7 ms·
Given Tablets but No Teachers, Ethiopian Children Teach Themselves
- thedrbrian 14y agoThat's one way of shifting all those unsold xooms
- no_more_death 14y agoThe Xoom is really solid, now that they've upgraded to Ice Cream Sandwich. I often tell people wanting a new laptop to just buy a Xoom. You can't get better bang for your buck. I have a Xoom and I totally love it to death. I love it as a tablet. It also makes an excellent desktop when you connect it to a monitor and bluetooth mouse / keyboard.
- hugoc 14y agoIndeed, at the rate companies are pushing and customers buying updated versions of gadgets a program like this is way better than dumping unsold or outdated tablets on a landfill.
- tokenadult 14y agoA friend shared this story (from a different link posted by Mashable) on Facebook, and I asked then how we really know how well the students are picking up what knowledge of what topic through this means. I see, going back to that link (the same text appears in your link), "In an interview after his talk, Negroponte said that while the early results are promising, reaching conclusions about whether children could learn to read this way would require more time. 'If it gets funded, it would need to continue for another a year and a half to two years to come to a conclusion that the scientific community would accept,' Negroponte said. 'We’d have to start with a new village and make a clean start.'" I also noted in the Facebook discussion thread that National Public Radio in the United States recently broadcast a report about One Laptop Per Child in remote villages in Peru, where ensuring access to the Internet or even electricity was a difficult problem for the schoolchildren attempting to use the laptops. I think further research is needed before we can be really sure that dropping off the laptops next to groups of children in the Third World will genuinely result in learning gains for the children in the usual school subjects. AFTER EDIT: An astute top-level comment below asks, Nobody's actually there, so who knows what's going on? And, indeed, I should have mentioned that to properly evaluate this project, you would not only need people in-country, seeing the children face to face, but you would have to make sure that the evaluators are familiar with the local language, as foreigners who visit another country without knowing the local language often miss many important details in their interactions with local people.
- aw3c2 14y agomultilevel aggregator spam for http://www.technologyreview.com/news/506466/given-tablets-but-no-teachers-ethiopian-children-teach-themselves/ http://www.technologyreview.com/news/506466/given-tablets-bu... edit: submission url updated, thanks
- mtgx 14y agoAnother similar story with Samsung's solar-powered mobile school: http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-57542623-1/samsung-solar-powered-school-shines-in-rural-south-africa/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-57542623-1/samsung-solar...
- droithomme 14y agoThey don't cite it, but their experiment was clearly inspired by the successes of the Hole in the Wall project in India which has been successful for many years. http://www.ted.com/talks/sugata_mitra_shows_how_kids_teach_themselves.html http://www.ted.com/talks/sugata_mitra_shows_how_kids_teach_t... http://www.hole-in-the-wall.com/Beginnings.html http://www.hole-in-the-wall.com/Beginnings.html http://www.ted.com/talks/sugata_mitra_the_child_driven_education.html http://www.ted.com/talks/sugata_mitra_the_child_driven_educa... http://www.edutopia.org/blog/self-organized-learning-sugata-mitra http://www.edutopia.org/blog/self-organized-learning-sugata-... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimally_invasive_education http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimally_invasive_education
- cjbprime 14y agoYes, Dr. Mitra was involved in this project too. See this comment by Ed McNierney on the Technology Review article: http://www.technologyreview.com/news/506466/given-tablets-but-no-teachers-ethiopian-children-teach-themselves/#lf_comment=41999900 http://www.technologyreview.com/news/506466/given-tablets-bu... Although OLPC initiated and has been managing this experiment, we haven't done it alone. Right from the beginning the project team has included Prof. Sugata Mitra of Newcastle University (http://www.ncl.ac.uk/ecls/staff/profile/sugata.mitra http://www.ncl.ac.uk/ecls/staff/profile/sugata.mitra) and Prof. Maryanne Wolf, director of the Tufts University Center for Reading and Language Research (http://ase.tufts.edu/crlr/team/wolf.htm http://ase.tufts.edu/crlr/team/wolf.htm).
- tomjen3 14y agoGo watch his speech. It is amazing.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 14y agoNobody's actually there, so who knows what's going on? Perhaps they learn by asking nearby adults to show them how? Even so, providing motivation is great.
- rickdale 14y agoCheck out the Amazon home page and you will see this related story: http://www.amazon.com/gp/feature.html/ref=amb_link_365909982_2?ie=UTF8&docId=1000843091&nav_sdd=aps&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_s=center-B1&pf_rd_r=0EVQ1S1GVHFFY4R17AVZ&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=1409802742&pf_rd_i=507846 http://www.amazon.com/gp/feature.html/ref=amb_link_365909982...
- gmoore 14y agoJust curious - is this actually 'hacking'? Seems that kids are just figure out how to used the installed software on their own....
- MichaelGG 14y ago> “The kids had completely customized the desktop—so every kids’ tablet looked different. We had installed software to prevent them from doing that,” For instance, they could have had one of those "lock" apps that requires a code for certain apps like system settings or app installation, and the kids killed the lock app via a task manager.
- myko 14y agoThe systems came pre-installed with software to prevent the kids from using the devices cameras and customizing their home screens. They found their way around these 'protections'.
- derleth 14y agoReminds me of Nicaraguan Sign Language: > Nicaraguan Sign Language (ISN; Spanish: Idioma de Señas de Nicaragua) is a sign language largely spontaneously developed by deaf children in a number of schools in western Nicaragua in the 1970s and 1980s. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaraguan_Sign_Language http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaraguan_Sign_Language Similar story, in some ways: In Nicaragua, the kids were taught a wholly deficient sign language that wasn't sufficient to the needs of actually using it as your mother tongue. They improved upon it by inventing grammar (not just words, but actual rules) and generally bringing it up to the standards required of a real language. Same kind of independent discovery and invention. In a linguistic sense, there appears to be a minimum complexity a language must have before it's worthwhile, and humans will spontaneously invent complexity that is missing. This also completely debunks the idea that grammar is dying: Humans can't exist without grammar. They can, however, exist without your preferred grammatical and stylistic conventions. (Grammar is observed, as part of a science; style is dictated, as part of fashion.) In a broader sense, humans desire a certain minimum level of complexity in their lives and will get bored and invent complexity if it is lacking. We aren't cattle.
- rmc 14y agoI think most sign languages started to take a turn for complexity when children started using them from when they were young,
- tow21 14y agoPersonal background: my wife works in development and has organized education projects in Ethiopia. The development community know all about this and are scathing of it. What the article doesn't mention is that: a) these tablets are vastly more expensive than just hiring teachers locally - by orders of magnitude. This is not a remotely scalable scheme, and frankly research budgets would be much better put to use working out how to distribute cheap teaching materials through existing education networks. b) More perniciously, the tablets educate in English or Amharic: not in the local language of the population in question, which these children would otherwise speak; their parents are often not fluent in either. The Ethiopian government (a dictatorship) loves this project, because it is actively trying to exterminate local languages and culture. This provides for them a route to do so.
- readme 14y agoWho needs native culture when you've got nyancat
- no_more_death 14y agoTrue, this is something of an experiment and may not be the optimal way to educate. At least, not yet. But Xoom tablets are $200 today and the price for tablets continues to fall. In a year or so, there will be e-readers on the market for $20 and many decent tablets will be available for $60 and less. The market is glutted with last-generation tablets and phablets. Something of this nature could provide a second life for these tablets. Xooms in particular are extremely durable and could service children for years. I would also keep in mind that the development community is probably biased toward hiring new teachers. Again, this just sounds like an experiment.
- vidarh 14y ago> In a year or so, there will be e-readers on the market for $20 and many decent tablets will be available for $60 and less. In volume (lots of 100,500,1000) this is already the case. You can find sellers dumping lots of 1000 of "outdated" tablets (mostly Android 2.2) for $5-$10 a piece. For smaller lots of more current generation: A Freescale IMX6Q quad core based 10.1" tablet with Android Jelly Bean (4.1), 1024x600 capacitive screen, 1GB RAM, 8GB flash: $32.50 a piece in lots of 200.... Current generation reasonable spec'ed 7" tablets ordered from China in lots of 1 start around $40-$50, with free shipping to large parts of the world...
- namank 14y agoSame in India. They left a village with a computer. Within 30 days, the previously illiterate students through it. It's important to note that they didn't master the computer but used it as a tool to master educational content.
- conroe64 14y agoTeachers with an ego trip, step back. Technology is taking over your job, too.
- polymatter 14y agogood teachers are worth their weight in unobtainium. poor teachers can be a huge negative to student learning.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThis is the future of education at the "bottom" in the 21st century. In several years (perhaps a few decades) solar powered tablet computers will be mass produced and so ubiquitous and inexpensive that they will flood the world. And one of their key uses will be education.
- kirian 14y agoAnybody else reminded of The Diamond Age: Or, A Young Lady's Illustrated Primer by Neal Stephenson?
- geori 14y agoI was reminded of that as well. And when I read through the comments, one of the experiments confirmed that yes, the Diamond Age actually gave them inspiration: >> Richard Smith >> Exactly. See http://cananian.livejournal.com/tag/nell http://cananian.livejournal.com/tag/nell The Diamond Age was an inspiration for some of the software we developed for the tablet.
- mherdeg 14y agoYup; fascinating to see how close / far that future is. To my mind the most acute observation Stephenson makes in that novel is that if you control the education of hundreds of millions of people in the third world, you also get tremendous political and social influence (the "Mouse Army"). This potential for power is something that I think is understood deeply by Salman Khan (who already has a devoted legion of followers whose lives he has changed) and by groups like Coursera and EdX. How much government funding is there in the educational startup space?
- joelhooks 14y agoWe use an autodidactic approach for our kids' home education. Working out really well so far with one at high school age on down to our 4th that is kindergarten aged.
- Dove 14y ago“I thought the kids would play with the boxes. Within four minutes, one kid not only opened the box, found the on- off switch … powered it up. Within five days, they were using 47 apps per child, per day. Within two weeks, they were singing ABC songs in the village, and within five months, they had hacked Android,” Negroponte said. I know we're not supposed to be snarky on this site and all, but I just can't help myself . . . Compromised by illiterate children. That's a secure OS!
- esrauch 14y agoI know you are just being snarky for fun, but it sounds like the kids set the desktop background when they thought they had disabled the option in settings. I doubt they did anything more than find a different option that lets you set the background through the browser or something.
- politician 14y agoIlliterate children from an illiterate village with no technology or anything remotely analogous not only figure out how to use a laptop, but customize it to their personal preferences. Let's give credit where credit is due. This is pretty amazing.
- HBKN2o1MhO 14y agoSomething irks me about whether or not they consulted any ethics guidelines for this project.
- Dove 14y agoThis is a particular area of interest for me, as well. I've experimented with an Android app designed to help my toddler learn to count (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.cdarrow.countingrobot https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.cdarrow.co...), and it really seems to work. In fact, I think the app can give him better feedback than I can because it doesn't get bored. I really do think a lot of things can be taught through games and unsupervised computer experiences. It's an area I'd like to explore further.
- yanokwa 14y agoInstead of the "promising results" maybe we can focus on the actual results of the randomized control trial that focused on educational outcomes of OLPC? That RCT conducted in 320 schools in Peru found: 1. The program dramatically increased access to computers 2. No evidence that the program increased learning in math or language 3. Some benefits on cognitive skills Source: http://blogs.iadb.org/desarrolloefectivo_en/2012/03/06/and-the-jury-is-back-one-laptop-per-child-is-not-enough http://blogs.iadb.org/desarrolloefectivo_en/2012/03/06/and-t....
- jagbolanos 14y agoThere is a difference in the sense that in Peru the laptops didn't have math or language software and in this case it did
- vidarh 14y agoThere's also another difference in that adding a laptop for a kid that is already in school without doing anything to take advantage of the laptop in the teaching is very different from making tablet available for a kid that is not only without access to school, but in a village where everyone is illiterate.
- aufreak3 14y agoThe hole in the wall project and this are certainly interesting. I can't help wonder what would happen if such tablets happened to be dropped in kids' hands in an urban literate area. Would they end up stuck playing angry birds and loitering on facebook?
- netcan 14y agoLooking at things from my comfortable vantage point a million miles away, I've always had a somewhat skeptical view of OLPC & similar efforts. (a) They built in the high risk, high capital cost aspect of developing pretty complicated devices. Big things like inventing their own laptop for radically different conditions & making a radical flavor of Linux when none of the existing flavors have had much success with nontechnical users. (b) They planned to go through Governments, the UN & other giant organizations. Simple & revolutionary technology coming about this way always seemed unlikely. This on the other hand is interesting. It may seem almost cruel, giving away scores of tablets at a price that could have built and staffed a school. OTOH, it's still not a huge amount of money (in the context of the OLPC budget), you can do it right now and it might work. If it works, then they can find ways to make it cheaper, cooperative with schools. etc.
- lrobb 14y ago“Some idiot in our organization or in the Media Lab had disabled the camera, and they figured out the camera, and had hacked Android.” Sounds like a great guy to work for. #sarcasm.
- b0rsuk 14y agoGiven Tablets and One Person with an Internet Connection, Children Discover Porn... or MMOs. Absence of teacher is no substitute for a teacher.
- mavhc 14y agothe software is the interesting part, http://cananian.livejournal.com/tag/nell http://cananian.livejournal.com/tag/nell http://nell-balloons.github.cscott.net/ http://nell-balloons.github.cscott.net/ to play