2 ms·
Awesome. Thanks for that. I won't get into a long discussion -- HN seems to frown on these in-depth things. I'd like to point out that to a casual observer you
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Awesome. Thanks for that.
I won't get into a long discussion -- HN seems to frown on these in-depth things. I'd like to point out that to a casual observer you sound like our Civil War vet talking about how much better his life is now that he's hooked on dope.
I did some investigations into MMORPGs a year or so ago. The average WoW player spends a little more than 35 hours per week online playing the game. That's about as much as a full-time job. The virtual goods industry alone -- that's goods that are purely digital -- is in the billions.
Perhaps there are these great mental exercises that make us all the equivalent of digital Mozarts or something. The external evidence is lacking -- there's not some huge increase in SAT scores or math prodigies among video game players. At the very least to an outside observer it seems that there is a huge amount of time and energy being spent in something with no physical results. Except, of course, the usual results of spending 40 hours a week sitting on a couch plugged into a LCD eating Fritos. At the very least, it's completely unprecendented that so many people would spend so much time in sedentary, er, contemplation.
Great comment.
- ryanwaggoner 18y agoThe average WoW player spends a little more than 35 hours per week online playing the game. Do you have a source for that? According to this article, Nielson has it at less than 15 hours per week. Still a huge amount of time, mind you. http://www.tvturnoff.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=12&Itemid=21 http://www.tvturnoff.org/index.php?option=com_content&ta...
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoCan't dig it up easily. Gartner expects 80% of internet users will be involved in an online world by 20011 http://www.gartner.com/it/page.jsp?id=503861&format=print http://www.gartner.com/it/page.jsp?id=503861&format=prin... Chinese Gold Farmers, a significant population of WoW, play an average of 12-14 hours per day http://www.techcrunch.com/2007/06/20/virtual-goods-the-next-big-business-model/ http://www.techcrunch.com/2007/06/20/virtual-goods-the-next-... I might be able to find the original for the 35-hour quote. If it's bugging you, email me and I'll take some extra time to dig it up.
- unalone 18y agoGold Farmers are kind of the exception - and they use WoW as a business, so arguably they're not wasting time. I would bet against Gartner aggressively. They don't understand the technologies they're talking about. Virtual worlds have less to offer than people think.
- patio11 18y agoStill a huge amount of time, mind you. Ex-WoW player here (I quit it to take up running a business in my spare time -- pays better, a different flavor of fun, rather less dragons). I probably spent 15-20 hours many weeks during those two years. It is a lot of time. What impresses me about it is that it seems to suddenly become far less time if I had confessed to watching TV instead.
- unalone 18y agoI did some investigations into MMORPGs a year or so ago. The average WoW player spends a little more than 35 hours per week online playing the game. That's about as much as a full-time job. The virtual goods industry alone -- that's goods that are purely digital -- is in the billions. I agree with Jonathan Blow, who said that it's awful that Blizzard doesn't take more responsibility with its games, that WoW's model of gameplay is awful. That said, I think the design of the game itself is of an incredible scope. I don't play WoW, so I'd agree with you that WoW is kind of icky. Video games aren't big mental exercises. Then again, neither is reading a book in and of itself, or watching a movie, or talking to somebody. You get what you want to out of it. Most of the things I get out of gaming involve lessons about game design itself. A few exceptions: the video game Passage - available for free online - changed how I looked at life (and also made me a bit weepy); Portal taught me of the incredible values of lateral thinking - that won't show up on test scores, because you can't test creativity, but Portal is the video gaming world's Gordion knot, and it showed me just how imperative it is that you create your own mindset when designing rather than mimicking somebody else's; Half Life 2 (also by Valve, who made Portal) taught me about the impact of small things. When you play a shooter game that starves you for bullets, every shot you fire counts, and you begin to form a bond with the few weapons you have, and you begin looking at the environment around you - the lesson there being to focus on the little details until every little thing is wonderful and worth caring about. But that's antithetical to the discussion. Listening to Mozart doesn't make you smarter. In fact, Mozart wrote pop - he made easy, distinct, catchy themes. The only genius involved with Mozart is Mozart. There are similar geniuses now working in the world of video gaming, and online. It's not the masses, it's the individual that gains.
- silentbicycle 18y ago"Video games aren't big mental exercises. Then again, neither is reading a book in and of itself, or watching a movie, or talking to somebody. You get what you want to out of it." Agreed. Also, some books are stimulating, but some are really vapid. Generalizing about any medium as a whole is probably a bad idea, except in relation to the factors shaping it. For example, I think that media which makes money by holding your attention long enough to expose you to ads (some tv and blogs, most magazines) have a strong incentive to produce content that grabs your attention but isn't necessarily deep.
- llimllib 18y ago> The external evidence is lacking -- there's not some huge increase in SAT scores Plus you state in your article that people are getting less intelligent; what do you base that on? How do you explain the Flynn effect? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect
- yters 18y agoMaybe IQ scores are rising because they are becoming more important in society. The article says people who have attended school less do not score as well. So, if IQ has permeated the school system as an important metric, it makes sense that children will be trained to do well on IQ tests. As it is, the article states the IQ increase correlates well with better education, health, and family structure. Also, at the end of the article, it states there are indications the IQ increase has stopped, and may be reversing, in the Western world.
- DaniFong 18y agoI suggest you read the book "What is Intelligence?" by James Flynn himself. It's a cautious and erudite work, and the theory they float does seem to resolve quite a few of the mysteries. Perhaps most importantly, the data do not bear out universal and generic intellectual ascension. They contend that the rise in IQ has been spurred on by a change in cognitive environment over the past century, and I think the existence of a shift in cognitive demands of a massive scale is something tough to deny. Here's a paper where they discuss the theory, if you can't get the book. http://www.apa.org/journals/features/rev1082346.pdf http://www.apa.org/journals/features/rev1082346.pdf
- gnaritas 18y ago> At the very least to an outside observer it seems that there is a huge amount of time and energy being spent in something with no physical results. You say that as if it's a bad thing, it isn't. The greatest things we tend to seek aren't physical things, but mental states like love and happiness. It matter not whether the things that invoke those mental states come from the real world or the virtual.