3 ms·
It sounds like SurfCast owns some pretty valuable intellectual property. Good for them! Of course, I wonder if they've been paying taxes on that property. If n
by kstrauser 14y ago
It sounds like SurfCast owns some pretty valuable intellectual property. Good for them!
Of course, I wonder if they've been paying taxes on that property. If not, then Maine Revenue Services might be interested in the fact that a local corporation has been evading their taxes.
On the other hand, if SurfCast is willing to attest to the Maine Revenue Service that their property has no value and should not be taxed, then I'd like to see Microsoft introduce that into court as evidence that SurfCast can't have suffered financial harm.
So which is it: is SurfCast filing a baseless lawsuit over valueless property or are they tax evaders?
- politician 14y agoAre you suggesting that IP owners owe (real estate) property taxes?
- jlgreco 14y agoThat would have some interesting consequences. Could I suddenly owe lots of taxes if I get a really great business idea that I think is worth a lot?
- mdonahoe 14y agoOnly if you patent it, granting you exclusive right to that idea.
- jlgreco 14y agoWhat if I copyright something? The text I am typing right now is under copyright by default, if I write something particularly brilliant here, can I expect to owe a good deal of taxes? If not, why not? Both are intellectual "property", and both clearly can have very real value. Why should unpublished books be any less taxable than un-implemented patents?
- kstrauser 14y agoGood question. Why not, indeed? If you're stating that a property has a cash value, such as by selling it or suing for that amount in real damages, then why shouldn't you have to pay taxes to the government that protects your right to copy it? Ideas aren't a naturally limited resource. It takes government intervention to declare that an idea is owned by one specific party. It seems only fair that the beneficiary of that intervention should be expected to support the government that makes it possible. By the way, I have no problem whatsoever with property rights. Although I think software patents are BS, if the government says they exist, then they exist. I just don't think it's fair that these non-practicing entities are paying their fair share to support the system that's netting them a paycheck. Why would I have to pay taxes on a rent house that I lease out, but they don't have to pay taxes on a patent that they lease out?
- jlgreco 14y agoI don't think that claiming damages implies a worth that should necessarily be taxable. If I am in an automobile accident and my spine is destroyed, I don't think anybody would suggest that since my spine is worth something to me that I should have been paying taxes on it. Paying taxes to ensure copyright protection would basically have the real world effect of pealing back default copyright. No works would be protected unless the creator went through the trouble of registering^Wpaying tax for that work. I don't think society would be better off without default copyright, so copyrighted works must remain effectively untaxed "properties". The problem I am having here is that you are conflating physical property with intellectual "property" just because you want to go after patent trolls. What you are proposing would not be limited in effect to the people you dislike though. If Bob Handyman were to invent a new type of, say, catalytic converter, in his garage, this would be of immense value to the automotive industry. This would therefore be an incredibly "valuable" patent. (And Bob would of course have to patent his new invention, unless he were a fool.) ..But under your proposal he would then be responsible for a massive tax that he could never dream of paying. And if he didn't pay this tax, automotive companies would then be free to use his invention without giving him anything? That is crazy.
- kstrauser 14y agoYes. It's essentially the same as real estate property in that the petitioner asks the government to state that a given more-or-less well defined area is granted to their exclusive use. In those circumstances, why wouldn't it be subject to taxes by the same government that is giving them the privilege of that sole use? I'm not asserting that IP owners currently owe property taxes. I am asserting that if they've asked the government to declare that the property is theirs, and they're asking the government to help defend their granted rights, then they should have to pay for the operation of that government. In short, if you want to have it both ways and receive the patent without paying taxes, fine. Just don't expect to use my taxpayer-supported court system to help you enforce your rights on it.
- slapshot 14y ago> I'm not asserting that IP owners currently owe property taxes. Except you did when you called them tax evaders.
- kstrauser 14y agoI presume you're familiar with conjecture, such that "if these hypothetical conditions were really true, then this would be a consequence". If patents were appropriately labelled as taxable property, then they would be tax evaders (unless they chose to value that property at $0.00).
- slapshot 14y agoAn interesting idea, but which Maine tax would apply? I'm not a Maine tax lawyer, but it looks like Maine has plenty of taxes, including a "Blueberry Tax" [1][2], but there doesn't appear to be a general assets tax. Any corporate income from licensing the patent would be taxed just the same as any other income. Maine's property tax appears to apply only to "real property" (land) and "tangible" personal property [3] ("tangible" property includes tractors, factory equipment, and other things you can pick up and hold --- patents and other IP are "intangible personal property.") If you think it's a capital asset subject to capital gains taxation, there's usually no tax on that until the gain is realized by sale. I don't know how patents are taxed in states with general ad valorem taxes, but Maine doesn't seem to be one of those states. [1] http://www.maine.gov/revenue/othertaxes/homepage.html http://www.maine.gov/revenue/othertaxes/homepage.html [2] http://www.mainelegislature.org/legis/statutes/36/title36ch0sec0.html http://www.mainelegislature.org/legis/statutes/36/title36ch0... [3] http://www.mainelegislature.org/legis/statutes/36/title36sec601.html http://www.mainelegislature.org/legis/statutes/36/title36sec...
- kstrauser 14y agoI would be willing to bet that cash-strapped legislatures might be interested in the idea. In fact, I plan to test idea by suggesting it to as many legislators as will listen.
- jlgreco 14y agoHow do you envision this system not placing undue burden on small inventors? This proposed change would take the patent system, from something that is supposed to promote the progress of science, and turn it completely on it's head. Any small inventor that dared patent something worth-while would be forced to either turn a massive profit on it before tax season, sell it before tax season, or risk it being stolen with few substantial penalties. Companies with deep pockets would have a field day taking advantage of inventors, they would ignore patents if the inventor declared it worth little for tax reasons. Or, if the inventor claimed the true value of the patent for taxes, they would buy out the inventor at cut-rate prices after taxes had ruined him.