4 ms·
This is a question about the philosophy of science. How do you know clinical trials are better than observational methods? How do you know controlled experimen
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
This is a question about the philosophy of science.
How do you know clinical trials are better than observational methods? How do you know controlled experiments are better than post-hoc reasoning and logical deduction?
Standardized testing is just the application of the scientific method to education. If you don't believe in the scientific method then you shouldn't apply it here.
But if you are asking for an empirical method to compare the scientific method to "other ways of knowing", there isn't one.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- vehementi 14y agoStandardized testing is an application of the scientific method to education, but it's (accurately) measuring stupid shit that we shouldn't care about in ways that are not relevant.
- klochner 14y agoWhat about long-run outcomes under standardized testing vs. without standardized testing? Longitudinal data would be difficult to find, but surely countries differ in their respective levels of standardized testing.
- wpietri 14y agoStandardized testing is just the application of the scientific method to education. That's not true in any way. The purpose of the education system is to create a well-informed citizenry prepared for a productive life and for the duty of running a country. The goal of standardized testing is to get some very rough metrics about superficial, easy-to-observe aspects of some basic parts of the apparatus. The two are very tenuously related. If we were applying the scientific method, we wouldn't be doing things like national, uncontrolled experiments that assume that basing major decisions on those rough metrics will result in improvements along the axes we actually care about. And then acting as if those metrics tell us everything about one aspect of the system, teachers, because that's where the political focus is. Applying the scientific method would involve formulating hypotheses and then testing them through lab work and field trials. That's what we do with medicine, at least some of the time. Heck, we could start by testing the hypothesis that getting everybody to focus lots of classroom time on standardized tests improves actual education.
- saraid216 14y ago> Heck, we could start by testing the hypothesis that getting everybody to focus lots of classroom time on standardized tests improves actual education. It's been done. A quick Google found me this: http://www.nytimes.com/1992/10/16/us/study-finds-standardized-tests-may-hurt-education-efforts.html http://www.nytimes.com/1992/10/16/us/study-finds-standardize... Which is from 1992. I'm sure if I put some effort into it, I could find more, or at least demonstrate that standardized testing has not meaningfully changed in the last 20 years.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe purpose of the education system is to create a well-informed citizenry prepared for a productive life and for the duty of running a country. Could you be specific? In particular, how do I measure whether a citizen is prepared for a productive life or not? Heck, we could start by testing the hypothesis that getting everybody to focus lots of classroom time on standardized tests improves actual education. How would you set up the experiment? In particular, how would you compare group A (no tests) to group B (with tests)?
- saraid216 14y ago> Could you be specific? In particular, how do I measure whether a citizen is prepared for a productive life or not? I like that you ignored the latter half. You don't measure the citizen. You measure the rate at which the country is liberalizing. That is, the rate at which its core philosophical attitude is becoming more individualist, egalitarian, meliorist, and universalist. The purpose of public education is to shift us from the medieval era into the modern era. (And to be clear, being conservative is the opposite of being radical; it does not contradict being liberal. Many things that belong on the political Right are legitimately liberal but not Left.) How many people are concerned with individual rights? How many people demonstrate equal moral worth and status to all individuals? How many people have a positive outlook on the future? How many people recognize universal qualities in all human beings? The rate at which these indicators are moving is positive, but that rate should be increasing in a country with a strong educational system; you'd ask the questions differently in a different era.
- saraid216 14y ago> Standardized testing is just the application of the scientific method to education. If you don't believe in the scientific method then you shouldn't apply it here. Sorry, what's the null hypothesis here, and where's the control group?
- lutorm 14y agoStandardized testing has nothing to do with science. There are studies in teaching and learning that do attempt to gauge the effectiveness of different teaching approaches, etc, and they typically use randomized trials and carefully controlled situations to be able to measure the effect. But more crucially, the subjects (both teachers and students) in those studies are not rewarded based on the outcome of the study. Even if there is a correlation between the test and what we want schools to achieve (whatever that is), making teachers jobs contingent on that outcome will select for teachers who are good at achieving those results, which increasingly will diverge from your desired outcome. It's an example of dangers of "optimization by proxy" (http://lesswrong.com/lw/28r/is_google_paperclipping_the_web_the_perils_of/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/28r/is_google_paperclipping_the_web_...).