5 ms·
While great option, LispWorks and Allegro Common Lisp should not be overlooked, too many focus on SBCL + Emacs and then complain about Lisp tooling.
by pjmlp 9mo ago
While great option, LispWorks and Allegro Common Lisp should not be overlooked, too many focus on SBCL + Emacs and then complain about Lisp tooling.
- cultofmetatron 9mo ago> too many focus on SBCL + Emacs and then complain about Lisp tooling. well yea, lispworks and allegro are expensive commercial projects. I wish sbcl, the defacto best open source option had better tooling. emacs is great and all for the true believers but I'm an unwashed vscode user. For plenty of reasons I can't justify it in my startup but I'd love to spend more time working with common lisp for personal projects but my time is limited so I prefer clojure or rust.
- pjmlp 9mo agoThey have community editions.
- vindarel 9mo agoI can't load my side projects in LispWorks' community edition, so… (because of the heap limit)
- dmpk2k 9mo agoVaguely related, but have you tried Alive? https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=rheller.alive https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=rheller....
- stackghost 9mo agoI use emacs regularly (in fact I have it running right now) and I think the complaints against it are perfectly valid. Emacs is awesome in lots of ways, but it also really, really sucks in lots of other ways. But putting emacs aside, the SBCL tooling seems reasonable to me. The real reason I rarely reach for lisp these days is not the tooling, but because the Common Lisp library ecosystem is a wasteland of partial implementations and abandoned code bases. It's also been my experience that LLMs are better at writing more mainstream languages, especially "newbie-proof" languages like Go. In any case, I don't see why one would reach for Allegro or Lispworks over SBCL unless one really enjoys writing lisp by hand and needs specific features they offer that SBCL doesn't. I would imagine those features are vanishingly few.
- vindarel 9mo agoI'd prefer that a LispWorks user answer, but there are quite a few interesting features, such as: - tree shaking and small binaries (±5MB a GUI app) - the CAPI cross-platform and native GUI toolkit - mobile platforme runtime (iOs, Android) - its Java interface - its KnowledgeWorks system for "rule-based, object-oriented, logical, functional and database programming" - more? ps: today we maintain a list of pretty decent libraries: https://github.com/CodyReichert/awesome-cl/ https://github.com/CodyReichert/awesome-cl/
- mveety 9mo agoI'm a lispworks user for a few projects. The killers, generally, for an enterprise project are the smaller binaries and java interface. I know of a few places that write gui apps in lispworks, but many (most?) projects with a user interface use some web framework stuff and only do the backend in lisp. The java is a killer feature for lisp adoption. A lot of companies use java heavily and being able to easily interface with that stuff is often a technical requirement and if not a technical one, a management requirement.
- remexre 9mo agomy impression is that most CL these days is existing large closed-source codebases, hence the price tag for those compilers (you're not trying it out for a bit, you're funding the compiler devs to work full-time on the issues you're actually having) and relatively little open-source activity for "finished" things -- if you're developing against internal libraries, it's hard to open-source just the part you intend to (work at a CL shop; mostly SBCL users, but maybe 1/3 of people are die-hard ACL fans)
- dmux 9mo agoLispWorks and Allegro are both interesting, but I've found their IDE offerings to be very limited. I haven't used either since I was playing around with CL during Covid, but from what I recall, even the basic IDE experience of writing code was severely lacking: poor autocomplete, poor syntax highlighting, clunky interfaces. In most discussions I see about them, they're only recommended for their compilers, not for their IDE offerings.
- vindarel 9mo agoI think LispWorks is fine (also look at these plugins https://github.com/apr3vau/lw-plugins https://github.com/apr3vau/lw-plugins - terminal integration, code folding, side tree, markdown highlighting, Nerd Fonts, fuzzy-matching, enhanced directory mode, expand region, pair editing, SVG rendering…) but I had this feeling with the newer web-based Allegro IDE (the poor syntax highlighting surprised me, did I do sthg wrong?).
- Keyframe 9mo agoIt was and remained an esoteric mystery to me ever since I saw Nichimen's work (with it); Pricing was just out of this world to even consider at the time.
- jwr 9mo agoI used both, AllegroCL commercially in production, and was disappointed in both. Especially AllegroCL given its price and promises made.