4 ms·
> find those people who make your policy decisions Genuine question: who put Iran in their policy portfolio?
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
> find those people who make your policy decisions
Genuine question: who put Iran in their policy portfolio?
- gizajob 9mo agoMake a genuine guess…
- JumpCrisscross 9mo agoI was hoping someone serious (versus the everything is AIPAC nutters) had put thought into it. Rubio and Walz have been Iran hawks. But I’m not yet convinced they were unilateral. Instead, it looks like a Rice-Powell alignment of vague interests with enough groupthink that dissenters weren't in the room.
- hightrix 9mo ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> it literally is the AIPAC AIPAC isn't a person. Who is the person who convinced the President to order these strikes? It could be someone at AIPAC. There is no evidence for that, I suspect, because it's highly unlikely.
- mixmastamyk 9mo agoLindsey Graham and cronies. Tons of evidence, he travels to israel every month or so.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> Lindsey Graham and cronies Lindsey Graham doesn't have that kind of pull in the White House. I'm not saying he didn't influence someone with it. But he isn't the power player.
- mixmastamyk 9mo agoI wouldn’t think so, but obviously things have changed significantly in the last few months.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> obviously things have changed significantly in the last few months Not to the point that Graham makes such calls. (Hint: the person will be in the Situation Room with Trump.)
- mixmastamyk 9mo agoThe "convincers" and those directing military operations are obviously different folks. I'd follow the money from Graham and Trump backward. Oh, and by the way you don't have to quote single sentences from my responses when they consist of one or two sentences. ;-)
- galangalalgol 9mo agoThe current Israeli government obviously has a great deal of influence in the US government. That much is not conspiracy theory. The evangelicals involved in project 2025 have a very real interest in middle eastern conflict from an ideological standpoint. If you want a cynical follow the money villain look no farther than Al Saud and friends. Also, this weakens Russia and further restricts oil reaching China from anywhere. Every oil feed reaching China over water is at this point being curtailed. Looking for a single reason is very hollywood, enough interests aligned. The US president hasn't required a new war resolution since Afghanistan. They each keep stretching it farther and farther. It cannot be rescinded without a veto-proof majority. If there was a veto proof majority willing to stand up to the executive, a conviction and removal would have already occurred. The assertion that the US is a democracy is nisguided. It will be downgraded by vdem this month to an electoral autocracy. It is also worth noting that it only takes senators receiving the votes of <7% of the total population to filibuster all legislation, prevent overriding any vetos, and halt all impeachment trials. The fact it has looked like a democracy for so long is astounding.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> Looking for a single reason is very hollywood, enough interests aligned Correct. But interests need to be animated to have power. Who was arguing that this should be a priority, and a priority now, who is familiar in the White House? > The assertion that the US is a democracy is nisguided. It will be downgraded by vdem this month to an electoral autocracy This is nonsense. > halt all impeachment trials False. Senate Rule 193 sets time limits on debate for impeachment trials [1]. [1] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CDOC-117sdoc1/pdf/CDOC-117sdoc1.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CDOC-117sdoc1/pdf/CDOC-1...
- galangalalgol 9mo agoYou seem to have a singular villain ready to point at. I do not see it. The president reportedly thinks whatever the last person to speak said. So are you proposing a mastermind or simply a catalyst? As far as vdem goes, Lindberg has recently as much as confirmed they will down grade the us below democracy status.
- nostrademons 9mo agoThe rumor I heard was that high-level Pentagon generals had subtly suggested that Trump target Iran. The reason was to distract his attention from Greenland. Logic goes that if you have a reality TV star who built his brand on being a tough guy in the White House, it's far better that he attack a theocratic dictatorship that funds a host of terrorist organizations and whose country is already on the verge of collapse than a NATO ally and fellow democracy that didn't do anything to us.
- qup 9mo agoHe's been talking about Iran since 2011
- underlipton 9mo agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7s5pT3Rris https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7s5pT3Rris
- byproxy 9mo agoFrom where did you hear this rumor?
- nostrademons 9mo agoWas a news article from a reputable source (Reuters or PBS?), around the time of the Greenland flap in early January, but Google Search now sucks and the results are all polluted with news articles from the strikes today so I wasn't able to find it again.
- ThagH 9mo agoIndeed, the permanent bureaucracies and think tanks have advised all administrations: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7864/j.ctt6wpgvg https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7864/j.ctt6wpgvg This is bipartisan. The long term goals were to start with Libya, Iraq, Syria and then Iran. The latter two required Russia to be tied up in another conflict. They don't explicitly put Iran in their portfolio because for Reality TV it is better to be a peace lover. Now, undoubtedly the Democrats will pretend to complain, but Schumer and Pelosi want this, too. [I am expanding on your comment, not trying to contradict anything.]
- oldnetguy 9mo agoI see this as Trump going after governments that were close to Russia and China. Which is why he is going after Iran, Venezuela and Cuba. Also there are many countries in the middle east that we are friends with which would be happy if Iran falls.
- bell-cot 9mo ago> ...would be happy if Iran falls. Literally, perhaps true...at least initially. But: - Take a look at how poorly the fall of the Iraqi gov't in 2003 actually worked out for the U.S. and its regional friends. - Iran has 92 million people, very deep issues with being able to support that large a population, and very long borders. If things really went to crap there, it could produce tens of millions of desperate refugees.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> take a look at how poorly the fall of the Iraqi gov't in 2003 actually worked out This is an immensely risky operation. But part of the reason for Iraq being a shitshow was De-Ba'athification. You don't need to clean house to effect regime change. My guess would be we're hoping someone in the IRGC disappears Khamenei and a few senior commanders and then makes a call to Geneva.
- arw0n 9mo agoThis is assuming a coherent national security strategy, which is unlikely. We know a lot of generals disagree with the attack on Iran, and none of the geopolitical experts I trust think it is a good idea, be they conservative, realist, liberal, leftist or something else. There's a number of reasons this is happening now that I think are more plausible than American interest: - Saudis want Iran weak as they are primary geopolitical rivals. There are deep ties between the Saudi dynasty and the Trump dynasty. Without Iranian support, the Houthis will have a much tougher time. (Although they should not be underestimated regardless. They are not an Iranian proxy, but an ally, and field one of the strongest armies in the whole region.) - Israel wants Iran weak, and pro-zionism is a strong wedge in American politics. Again, there's also a lot of personal business interests involved. Iranian allies and proxies are the chief causes of grief for Israel's expansionist agenda, and a very credible threat to their national security. - This war conveniently moves the headlines away from a faltering economy, the Epstein files, and ICE overreach. There's probably hope that it will improve chances with the 'war president bonus' in the mid-terms. It could also be a convenient cover for and excuse to increase rigging in the elections. Expecting positive regime change after bombing a school full of little girls is... naive. This is not how you turn an enemy into a friend.
- jacquesm 9mo agoAIPAC is a thing... And now of course you're going to label me an AIPAC nutter, but in this particular case I think the evidence is fairly plain given the collaboration between the two countries on this. If Israel had done this by their lonesome or if the US had not involved Israel then you could make the case that they reached this point independently, right now it looks to me as if collusion is a 100% certainty and that the US is executing a foreign policy that will not benefit it but that will benefit Israel. It also makes me wonder whether this will end up as a Venzuela re-run where the top names change but everything else remains the same, just with US companies the beneficiaries of the oil, which is, besides policy the main driver behind these things anyway.
- heraldgeezer 9mo ago[flagged]
- frmersdog 9mo agoWell, we're certainly not collaborating with West Africa to bomb France. Not even the Philippines, Taiwan, and Uyghur and Hong Kong dissidents to bomb China. I mean, it could just be the evangelicals hoping to start a holy war that heralds the End of Days. And now that I type that out, I have to agree with your implicit position that it's definitely the more rational catalyst.
- jacquesm 9mo agoYou've been uncritically supportive of Israel in plenty of other threads on HN already so I'm not sure if your exaggeration of my comment should even be taken serious. Israel has a massive lobbying effort in the United States and that's not exactly news, on top of that there have been many documented pieces of interaction between Trump and Nethanyahu that seem to be evidence that Trump is doing a lot of things to please Israel, besides that they are actively collaborating on these attacks.
- heraldgeezer 9mo ago[flagged]
- Braxton1980 9mo agoThe voters