8 ms·
History of Drug Use and Drug Users in the United States. http://www.a1b2c3.com/drugs/gen003.htm http://www.a1b2c3.com/drugs/gen003.htm Halfway down the page, th
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
History of Drug Use and Drug Users in the United States. http://www.a1b2c3.com/drugs/gen003.htm http://www.a1b2c3.com/drugs/gen003.htm Halfway down the page, the section is titled "Opiates: The New Nineteenth Century Habit" Also "Opium in the Civil War: Marching Through the Opium Fog" http://www.4thus.com/opium http://www.4thus.com/opium
Obviously opiates were around before then. Geesh. They were natural substances. The point of that section is about the social evolution of drugs.
And yes, Cocaine is not an opiate. It made a better example -- the available graphics were better -- so it was used. It was an editorial decision. It's an essay, not a science book.
The article is about the social parallels that led to drugs being severely restricted and how it compares/contrasts with modern entertainment technology taking more and more of our time and energy. Counter-arguments based against this thesis are welcome. (speaking as the author)
Your comment looks a bit like nit-picking, at least to me.
- kragen 18y agoIt was, sorry. I guess I got annoyed with the inaccuracies and didn't bother to read the main point. I'll try to give you some feedback that is more thoughtful after reading the article more tolerantly.
- kragen 18y agoWell, I've read through your essay somewhat more tolerantly. It seems to be a fairly vague assertion that "addictive" "technology" will have a deleterious effect on the lives of many people by virtue of taking more and more of their time and "energy" (I assume you mean attention), wound around with a lot of nicely-told stories, which (as I noted previously, and you acknowledge above) are retold there without any concern for accuracy. It seems that if you were interested in whether "addictive" "technology" would have a good or bad effect on people's lives, you could start by being more specific about the technology; there isn't much sensible that you can say about a category that encompasses the phonograph, Facebook, SMS, and a lot of etc. Then you could examine what effect it actually has on people's lives: does it make them more social or less social? Does it make them better informed or worse informed? Does it make them more or less likely to marry, or to stay married? Does it make them richer or poorer? Does it make their governments more or less accountable? You wouldn't necessarily have to go out and interview people yourself. The Pew Internet and American Life project has already done quite a bit of quantitative research along these lines. danah boyd has done a lot of peer-reviewed qualitative research along these lines. I haven't read it all but the things I have read don't really seem to support your thesis, although it is hard to tell because it is so vague. Nice stories and pictures, though, as long as nobody reads them and thinks they're true.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI'm not sure you understand how to critique an essay. There's a premise, a thesis, and examples. You can take issue with any of these. For instance, you can claim the examples don't support the thesis. Or you can say the thesis doesn't follow from the premise. Or you can claim the premise is incorrect. etc Instead you seem to make your comment personal "Nice stories and pictures, though, as long as nobody reads them and thinks they're true." You also assume the thesis "interested in whether addictive technology would have a good or bad effect" -- by definition addictive things have a deleterious effect. Then you run along the lines of the productive, good uses of technology, which was never in question and doesn't have an impact on the argument in question. Just to be clear: Premise: society has a difficult time dealing with technologies that have mixed effects and can lead to addictive behaviors. Especially when such conditions have not been seen before Thesis: Modern technology is evolving to actively take more and more of our time and make us happy, which to some degree is the same thing that drugs do (except drugs are inert while technology is ever-evolving) Examples: (of society having a hard time) drug prohibition in the late 19th century. (of technology actively competing for time) phonograph, television, video games, internet, MMORPGS Thanks for the comment. I appreciate your reading the essay this time instead of just commenting without reading it. I think we're done here.