5 ms·
The purpose of the education system is to create a well-informed citizenry prepared for a productive life and for the duty of running a country. Could you be s
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
The purpose of the education system is to create a well-informed citizenry prepared for a productive life and for the duty of running a country.
Could you be specific? In particular, how do I measure whether a citizen is prepared for a productive life or not?
Heck, we could start by testing the hypothesis that getting everybody to focus lots of classroom time on standardized tests improves actual education.
How would you set up the experiment? In particular, how would you compare group A (no tests) to group B (with tests)?
- saraid216 14y ago> Could you be specific? In particular, how do I measure whether a citizen is prepared for a productive life or not? I like that you ignored the latter half. You don't measure the citizen. You measure the rate at which the country is liberalizing. That is, the rate at which its core philosophical attitude is becoming more individualist, egalitarian, meliorist, and universalist. The purpose of public education is to shift us from the medieval era into the modern era. (And to be clear, being conservative is the opposite of being radical; it does not contradict being liberal. Many things that belong on the political Right are legitimately liberal but not Left.) How many people are concerned with individual rights? How many people demonstrate equal moral worth and status to all individuals? How many people have a positive outlook on the future? How many people recognize universal qualities in all human beings? The rate at which these indicators are moving is positive, but that rate should be increasing in a country with a strong educational system; you'd ask the questions differently in a different era.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoSo you are proposing that the purpose of education is indoctrination into value system X, and propose that a successful system will indoctrinate more people? Your goal is now vaguely stated. But how do I actually count the # of people concerned with individual rights/positive outlook/etc?
- saraid216 14y ago> So you are proposing that the purpose of education is indoctrination into value system X, and propose that a successful system will indoctrinate more people? What did you think it was? > Your goal is now vaguely stated. But how do I actually count the # of people concerned with individual rights/positive outlook/etc? Uh, polling?
- ntumlin 14y agoHopefully the goal isn't to indoctrinate people but to prepare them to go to college, get a job, make money, spend money, etc.
- saraid216 14y ago> go to college, get a job, make money, spend money Can you tell me why these are good things to prepare people for?
- ntumlin 14y agoCollege leads to job leads to money. Money is generally a pretty handy thing to have.
- saraid216 14y agoAnd some people disagree with the notion of money. Why is your value system better to indoctrinate the young with over theirs? I don't disagree with you, mind. It's just that accusations of indoctrination are responded to in kind.
- smsm42 14y agoI think living a good life and doing something that benefits other people (aka earning money) is a good idea. If somebody disagrees, he can of course take his kids and go live under the bridge and open his school there. Let's see where we'd have more applicants - in a school that teaches kids how to be successful or in a school under a bridge that teaches them money is nothing, you can subsist on garbage and live in cardboard boxes forever. I think you can predict the result - and explaining this result would also explain which system is better, in opinion of your peers.
- wpietri 14y agoWhy is it suddenly my job to make up tests? If you'd like some, give it a go. My point is that NCLB is scientific in the same way Taylorism was: it's a cargo cult activity that takes on the trappings of science and looks for something easy to measure. And then uses those measures in ways that aren't scientifically validated at all.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI'm asking you what evidence (if any) would change your belief. Perhaps no evidence is capable of changing your mind. That's fine - you've just adopted a different philosophy, one of the "other ways of knowing" rather than science. My point is that NCLB... I'm not arguing for NCLB, I'm arguing that objective, comparable and reproducible measurements are the only viable way to optimize a system. If you want to argue some specific metric is flawed, do it. Explain what should be measured and how the particular metric differs from it (i.e., details). So far, not a single person in this thread has actually done that - the closest we came was this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4713558 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4713558
- wpietri 14y agoScience is awesome. It is also incredibly difficult and expensive. I would love it if we did proper science with education. I would love it if we did it with software development. In neither case has anybody put forward sufficient resources to do real science in these realms. Not science sufficient to replace human judgment. Until we can, I don't think cargo cult science is the way to go. Half-assed studies on software development methods, counting simple metrics for developers, measuring teachers through simple standardized tests: all cargo cult science. For now, I'd much rather rely explicitly on human judgment. It's not as good as actual science, but it's much better than pseudoscience.