3 ms·
> Looking for a single reason is very hollywood, enough interests aligned Correct. But interests need to be animated to have power. Who was arguing that this s
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
> Looking for a single reason is very hollywood, enough interests aligned
Correct. But interests need to be animated to have power. Who was arguing that this should be a priority, and a priority now, who is familiar in the White House?
> The assertion that the US is a democracy is nisguided. It will be downgraded by vdem this month to an electoral autocracy
This is nonsense.
> halt all impeachment trials
False. Senate Rule 193 sets time limits on debate for impeachment trials [1].
[1] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CDOC-117sdoc1/pdf/CDOC-117sdoc1.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CDOC-117sdoc1/pdf/CDOC-1...
- galangalalgol 9mo agoYou seem to have a singular villain ready to point at. I do not see it. The president reportedly thinks whatever the last person to speak said. So are you proposing a mastermind or simply a catalyst? As far as vdem goes, Lindberg has recently as much as confirmed they will down grade the us below democracy status.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> Lindberg has recently as much as confirmed they will down grade the us below democracy status I mean, that's interesting from a political theoretical perspective. And if you want to put sacred meaning into it, sure. I'm not sure most people would take a decade-old Swedish institute as a harbinger of whether or not America is a demoracy too seriously (versus other sources, to be clear).
- galangalalgol 9mo agoYou are right that unless the eiu or others follow suit it would be less meaningful. On the senate conviction, my point is that only 33 senators need to oppose a conviction to stop it. Or to let a veto stand. The smallest states get the same number of senators. If those votes were evenly split, and it was the typical 50-60% turnout. It would actually only be 2-3% of the populace needed. I do want to know who the bad guy is though.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> unless the eiu or others follow suit it would be less meaningful Even if they do it's book reports. > On the senate conviction, my point is that only 33 senators need to oppose a conviction to stop it Yes. The bar is high for removing an elected executive. That's not a sign of not being a democracy.
- galangalalgol 9mo agoEven taking into account that not all small states are right leaning, and theoretically there could be 100% turnout, we are still talking about a situation wjere it takes over 90% agreement among the population to remove a president. That isn't a high bar, that is a complete lack of accountability. It isn't just removal. The whole system was designed by people so terrified of the tyranny of the majority that they neglected to forsee such uneven populations leading to the potential for a tyranny of the minority. The lack of any meaningful consensus for judiciary appointments is also a solid sign of competitive authoritarianism. But we are getting far off on a tangent. I really am intrigued that I'm missing some actor or faction. Will you get downvoted for the hypothesis? Or have you already replied with it and it got shadow blocked?
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> wjere it takes over 90% agreement among the population to remove a president ...no? Majority of the House and two thirds of Senators doesn't require 90%. Nixon still had way more than 10% of support in the country when his removal from office was imminent. > have you already replied with it and it got shadow blocked? I don't think I've written anything that got shadow blocked for many years.
- galangalalgol 9mo agoMy best guess at who you mean is Netanyahu or Miller? I still think the SA benefits so greatly we should assume their advocacy.
- 9mo ago