4 ms·
> making or supporting comparisons based on incomplete knowledge Comparisons needn't be limited to one event or one atrocity. > Russia calls all the West "Naz
by ignoramous 8mo ago
> making or supporting comparisons based on incomplete knowledge
Comparisons needn't be limited to one event or one atrocity.
> Russia calls all the West "Nazis", should we just listen to them?
All? I doubt that. Even then, unfortunately for you, like Leibowitz, Kahneman (perhaps world's foremost & finest thinker) isn't alive either to explain himself.
- throwaway3060 8mo ago> Comparisons needn't be limited to one event or one atrocity. You can't openly call a group Nazis and then claim you only meant in terms of their behavior on the western front. It misses the whole point, not to mention it makes people forget what the Nazis did. > All? I doubt that. Yes, at times all.
- ignoramous 8mo ago> You can't openly call a group Nazis and then claim you only meant in terms of their behavior on the western front Me? As before, in this context, your argument is with Kanheman & Leibowitz. And possibly other prominent Israelis (present or past) who may hold such views.
- throwaway3060 8mo agoThen Liebowitz was wrong (and Kanheman, though it seems to me he wasn't trying to make a reasoned argument in that interview). And thus, those who cite him would presumably do better to read other, more historical sources.