3 ms·
Worst case they will lose a few comments and some karma. I think the worse case is actually substantially worse -- call it an identity escalation attack. I th
by patio11 18y ago
Worst case they will lose a few comments and some karma.
I think the worse case is actually substantially worse -- call it an identity escalation attack. I think a huge number of Internet users are vulnerable to it:
a) Use any means you please to compromise the password on a low-security site, such as HN.
b) Use the same login credentials at other low-security sites, such as Facebook and Twitter. These compromises are valuable in their own right, but what you are really looking for is the email address.
c) After you have their email address, compromise it using variations on the same password you already know.
d) You can now read their email. Search for "statement", and identify which bank they bank with. Go to bank and try logging in with their email and password. That probably just worked. If not, click "lost password", supply email address and their security question (you have their Facebook already or can in seconds, how hard will it be to find their mother's maiden name or middle school?), and enjoy.
e) For added fun, look for other high-value accounts whose security is premised on the email user being authorized, such as brokerages (a tough target due to strong institutional controls, like banks) and GoDaddy (a successful compromise would cost me FAR more than what I have in my bank account).
The worst part? You can automate large portions of this attack (given a list of usernames and password, writing a script to try them at a dozen or a hundred popular services is child's play) and outsource the rest right up until the "compromise bank account" portion.