4 ms·
> Attributes that distinguish WW3 from previous world wars were IIRC You're missing the commonalities, what defined world wars: the full might of industrial ec
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
> Attributes that distinguish WW3 from previous world wars were IIRC
You're missing the commonalities, what defined world wars: the full might of industrial economies being dedicated to military campaigns.
World War II's theatres' were incoherent–the Axis interests in e.g. China and the Pacific had basically zero stragegic overlap with Europe and North Africa. (The only parties having to consider a unified theatre being the USSR and USA.) But the entire economic surplus of Europe, Asia and North America was basically dedicated to (or extracted towards) making things that were reasonably expected to be destroyed within the year.
- ethbr1 9mo agolooks at Russia's economy
- bobthepanda 9mo agothe "world" part of world war is also important. pretty much every economy involved was at least undergoing heavy handed rationing of goods, encouraging people to donate scrap metal, etc. Russians are not under food rationing yet.
- testdelacc1 9mo agoHere’s hoping they feel the war in Moscow and St Petersburg this year. A bit of rationing wouldn’t hurt them. More than the war, they’ll feel the peace. More than 100% of the economic growth of the last few years has gone into war production, meaning the civilian economy has shrunk. When the weapons factories are scaled back the economy is going to hurt something fierce. Even Muscovites will notice. This is why Putin can’t stop fighting. When the fighting stops Russia will face a reckoning. Better to postpone that day hoping that Europe runs out of steam.
- braincat31415 9mo agoww2 history begs to differ. The USSR has seen massive economic growth in 1946-1950s.
- simonh 9mo agoThat was a very different situation. The USSR was still catching up in industrialisation, and despite its huge losses still had vast reserves of labour in the countryside to tap. It was much more like the process of industrialisation in China that’s seen huge growth there over the last generation. Russia has already industrialised so it doesn’t have a catch-up growth opportunity in the same way. They are much more labour and resource constrained these days.
- braincat31415 9mo ago"still had vast reserves of labour in the countryside to tap" There was a huge shortage of labor in the countryside after the war.
- KPGv2 9mo agoThis labor was, pre-war, a bunch of poor, uneducated serfs (basically slaves). But leading up to WWII, they were transformed into educated, literate, laborers. Also the USSR had invested leading up to WW2 in agriculture outside Ukraine (since the Nazis controlled it). So while there was less labor, they were far more productive labor thanks to post-revolution, post-WWI measures
- braincat31415 9mo agoSo one person says, USSR was still catching up in industrialisation, the other one says, they were far more productive... what is it? The whole argument still feels far-fetched at the very least.
- lII1lIlI11ll 9mo ago> This labor was, pre-war, a bunch of poor, uneducated serfs (basically slaves). This is incorrect. Serfdom in Russian empire was abolished in 1861, long before the revolution. Peasant literacy rates, while still poor, had been gradually improving after that. > Also the USSR had invested leading up to WW2 in agriculture outside Ukraine (since the Nazis controlled it). What? Not only Ukraine was controlled by Bolsheviks at the start of WW2 its territories have also been extended with parts of Poland and Romania annexed by Soviets between the start of WW2 and the so-called "Great Patriotic" phase of the war.
- iso1631 9mo agoBritish Empire was heavily involved in Europe, North Africa and South-East Asia. Events in India had great consequences on Europe The USSR on the other hand barely had any involvement in the Pacific theatre, entering in August 1945.
- AnimalMuppet 9mo agoThe USSR had to carefully keep enough land forces in the Pacific region to deter a Japanese land invasion. (Remember that Japan controlled Manchukuo.) So, yes, the USSR had little involvement, and they had to be very careful to keep it from becoming an active front. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battles_of_Khalkhin_Gol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battles_of_Khalkhin_Gol (that was in 1939).
- dwd 9mo agoFear of the USSR entering the war against them was also a deciding factor in Japan's surrender. More so than the atomic bombs.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- jjfoooo4 9mo ago> But the entire economic surplus of Europe, Asia and North America was basically dedicated to (or extracted towards) making things that were reasonably expected to be destroyed within the year. This is no longer necessary to inflict the catastrophic destruction we're really referring to when talking about a hypothetical WWIII
- datsci_est_2015 9mo agoTheir argument is that, by definition, it can’t be a world war unless all economic surplus is dedicated to war purposes. I tend to agree with both of you, and that by extension, we will never see another world war unless society as we know it collapses significantly.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- jbboehr 9mo agoI don't think you are using standard definitions. > A world war is an international conflict that involves most or all of the world's major powers. > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_war > Total war is a type of warfare that mobilizes the totality of national resources to sustain war production, blurring the line between military and civilian activities and legitimate attacks on civilian targets as part of a war without restriction as to the combatants, territory or objectives involved. > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_war It does so happen that the two world wars were also total wars.
- datsci_est_2015 9mo agoWell first off I think we were speaking colloquially. But secondly, I think unless certain powers cross some threshold where they’re undeniably engaging “total war”, they’ll use wishy-washy terms like “special military operation” (Russia) or “armed conflict”. That’s also not to mention proxy wars (Syria) or even non-violent acts of aggression against sovereignty (Hong Kong). In other words, “total war” is a necessary ingredient for a “world war” these days or you’ll have all of these countries claiming they’re not actually at war.