3 ms·
In today's marketplace, there's very little about the ARM instruction set that makes it better suited for low power applications. Yes, it is a saner instructio
by bryanlarsen 14y ago
In today's marketplace, there's very little about the ARM instruction set that makes it better suited for low power applications. Yes, it is a saner instruction set than x86, requiring less silicon to convert into uOPs, but the difference is trivial in 2012.
The difference between x86 and ARM on the power/performance curve is almost purely due to design choices and trade offs. So why not create a new low-power x86 core instead of a new ARM core?
The only way this makes sense to me is for this to be a stepping stone into the mobile market. The mobile market is definitely stepping up the power/performance curve, and AMD's experience with GPUs may be a distinct advantage for them in the mobile market in the future.
- caf 14y agoNote that this announcement is based on a processor license, not an architecture license - AMD are using an ARM design off the shelf, not designing their own new ARM core.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoYup, I had read the article the other way around. Designing their own ARM core didn't make much sense to me. Using someone else's does.
- stonemetal 14y agoConsidering AMD is now a fabless chip design shop, not doing any design work doesn't make sense to me. What is their value add? They may as well have ordered a shipment of completed processors from Nvidia.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoIn this case, the value add is the processor interconnect fabric. In other cases, it will be their GPU.
- jbarham 14y ago> In today's marketplace, there's very little about the ARM instruction set that makes it better suited for low power applications. So it's just a coincidence that ARM powers 95%+ of smartphones? I think not. Given Intel's advantage in fabs and process technology I think it's all the more striking that to date they have failed at developing chips to effectively compete with ARM in the mobile market. x86 is an ugly and inefficient ISA compared to ARM but it didn't matter as long as users plugged their computers into the wall.
- bryanlarsen 14y ago"So it's just a coincidence that ARM powers 95%+ of smartphones? I think not." ARM designs have been optimized for low power. x86 designs have been optimized for high speed. It has little to do with the architecture and lots to do with the design. Nobody has ever tried to design a sub 1 watt x86 design. Nobody has ever tried to design a 100 watt ARM. Only very recently have we had anything that's close to comparable. Medfield has a similar power rating to high performance ARM designs, and similar performance.
- yvdriess 14y agoIntel tried the low-power x86 with the Atom, didn't really go anywhere. It's true that scaling up an ARM will be equally problematic. But, the point is that they use ARM because they don't want to push the power envelope.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoAtom didn't go anywhere because it was a 10W processor benchmarked against 100W processors when running performance tests, but compared to 1W processors when doing battery tests.
- hfs 14y agoNot to mention that a lot of ARM chips outperformed it anyway, right?