3 ms·
Many times I've been asked by online American friends why I held such strong opinions about American politics. After all, I'm a Swiss living in London, so I don
by swombat 18y ago
Many times I've been asked by online American friends why I held such strong opinions about American politics. After all, I'm a Swiss living in London, so I don't think there was much identity involved. I don't consider myself American, and I certainly don't consider myself "democrat" or "republican". Those concepts are not a part of my identity.
However, I have very much cared about US politics because of its impact on the world around me. The last 8 years of Bush decadence have, as far as I can tell, made the world a worse place to live in, made it more dangerous both to people and ideas, and I see that as having a direct impact on the range of things that I can do.
In contrast, religion does indeed have little impact on what happens in much of Europe, and though I have had many arguments with religious friends (I'm an atheist), they were all constructive and enjoyable to both parties - not emotional flash-fires. This contradicts pg's "identity theory", in that my "religious beliefs" (or lack thereof) are certainly a part of my identity - they have a direct impact on how I choose to look at life and behave within it - but because other people's religion has little impact on me, there is no need to get heated about it.
I think Matt's hit this spot on. It's impact, not identity, that makes the discussions so heated.
Now, with that in mind, why do people feel the need to have heated arguments about, say, OS's...? Well, there, I think there is also an element of impact. Most OS flame wars that I've seen were between Windows and something else. There's a good element of impact there, because most non-Windows people have perceived Microsoft as a threat, hell-bent on exterminating all competition, so imho that could have driven much of the flame wars between OS's. What about languages? Again, there is an element of impact there. I've rarely seen a heated flame war between Java and .NET, because they don't threaten each other. But between Rails and, say, PHP - well, it's a different kettle of fish, because many Rails programmers have had to maintain spaghetti PHP applications in the past and so these have a personal impact on them.
This is a very interesting discussion, for sure. I'm curious what other perspectives people have on this.