7 ms·
Patent troll claims it invented the Windows 8 and Windows Phone “tiles”
- loumf 14y agoNever shipped a product, only started describing its tech as "tiles" in 2011. The word "tile" is used prominently in the patent.
- adrianonantua 14y agoI think we all agree that software patents just gotta go (specially the ones regarding UI). The real question is how to make that happen. Perhaps having a big player like Microsoft targeted by a troll will help.
- mrich 14y agoThey have been targeted many times, and paid quite some millions (billions?) over the years [1] [2]. The thing is, the big players like Microsoft all have large patent portfolios and are using them to keep up the oligopoly, they have no interest in abolishing the system. [1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/10/company-that-won-585m-from-microsoft-sues-apple-google/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/10/company-that-won-... [2] http://www.inquisitr.com/112717/microsoft-loses-i4i-patent-lawsuit-supreme-court-awards-290-million/ http://www.inquisitr.com/112717/microsoft-loses-i4i-patent-l...
- acluistic 14y agoI thought this was an article from The Onion.
- meaty 14y agoThere was a piece of DOS software in the late 80's called HyperPad which had tiles and used them to display status and launch applications. I can't find a single screenshot of it though unfortunately. I'm sure that is probably slightly "more prior" art.
- jotux 14y agohttp://www.atarimagazines.com/compute/issue115/406-1.jpg http://www.atarimagazines.com/compute/issue115/406-1.jpg
- swang 14y agoGee, waiting until Windows 8 releases before filing a lawsuit rather than before hand when the damage to your "company" could have been avoided. I wonder why that is... Seriously though, even disregarding any previous prior art, Microsoft already did stuff like this back in 98 when it was called Active Channel.
- tsycho 14y agoI am glad that a patent troll has directly attacked one of the software giants. Now hopefully Microsoft with its deep pockets and legal team can crush this troll.
- anonymfus 14y agoMicrosoft lose in such cases surprisingly often. Smart Tags in Office, onclick activation of plugins in IE...
- Dirlewanger 14y agoYup. Fuck, they lost their right to use "Metro" to describe their now "Modern-UI style." MASSIVE fuck up in my opinion. Microsoft should have raided the coffers to protect using that term.
- neurotech1 14y agoAgreed it was a massive SNAFU. Metro AG is a huge corp, based in Germany, that wasn't interested in licensing the 'Metro' trademark to MS in a settlement. I don't think any dollar amount was mentioned for continued use of Metro.
- thwarted 14y agoAnd wasn't click activation of plugins the change they had to make to avoid the Eolas patent on automatic execution of embedded content (going back to the 90s here)?
- neurotech1 14y agoThe Smart Tags lawsuit had some merit to it. They adopted the idea only after it was shown to them, and they refused to license it. The Eolas case was BS though. The patent was based on rewording the description of existing technology. If memory serves me correctly. Microsofts own OCX technology was prior art for the concept. Eolas claimed that by applying their concept to the web, it was novel and non-obvious.
- machrider 14y ago
- jakejake 14y agoIs it possible to sue a patent troll for time and legal fees if you win the original case? I know they are basically shell corporations, but it would be great to see these patent cases incurring some risk for the trolls.
- debacle 14y agoWhat is the risk to a company whose only asset is the patent which, should they fail to win their case, is probably useless anyway?
- rayiner 14y agoWelcome to the problem of limited liability corporations in general. You think it's irksome to win a judgment against a shell that has no assets in the patent troll context, imagine it in the environmental damage, shareholder fraud, etc, context.
- jlarocco 14y agoOn the other hand, imagine losing your house, car and savings because somebody finds a bug in your product and sues you...
- rayiner 14y agoPresumably if you're designing products that could cause that much damage if they malfunction, you can buy insurance against any resulting problems. Limited liability is a public subsidy for big business--it reduces the cost of inherently risky business activity by shifting those costs to the injured public rather than to the business owners. It's really arguable whether such incentives are needed and whether liability insurance wouldn't be a more appropriate measure.
- debacle 14y agoMost LLCs have assets and thus require liability insurance anyway. The tech sector is a small slice of the business space. Lets phrase it another way - you get a bad shipment of chocolate from a supplier, and your cookies send a handful of kids into allergic shock from the peanuts tainting the chocolate. One of them dies. You're likely going to be sued, and your liability insurance is likely a drop in the bucket (enough to cover your business assets). Do you still deserve to lose your house?
- TopTrix 14y agoI have now realized that anything can happen in the world of ...
- xo 14y agoStop the madness
- at-fates-hands 14y agoI know there has been a spat of these recently, but I always think about Robert Kearns and his lifelong battle against Ford for his intermittent windshield wiper patent. As much as we hate patent trolls, once and a while, there is an exception to rule which proves us all wrong.
- nitrogen 14y agoIs an intermittent windshield wiper really worthy of a 20-year monopoly?
- bduerst 14y agoDepends on how much you have invested in it.
- thirdtruck 14y agoAnd even then, I could spend the rest of my life on digging holes and refilling them. I might have invested countless hours in such effort, but that does not grant it any inherent value.
- bduerst 14y agoDid Ford try to infringe on your patent for hole digging?
- nitrogen 14y agoThe value of a patent is not in whether it is infringed, but whether it is both novel and non-obvious. Many software patents are neither, as evidenced by the recent spate of lawsuits over patents that largely amount to "regular expressions, but on a PHONE!!111."
- thirdtruck 14y agoIf my theoretical competitor wants to spend their time and resources on an inherently fruitless endeavor, all the more power to them.
- lemiffe 14y agoI am REALLY pissed off. Idiotic patent trolls. GAH
- SethMurphy 14y agoFor those interested in the actual patent here is a link: http://www.surfcast.com/images/pdfs/US6724403.pdf http://www.surfcast.com/images/pdfs/US6724403.pdf I particularly find the following quote interesting from the last line on the first page: "The present invention is intended to operate in a platform independent manner."
- illuminate 14y agoIn that they are interested in suing as many platform developers as possible?
- SethMurphy 14y agoNo, in that a claim can be so specific and so vague at the same time.
- kstrauser 14y agoIt sounds like SurfCast owns some pretty valuable intellectual property. Good for them! Of course, I wonder if they've been paying taxes on that property. If not, then Maine Revenue Services might be interested in the fact that a local corporation has been evading their taxes. On the other hand, if SurfCast is willing to attest to the Maine Revenue Service that their property has no value and should not be taxed, then I'd like to see Microsoft introduce that into court as evidence that SurfCast can't have suffered financial harm. So which is it: is SurfCast filing a baseless lawsuit over valueless property or are they tax evaders?
- politician 14y agoAre you suggesting that IP owners owe (real estate) property taxes?
- jlgreco 14y agoThat would have some interesting consequences. Could I suddenly owe lots of taxes if I get a really great business idea that I think is worth a lot?
- mdonahoe 14y agoOnly if you patent it, granting you exclusive right to that idea.
- jlgreco 14y agoWhat if I copyright something? The text I am typing right now is under copyright by default, if I write something particularly brilliant here, can I expect to owe a good deal of taxes? If not, why not? Both are intellectual "property", and both clearly can have very real value. Why should unpublished books be any less taxable than un-implemented patents?
- kstrauser 14y agoGood question. Why not, indeed? If you're stating that a property has a cash value, such as by selling it or suing for that amount in real damages, then why shouldn't you have to pay taxes to the government that protects your right to copy it? Ideas aren't a naturally limited resource. It takes government intervention to declare that an idea is owned by one specific party. It seems only fair that the beneficiary of that intervention should be expected to support the government that makes it possible. By the way, I have no problem whatsoever with property rights. Although I think software patents are BS, if the government says they exist, then they exist. I just don't think it's fair that these non-practicing entities are paying their fair share to support the system that's netting them a paycheck. Why would I have to pay taxes on a rent house that I lease out, but they don't have to pay taxes on a patent that they lease out?
- mdonahoe 14y agoAmusingly, they use screenshots from Windows Explorer in their patent drawings. See Fig. 1 in the first patent (pg 3) http://www.surfcast.com/images/pdfs/US6724403.pdf http://www.surfcast.com/images/pdfs/US6724403.pdf The pictures has some funny Drive names: Bambam, Fatbelly, Bigboss, Hulk.
- bitwize 14y agoPrior art: Windows 1.0. Microsoft even once gave a demo of how fast QuickBASIC compiled code was by writing a program that split the screen into quarters and showed different real-time data displays into each quarter. You could call that prior art, even if it weren't for Windows 1.