3 ms·
Idk why you’re getting downvoted, the U.S. is looking for a quick win if it can have it. One of the destructive streaks in the Iranian regime (and among its pro
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
Idk why you’re getting downvoted, the U.S. is looking for a quick win if it can have it. One of the destructive streaks in the Iranian regime (and among its proxies) is their glorification of martyrdom over pragmatism. It’s cost them historically and it’s costing them now.
- bluegatty 9mo ago"the U.S. is looking for a quick win if it can have it." ?? What is a 'quick win' ?? Serious question. - Ayatollah dead, next Ayatollah? - 10 years of civil war? - Installation of US-backed Shah, with no real power base, which will lead to ongoing insurrection, which is what led to ... Islamic Revolution ... because we already tried that? - Faux acquiescence at the negotiating table ... while they dig their HQs further under ground? What else? A quick win is possible, but one of the most narrow scenarios. It looks at the moment like everyone is losing, some worse than others.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> What is a 'quick win' ? An Iranian Delcy Rodriguez. Someone who waives a white flag, accepts Trump's terms and then gets left alone for the most part. Even if it's a bluff to buy time to rebuild, I'm not seeing the strategic rationale for refusing to negotiate. (I do see Iran's leaders being internally constrained to keep fighting. We saw a similar dynamic in Japan during WWII.)
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 9mo agoI'm not seeing the strategic rationale for refusing to negotiate. My understanding is that they were actively negotiating, or at least they thought they were. In the middle of the dialogue the lights went out. Essentially, Trump was not authorized by Netanyahu to win that negotiation. The outcome was foreordained.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> My understanding is that they were actively negotiating The only parties I’ve seen say this are Iran and Oman. Practically every other source, including non-English, concedes taking three weeks to come close to hashing out a framework isn’t serious. > Trump was not authorized by Netanyahu to win that negotiation This is nonsense. Netanyahu was pushing Trump. But if the Tehran team had capitulated, Trump would have taken the win. Hell, the capitalization could have been bullshit. > outcome was foreordained Of course it wasn’t. Ford wasn’t scrambled until weeks ago. If you can read translated European, Indian, Chinese and Arab reporting on this, I’d strongly suggest it. The English-language stuff has inherited America’s obsession with Israel. That’s obviously germane here. But it isn’t as controlling as we like to make it seem.
- CamperBob2 9mo agoHow can you read things like this: https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mg5ylq5phs2s https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3mg5ylq5phs2s ... and still carry water for Trump? Honest question, posed with all possible respect to a longtime HN user whom I am certain isn't a bot, an idiot, or a shill. Does Trump sound, to you, like a guy with a plan of his own, who can be trusted to execute that plan? Like someone who deserves the benefit of the doubt? We're told that "Biden gave everything to Ukraine and didn't bother to replace it," but "Fortunately, I rebuilt the military in my first term," and now we have a "virtually unlimited supply, stocked and ready to WIN BIG!!!" Where do you, personally, draw the line? What could he say to convince you that he isn't acting in our country's interests, or even his own?
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> and still carry water for Trump? I’m doing nothing of the sort. I’m carrying water for the evidence. Iran was not negotiating in good faith regarding giving up their nuclear program. Israel was encouraging but not boxing in American decision making. Witkoff and Kushner were (a) genuinely trying to strike a deal and (b) against kinetics when they started. These are each supported by the preponderance of evidence, far more than their inverses. > Where do you, personally, draw the line? Where the evidence does. If that winds up being pro- or anti- whatever party, I’ll look at that second. Facts aren’t partisan.