5 ms·
Wow...I can't remember being this blown away by a search development since...I don't know when (being able to Google mathematical formulas is pretty amazing, bu
by danso 14y ago
Wow...I can't remember being this blown away by a search development since...I don't know when (being able to Google mathematical formulas is pretty amazing, but not as everyday-useful)...
I asked both Google and Siri, “How much damage did Hurricane Sandy do?”
Google heard it as “How much damage did Hurricane Sandy too?” and returned with official Hurricane Sandy emergency info and latest news stories literally as I stopped talking.
Siri took nearly five seconds to register my question as “How much damage did hurricane you do” and responded with hockey league standings for the Hurricanes team.
And the execution of Google's product is more stylish than Apple's...given Google's lead in collecting voice data, nevermind their lead in search technology and algorithms...how can Apple hope to even compete in voice search except by forcing Siri on iOS users?
*edit: Here's a screenshot comparison:
http://danwin.com/words/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/google-vs-siri-sandy.png http://danwin.com/words/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/google-vs...
- hornbaker 14y agoI tried the same test. Google got the translation right first try, and the first result, which returned in less than a second, had "over $20 billion in damage" visible. Siri took ~8 seconds to return "Ok sports fans, the Hurricanes appear to be in first place in the Southeast right now" followed by AHL team standings. Apple has a lot of catching up to do here. They're going to have to start translating client-side, which Google has obviously figured out, and they're going to need a data source as rich as Google. It think the first part will get done at some point, but how will they match Google on the data side?
- cloudwalking 14y agoThey won't. They can't. It's important to remember that Apple is a hardware company with a software habit. Google is a software company. While I understand why Apple hates Google so much, I think breaking with Google is a mistake. Nobody can beat Google at software; Apple hardware + Google software is a wonderful combination, and if the two companies worked together we'd really see the apex of user experience.
- czhiddy 14y agoThe hardware/software split is too simplistic a view. The companies have their various strengths and weaknesses. For example, the graphics stack on iOS embarrasses Android's. It took how many years and how many hardware advances before flagship Android got scrolling as smooth as the first iPhone? Another example: Google released Renderscript in early 2011 (http://android-developers.blogspot.com/2011/02/introducing-renderscript.html http://android-developers.blogspot.com/2011/02/introducing-r...) only to deprecate it a little over a year later (https://developer.android.com/about/versions/android-4.1.html#Renderscript https://developer.android.com/about/versions/android-4.1.htm...). We can cherry pick examples all day long, but the bottom line is that each company excels at certain things. It's interesting how Samsung is basically stuck to Google at this point. I'm sure they'd love to switch to their own Bada or Android fork and capture more of the profit, but Samsung is absolutely abysmal at software.
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoGoogle is a data company and its design approach is data-driven; whereas Apple is a design company and its data approach is design-driven.
- spullara 14y agoIf only Google hadn't stuck it to them with Android ALL users would be better off. We'd have Google apps on iPhone hardware and UIs. It hurts to think about how much better it could be.
- cheald 14y agoIt's incredibly myopic to argue that the mobile landscape would be better off without Android providing a compelling competitive force.
- commandar 14y agoWe'd be better off in a world with no Android, where RIM still hasn't shipped a modern smartphone OS, and with a Windows Mobile/Phone environment that has broken application compatibility twice in the past two years?
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoInteresting that Apple - the device company - opted to do the recognition on the server and Google - the cloud company - chose to do it on the device.
- pkulak 14y agoI'm pretty sure Google is doing most of it on the server as well. Why do you think otherwise?
- DominikR 14y agoBecause you can do a local search offline. (at least on the Android version)
- onemoreanimal 14y agoOn Android, voice recognition is built-in to the OS. On iPhone, they don't have this luxury and the app is relatively small, so I'm thinking almost all of it is done on the server. A link to a Google source verifying this would be nice though.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoThe sheer speed of it. Maybe I'm wrong but I'm getting near instant voice recognition off a poor wifi connection linking to a slow internet connection.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoThey do both, so it'll work totally offline, but it's better online and can utilise the two together seamlessly.
- StavrosK 14y agoIt is, indeed, on the server (at least on my Galaxy Nexus). It won't work if you turn the connection off. Maybe they have some sort of hybrid, though, because it does have offline recognition that can call people without a net connection.
- rustynails77 14y agoThis was exactly my experience. My iPhone struggled to understand me at times (albeit only 2 out of 20 times) - but the Nexus S (a fairly old phone) understood me 20 out of 20 times. It really whipped the pants off Apple - I was quite surprised. To see so many posts above say that Google Voice was far below par of Apple was a surprise to me. Note: I haven't tested IOS6 yet, so things may be different.
- onemoreanimal 14y agoHow do we know that Google is translating client-side? Is there a link to a Google source to verify this? The app is only 10 MB, so it would be very impressive if they actually accomplished this, but I can't find verification anywhere.
- lachlanj 14y agoFor current events, Google will always have the lead here. They have the full weight of all the searches that are being performed around the globe at any second.