4 ms·
As an outsider, why is this a credible institution over the jury and judge?
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
As an outsider, why is this a credible institution over the jury and judge?
- docdeek 9mo agoI can't speak to the institution but the only public statements on their website relate to this particular trial. It could be this is the first ever trial they have monitored in this way; it might also be a group that will only ever monitor this one trial.
- amarant 9mo agoIn other words Greenpeace is trying to muddy the waters and hide their guilt by painting themselves as the victims of injustice? How very original..
- some_random 9mo agoYeah we're dealing with a mud fight between two highly resourced adversaries who are practiced in bullshit underhanded tactics and influence operations.
- indubioprorubik 9mo agoNah, its one source of funding. The oil giants pump there money in bonkers oppossition- one Greta Thunberg glueing herself to a public street does more damage to that cause then the whole of counter propaganda ever could. And it prevents the debate about resonable measures like free public transport.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo agoI guess I was expecting a Matt Levine-style breakdown of why the trial was run improperly and why an appellate court would be expected to strike it down. Instead we have vague statements that could have come from an elected’s staff.
- mistrial9 9mo agorelated topic -- "Judge shopping" refers to the practice of litigants strategically filing lawsuits in court districts or divisions where they are likely to be assigned to a judge sympathetic to their cause, often exploiting structural quirks in the judiciary
- dmix 9mo agoMost state courts randomly assign you a judge so it's not that simple, in some cases you can target certain districts in certain states where there are less judges (like the Texas patent judge). This is a trial in North Dakota because that's where the protests happened. I doubt they had many options in a single jurisdiction. The fallback for this stuff is of course a circuit court appeal.
- singleshot_ 9mo agoCare to explain how a circuit court might come to hear an appeal out of a state court of general jurisdiction?
- bilbo0s 9mo agoWell, let's not get into this left-right thing because that could go back and forth forever. Especially in the current environment. eg - "As an outsider, why is [the jury and judge] a credible institution over the monitors?" We should all just give the legal experts time to look over the records of what happened, and assess why. From there, a consensus will likely emerge as to what happened during and before the trial. And the justice or injustice of the matter will present itself. But you can't have a judge say one thing and some other single expert say another, and from those pieces of information decide anything of an authoritative nature. Our institutions just don't have that type of credibility any longer. This is the consequence of credibility crises for any society's steward classes. It was a long slide getting here, decades actually. But I think we are firmly now at the point of the "credibility collapse" portion of the "credibility crisis".
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- quotz 9mo agoBecause sometimes corruption happens.
- some_random 9mo agoThey're a bunch of lifetime activists who spun up an authoritative sounding NGO that has done literally nothing else, but yeah muh corruption.
- toomuchtodo 9mo agoOil companies have been suppressing climate change research for decades to keep cooking the earth for profits. Is that not corruption? I suppose if you are economically exposed to these gains, don’t believe in climate change, and/or won’t be here for the bad times from this, the facts may not matter to your mental model. The facts remain that climate change is real and oil companies are doing their best to extract every bit of profit they can until we’re off of oil, regardless of the negative trajectories and outcomes from this. https://www.ucs.org/resources/decades-deceit https://www.ucs.org/resources/decades-deceit
- some_random 9mo agoOil companies have done worse than that, but we're not talking about them right now we're talking about Trial Monitors Dot Org, the real authoritative source on this trial that has done literally nothing else.
- switchbak 9mo agoYou know, it's possible for these oil companies to have done all this bad stuff, and for Greenpeace to be a pretty shitty organization. And for the person to have a different mindset than all the strawman assumptions you just made.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- 9mo ago
- harimau777 9mo agoIn America, just about anything is more cridble than our "justice" system.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- sbuttgereit 9mo agoBased on their "Meet the Committee" page, they look a bit more like they have a dog in this fight beyond simply adjudicating the case. https://www.trialmonitors.org/meet-the-committee https://www.trialmonitors.org/meet-the-committee Plenty of accomplished people there, but as a group "unbiased observers" isn't the first phrase that comes to mind.
- philwelch 9mo agoSurely you can’t be suggesting that a committee of environmental activists might be biased in favor of Greenpeace? https://www.trialmonitors.org/meet-the-committee https://www.trialmonitors.org/meet-the-committee