5 ms·
May be the second time I've found a genuinely insightful piece by Gruber. Skeuomorphic design was a nod to my non-computer using father in the 90s. It no more r
by bane 14y ago
May be the second time I've found a genuinely insightful piece by Gruber. Skeuomorphic design was a nod to my non-computer using father in the 90s. It no more represents useful metaphors for interfaces than steam engines represent a good way to build cars.
iOS is stagnant, reviews of recent Apple designed skeuo-heavy apps bemone the lack of functionality -- while noting what must be hundreds of hours of graphics work -- and not seeing that the tradeoff is worth it. With finite development hours the general public realizes that they'd rather get shit done then look really great sorta getting some things done.
So who makes the money at Apple? It's two people, Cook and Ive -- supply chain and product design. Let's give turning the entire device design over to a holistic human interface designer a try instead of running hardware and software as two disjoint efforts.
Between Siri and the maps screw up the decision made itself.
- Steko 14y ago"iOS is stagnant" iOS only seems stagnant because they don't have to trumpet every year about how they've finally gotten rid of ui lag or completely overhauled the system appearance. These are points in it's favor to most people.
- ChrisClark 14y agoI'd say it is stagnant because when you look at the design, it just feels old. I'm not much of a designer, I can't tell you why, but it just seems dated. Perhaps it is the skeuomorphism, maybe something else, but something is off about it now.
- qq66 14y agoIt feels old because it hasn't changed in 5 years, but I personally appreciate that. All of the original mechanics make perfect sense, and the new mechanics (such as app folders and multitasking) have been introduced in a way that minimizes interference with the existing look and feel. As someone who uses a lot of music production apps that can't talk to each other, I do wish there was something like a filesystem, but I also want it to be introduced in a way that does not change the basic look and feel of the device. What's amazing is that an original iPhone and iPhone 5 look and feel largely identical for basic uses, even though the latter is a far more capable device. That's a testament to the strength of the original design.
- angryasian 14y ago>All of the original mechanics make perfect sense this is the same thing thats spouted by fans of the iphone. We don't need a smaller ipad 10" is the perfect size. We don't need a bigger phone screen, this fits the perfect size for all hands. All this is said till Apple actually does it.
- qq66 14y agoI'm not saying that there's no room for improvement. Frankly, I want a smaller iPhone, a pressure-sensitive display, and a physical button to take a picture that's always active. What I don't want is for any of these improvements to fundamentally change the way the phone UX works (i.e. moving to a menu system or something). The only "bad" design elements, in my opinion, were notifications and Siri. They fixed notifications but I had to turn Siri off.
- gurkendoktor 14y ago> It feels old because it hasn't changed in 5 years, but I personally appreciate that. And I think Apple is betting on a "conservative" majority that does not want change for the sake of change (I'm certainly part of it) - just observe how similar all the iPhones look, or all the laptops, displays... The only exception I can think of are the cheaper iPods.
- bluesaunders 14y agoAnd that's because they are cheap enough to buy on impulse, and/or to make an affordable gift for the holiday season that is clearly the hottest and newest available.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- brudgers 14y agoIt's more or less Symbian or Palm Pilot with touch. What was groundbreaking in terms of interface was the method of input not the way the OS was designed. It's still just icons and a pointer.
- Steko 14y agoI don't see much stagnation: (1) Maps is probably the biggest thing they've done since the original phone's launch; (2) they are moving more and more of the interaction to voice every year; (3) they are moving more and more of the users' data to the cloud every year.
- chc 14y agoIt was pretty clear that he was talking about visual design and interaction. None of the things you list here are in that domain. One is a new app, one is a voice UI and one is an Internet-based storage service.
- Steko 14y ago"None of the things you list here are in that domain. One is a new app ..." Since the very sentence I was responding too was about apps ("iOS is stagnant, reviews of recent Apple designed skeuo-heavy apps bemone the lack of functionality") I fail to see how talking about app functionality is some huge leap of logic on my part. "he was talking about visual design and interaction. None of the things you list here are in that domain" How is voice control not about interaction?
- killahpriest 14y agoPerhaps it should be read as "visual design and [visual] interaction."
- bennyg 14y agoYou think voice integration isn't interaction? That's literally a form of interaction with the device that was not there in iOS 1.
- chc 14y agoI feel pretty sure there was a "visual" in there you're ignoring.
- snowwrestler 14y agoI see a lot of this type of sentiment here on HN, and I think it is because we are people who build technology and therefore study technology obsessively. Anything that stays the same for 5 years will feel ancient. Most people, though, just want to use technology to accomplish other things. For them, radical interface changes reduce rather than improve value.
- hellmans 14y agoYour out of place defensive reply (I assume you work on the Apple team?) notwithstanding, iOS is absolutely stagnant. They're in the unenviable position of being lauded and popular because of the simplicity of design, but that strangleholds them into a limited ability to change and improve.
- bane 14y agoI suppose, iOS hit a higher quality product much earlier than Android. But to me it feels like an evolutionary dead-end. Sure they aren't fixing any problems, but they sure aren't really adding anything to make my life better. Or another evolutionary analogy: crocodiles have more or less been around forever -- they don't have to trumpet about solving calorie intake problems, or overheating in the summer, but it took mammals to invent fire and get to the moon. Saying more or less "iOS is fine" is also saying "we're not interested in pushing the envelope anymore".
- Steko 14y agoIt'd help me if you gave examples what you think iOS could be doing that's it not. The big ticket feature that iOS didn't have 60 days ago was built in turn by turn maps. Since they added that with 6.0 I guess I'm wondering what else you're pining for? A weather widget? NFC? Fjords?
- bane 14y agoI'm principally talking about look and feel. iOS looks and operates great, let's get that out of the way. But it's essentially the same core design that was laid out in 2007 + Androidish notifications + multitasking-lite. At a glance can the average user tell the difference between iOS 2 or 3 and 6? I acknowledge that that's not necessarily an entirely worthy goal in and of itself, but keeping a design focused product fresh does have its merits. Here's iOS 1 and 5 side by side http://pocketnow.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/ios1ios5.png http://pocketnow.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/ios1ios5.png Other than the obvious lack of a wallpaper I'm not really sure that there's been any fundamental work on improving the user interaction and look & feel of the thing in 5 years. I find it unbelievable that there's nothing that could be done better and that iOS was launched with perfect interaction design, fully formed from the heads of the designers, or perfect visual design, reverently propagated to the modern day and on into the future. Is this really the penultimate in volume slider design? There's no more work to be done here? http://www.uiparade.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/clean-ios-volume-slider-ui-design.jpg http://www.uiparade.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/clean-ios... I think this recent shakeup is Apple signaling that it's time to evolve again and that excites me much more than the last 2 or 3 product launches have. If anybody can put out a new way of pushing electrons around and making it "just work" it's going to be Apple and I want to see what they come up with.
- twism 14y agoObviously you haven't spent any significant amount of time using Google Now.
- zachinglis 14y agoiOS has barely changed in UI since it's inception. That's not a good thing. No one designs the perfect design the fist time, nor the 100th time, nor ever. The goals and targets change and the design evolves. There has been no evolvement. Sure, there's more precise releases than it's competitors, but that doesn't negate the fact that Windows has a more functional-looking (whether or not it is, is an entirely different matter) phone. The Notification centre was a step in the right direction, but people are wanting data quicker more and more, and the notificiations aren't great for every app. After all, a big reason people cite for going for Android is customisation. When the iPhone was released it was the absolute leader in mobile iOS among other things. Now it's a solid competer but it lacks the originality it once had.
- alxp 14y agoThe original MacOS design wasn't 'perfect' but it was very, very good. And Apple messed with it at their peril. They gave themselves a similar bar with iOS 1.0 - they know a lot about interaction design, and how to make a UI feel smooth and intuitive, and they aren't going to scrap all of those good decisions for the sake of looking new. By contrast Microsoft have some interesting design ideas but they abandon them in the very next major version in favour of trying something else, which is jarring for users and doesn't inspire trust.
- zachinglis 14y agoI'm not saying scrap, I'm saying iterate. (Wrote a wee bit about it here: http://zachinglis.com/2012/why-the-apple-reshuffle-could-prove-cooks-worth/ http://zachinglis.com/2012/why-the-apple-reshuffle-could-pro...)
- alxp 14y agoThe original MacOS design wasn't 'perfect' but it was very, very good. And Apple messed with it at their peril. They gave themselves a similar bar with iOS 1.0 - they know a lot about interaction design, and how to make a UI feel smooth and intuitive, and they aren't going to scrap all of those good decisions for the sake of looking new. By contrast Microsoft have some interesting design ideas but they abandon them in the very next major version in favour of trying something else, which is jarring for users and doesn't inspire trust.
- Zev 14y agoiOS only seems stagnant because they don't have to trumpet every year about how they've finally gotten rid of ui lag.. You might not notice it, but, there is an eighth-of-a-second-ish delay between when you tap on most buttons and when the action occurs. An obvious (to me) example is when you tap on the back button on a navigation controller, and it takes a split second before anything happens.. It isn't much, but it is consistent across the OS, and it drives me crazy.
- alxp 14y agoI believe this is deliberate - giving a user a sense of what they did which results in the next action. This is especially important if the button you've pressed takes you to another screen.
- josephlord 14y agoIs that from touch down or touch up? Most controls respond on the release because holding down or dragging is a different action in many (maybe most) cases. I'm not perceiving much lag between touch up and animation start on the back button of the UINavigationController.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoiOS is stagnant or mobile OSs are stagnant? Android was listing screen capture as a new feature not long ago which hardly suggests a breakneck pace of change across the board. Windows phone tiles are interesting but they don't feel game changing. Is this an iOS thing or wider than that? Genuine question because if it was iOS alone then surely it would be eating Android's dust right now and that doesn't feel like it's the case, it feels like they're pretty much on a par. (Just say I'm not wild about the word stagnant given that this is a market that has gone from nought to sixty in about the same time as it takes MS to get a version of Windows out, but it does feel like that pace has somewhat plateaued in the last 12 months or so).
- johsoe 14y agoiOS IS stagnant. Windows Phone 8 has a totally different and new paradigm going with merging start screen and "notifications bar" with the live tiles. Rooms with its "all sharing feature". Kids stuff. Lockscreen apps. All of these are a totally new approach to the mobile platform. I feel the "new Microsoft" is really innovating(i hate that word) atm.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoThe Windows Phone UI is the one thing in my mind that actually is different, though I have a little skepticism about it as I'm not convinced that it's solving a problem many people actually have (certainly not one I or most people I know have) and it doesn't seem to be something consumers are queuing up to get their hands on. Meaningful innovation surely has to be something for which there is a demand? Kids corner I would love on my iPhone but it's a more polished version of what I can do with restrictions so I'm not really sold on it being that revolutionary.
- tatsuke95 14y agoCare to do an "Explain like I'm 5" about skeuopmorphism vs path dependence? I'm not sure I understand it in the context of device design. Edit: or are they talking specifically about app design?
- XaspR8d 14y agoThe way I understand it is that skeuomorphism is about using design to elicit elements or interactions that formerly served a purpose (i.e. making a keyboard look like typewriter keys), whereas path-dependence is about current schemes whose continuing popularity is more due to a quirk of history that gave its use better returns rather than being proven against others (i.e. the QWERTY keyboard).
- tatsuke95 14y agoQWERTY, good example. Thanks.
- jquinnmm 14y ago>Skeuomorphic design was a nod to my non-computer using father in the 90s. It no more represents useful metaphors for interfaces than steam engines represent a good way to build cars. This is wrong. It's just a cycle that we're going through with design fads. Less than ten years ago everybody was all for "lickable interfaces" with 3D buttons, drop shadows and the like. There was even a whole movement of indie developers for the Mac doing skeuomorphic UIs in the wave of Delicious Library, budded by the Mac press "the Delicious generation". Now designers are tired of that look and want something more subtle and flat, inspired by the whole Metro thing (and modern Web style plus the whole movement towards minimal design). The same transitions have happened dozens of times in the history of art and design, from ornamental to utilitarian and back again. One is not inherently better than the other: there can be good and bad skeuomorphic UIs. And, no, the Calendar app, with it's faux leather, is not an example of a bad skeuomorphic UI. If it's bad, it's just because of bad UI, period. The leather part is just decoration, i.e the inconsequential part of skeuomorphism, and doesn't affect behavior. For bad skeuomorphism consider any media app that resembles a physical dvd player, or the turning of the pages in iBooks. I.e behavior that impedes use, not just decorative choices. For the same reason, it also has nothing to do with appealing to "older users". If anything, skeuomorphism and references to old physical objects is extremely popular with younger people, from "steam punk", to hipsters loving vinyl, letter-pressed cards, pocket watches and everything that has "patina", to software like Instagram and Hipstamatic, that digitally applies the image distortions and color artifacts of 30 and 50 year old analog cameras and films. Sorry for the long rant, but I take offense in how everybody is throwing words like "skeuomorphic" around, like they always knew what the term meant, instead of just having in drilled into their head that "skeuomorphic == bad" from tens of me-too online articles this past year.
- starik36 14y ago> Between Siri and the maps screw up the decision made itself. Care to explain what is the issue with Siri? I use it every day to organize my day (with dozens of meetings and reminders) and it works perfectly fine. I can kind of see your point with iOS6 Maps. But only to a point. Yes, it did start out really badly. I reported 3 issues that got fixed the next day (literally). One of those issues was also on Google Maps and is still broken there. Since then I haven't seen any problems with quality of data. I do miss Street View, but day to day, the app is fine. Speaking of maps, when Tim Cook wrote the maps apology letter, he mentioned the Waze application. I've never heard of it till that day and, man, what a great app. Whenever I find myself in a traffic situation, I always fire it up. As far as point to point direction, it is second to none, routing me around traffic jams and standstills of the LA area.