't really see any evidence that police are disconnecting the transponders on those either. OTOH, I do have some concerns about the massive increase in numbers that these may bring, due to the decreased cost. It seems to open up some avenues for abuse.
- cynoclast 14y agoThink of the drones as Big Brother's eyes. Still unnecessarily paranoid? We already have Orwell's floating fortresses. The United States already has EIGHT. With three more under construction: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_carriers_of_the_United_States_Navy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_carriers_of_th... The cost of construction is $4,500,000,000. And that does not include their mandatory support fleet, nor how much it costs per day to keep operating. But people are talking about cutting NASA and PBS instead of the military budget. How about now? And neither of the political candidates from the dominant parties are even considering scaling back the War Department, excuse me, the "Department of Defense". Holy doublethink, Batman! 1984 has already happened because people were insufficiently paranoid. The only reason people think it could never happen here, to us, to the United States, is because it already has.
- jsymolon 14y agoAnother item is that the drones are very cheap to operate for long periods. Where a helicopter needs re-fueling and maintenance after x number of hours of flight, drones can fly for days(?).
- _djo_ 14y agoThe maintenance needs of drones are the same or higher than comparable manned aircraft, so they're subject to the same restrictions. What they have is long endurance, which is really measured in hours not days for the size of drones that police want to operate, but then that's little different to the endurance of police fixed-wing aircraft. In fact, in most cases drones are actually more expensive to buy and operate than fixed-wing surveillance aircraft, because their control systems are more sophisticated and require more maintenance, they need expensive ground stations which themselves require constant maintenance, they need dedicated comms links which also need maintenance and they can't fly in bad weather. In the short to medium term I fully expect the police fascination with drones to recede dramatically once they realise just how expensive they really are. Sticking a pilot and observer in a helicopter or fixed-wing plane with an electro-optical turret is often a lot cheaper.