7 ms·
Technology is Heroin
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoThis is a long article, but I wrote it based on the conclusions from many HN discussions. I think you guys will like it if you can bear with it, and I'm also really curious as to what your feedback might be. I never thought when writing programs that I'd have to ask myself "Am I doing good or evil in the world here?" After all, it's just so many bytes, right? But I'm not so sure about that anymore.
- unalone 18y agoI love reading articles from HN users. I love the feeling that I'm in a community of active thinkers. Thanks for sharing! :-)
- Eliezer 18y agoI tackled the same topic in "Superstimuli and the Collapse of Western Civilization": http://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/03/superstimuli_an.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/03/superstimuli_an.html Opening paragraph: "At least three people have died playing online games for days without rest. People have lost their spouses, jobs, and children to World of Warcraft. If people have the right to play video games - and it's hard to imagine a more fundamental right - then the market is going to respond by supplying the most engaging video games that can be sold, to the point that exceptionally engaged consumers are removed from the gene pool."
- unalone 18y agoThat's a fun article too. However, I'd argue that if anything that's a cruel example of social Darwinism. The ability to focus on yourself rather than to rely on the opinions and worlds of others is a trait useful for survival.
- Alex3917 18y agoDrugs: The one that makes us feel the best wins. Music: The one that gets noticed over the clutter wins. Games: The one that's the best at giving us the illusion of social status and accomplishment wins. None of these things are really competing against each other, because the hook for each is targeting a different need. And I do think there is a way out. Change our environment so that our lives aren't so hollow and empty. The reason these addictions take hold is because, for example, people are accomplishing absolutely zero in their lives so they need the fake feeling of accomplishment and respect from hitting level 60 in WoW. If we re-engineer society so that people actually have an opportunity to make friends, do productive work, get exercise, etc. these things won't be nearly as dangerous as they are today.
- DanielBMarkham 18y ago"Makes us feel best", "Gets noticed over the clutter", "[Gives] us the illusion of social status" Those are the lures that each niche uses, sure, but the result is that we lose time. The result is the problem, not the drug packaging or delivery mechanism. If anything, that makes it more disturbing: whatever our psychological needs, there's electronic joy out there competing for them. Not sure how it will play out. I'm an optimist, but after I wrote this it's kind of drug me down. I'm sure we'll muddle through somehow as a species. We always do.
- unalone 18y agoThere's already emphasis on that in society. You'll find that the weakest-minded people are all socialites who exercise and obsess to get their work done. Schools are littered with "all-American students" who try to be as generically happy as possible. It makes finding actually bright kids a pain. The problem is that the counterculture rejects that stuff - partly because it's true that a lot of people who do all that are shallow and annoying. (The counterculture's just as bad, of course.) If you drop out and eat too much and don't make friends, you're bucking the trend, you're rebelling. That's how it is among a lot of younger kids, anyway: past a certain point obesity is just a matter of not caring enough to keep care of yourself.
- homme 18y agopeople are accomplishing absolutely zero in their lives so they need the fake feeling of accomplishment and respect from hitting level 60 in WoW. If we re-engineer society so that people actually have an opportunity to make friends, do productive work, get exercise Someone has taken your (and DanielBMarkhams) arguments to their logical consequences... http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=472731 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=472731
- jacquesm 18y agoMan that's some excellent writing. I'm seriously jealous at your ability to write like that, I'll need to practice more :) I did spot this little HN reference in there: "Programmers are creating "no procrastinate" options for their web sites in order to help users not spend so much time there." thanks for all that work! I agree with your premise that technology is addictive, I think it somehow fits in with our fascination with tools in general. After all humans are 'toolmakers' par excellence, tools mean survival, food and progress, no wonder we should become addicted to them. Your analog with heroin and the time required to figure out what was happening reminds me of the old story of the frog and the boiling pot: If you put a frog in a pot with hot water it will jump out immediately, but if you slowly raise the temperature the frog won't notice the problem until it is too late to jump out and it perishes. Not sure if that's a true story but that's how I remember it. I'm passing your article on to my 15 year old son to read.
- unalone 18y agoFrom the comments: I watched the movie Idiocracy with you and it hit me in the face as to one potential out come for the human race. But talking about the fact that we don't do physical chores that were done a hundred years ago, doesn't make a lot of sense. After all, things have changed. Those chores are no longer an issue. I just saw Idiocracy yesterday (ironically, I decided it wasn't worth paying attention to so I played it on the top of the screen and coded on the bottom of the screen), and I think that assuming it's a plausible outcome is kind of silly. I doubt Mike Judge, the director, would disagree. Idiocracy is much more a critique of the present than it is of the future. This was a terrific article, but there're a few fallacies in your argument. The one that most stands out to me is how you talk about music switching from being active to passive, and therefore taking less effort from the listener. You then bring up rock music as an instance of something that provides a big hit rather than focusing on intricacy. The fallacy is that in the past, most people didn't listen to concerts. There is a long history of minstrel songs: music played in the street, catchy stuff for the public. The average person wouldn't listen to any concert in their lifetime. This is not a new thing. Furthermore, if you look at how many people travel to concert halls to listen to music, I would bet that more people proportionally listen to great pieces of work like Tchaikovsky or Mozart than ever have in the past. If anything, the trend is that once you have access to things easily, you are more willing to put effort into a viewing than you would be if you'd never been before. (I'm going to the Met to see a Tchaikovsky opera two weeks from now; I never would have wanted to if I hadn't torrented 2GB worth of his pieces earlier in the year.) "Don't turn that dial!" has become cliche: whatever you do, keep your eyes peeled on this station. That ignores the rise in TV that's actively challenging to watch. To bring up the two shows I always bring up, The Wire on HBO and BBC's The Office. Neither one is easy and clear-cut. They both attract watchers who are there to be challenged. I've watched the entire Office straight through three times in the way that I reread good books. It's not addictive per se, it's enriching. Your argument about video games make me wonder how avid a gamer you are. I'm not a huge gamer, but the games that I do like are almost always pretty rich in environment. Portal's the cliche in gaming, and that's a game that's clever, well-written, and encourages lateral thinking. My 13-year-old brother, who dislikes most books and isn't a big math kid, got hooked in Portal's advanced challenges, which really are difficult pieces. Then there're RPGs, the best of which are superb storytellers, there are real-time strategy games, there are all sorts of games that encourage you to actively think. You can't play a game and shut off. You need to focus incredibly. My friends that play Counterstrike are the best proof of this: you need to be a special sort of brilliant to play that game well. It's addictive, but only in the way, again, that challenging books or pieces of music are. It's not a "pop" game. Of course, I would also argue that VG composers are writing the most sophisticated orchestral music of the day. Listen to Roar of the Earth by Ko Otani if you can find sample pieces. It's rich and complex in the way good classical music is. Plus, it's attached to a video game that's pretty stimulating in and of itself - ever played Shadow of the Colossus? It's one of the few video games I will call an exceptional piece of art rather than merely a game. (Sidebar: World of Warcraft is an exception in that yes, it's focused on addiction rather than active focus. But what a piece of art it is in and of itself! I've never played, I don't want to get hooked, but they made an entire world! This is like Tolkien realized. One of my future plans is to make an MMORPG in a much more literary sense, and to create an enormous world that really feels like fantasy - World of Warcraft opened that door for me. It's an incredible achievement in and of itself.) The Internet is addictive, yes - but in what way is it addictive? My friend and I both competed to parody the 25 Things notes on Facebook yesterday - that requires some thinking and creative prowess. Meanwhile, while I spend hours a day in front of a computer, I'm constantly reading articles like this one, and writing answer pieces. I participate in debates. And I've found that as a result, in debate-focused classes I'm leagues ahead of classmates. It's entirely because the Internet gets my mind going. The Internet is not passive. It's not like rock music or TV shows or heroin. It's active. You consciously focus on what you're doing. People are less fit because less tasks require physical labor than ever have before. That's why society is so focused on being thin. Now, staying fit requires conscious effort. It is no longer a passive task. It doesn't happen during the day unless you choose it to. So in a way, it's a reversal of the ideas that you're stating here. (I keep a 30-pound weight on my desk, and I exercise and have my computer read long posts out loud. It's such a wonderful system.) Finally: things have always devoted people's lives like this. If I wasn't constantly on the Internet, I would be writing in a notebook, or practicing an instrument. That's not heroin, is it? That's an exercise in creativity. Think of it like that: anything worth doing is worth devoting time to. And most of society will always ignore those opportunities for wasted time. That's nothing new. It's a part of human nature.
- newt0311 18y agoFalse analogy: Heroin does not have significant positive side-effects (at least not in a monetary sense). Ie. it cannot make you more productive. Technology on the other hand does.
- silentbicycle 18y agoIn the article, he mentions examples of positive effects of opiates, particularly surgical anesthesia (via morphine, although ether and nitrous oxide were initially used). Heroin was also used as an antitussive, etc. Other solutions with less serious side-effects were later found, of course, but at the time, they really saved lives. Major surgery without anesthesia was a terrifying ordeal, and, before antibiotics, many conditions meant surgery or death. Some technology makes me more productive (refrigerators, text editors, bicycles, vaccines), and some makes me less (Flash games, irc, hacker news). Others have a mixed effect (cell phones, books). Technology takes many forms, and it's hard to generalize about them all in any sound way.
- unalone 18y agoDoes Hacker News absolutely make you less productive? Yeah, you're not getting work done right now, but you're debating people, you're teaching yourself to write out good arguments, and you're reading a ton of articles, some of which are bound to fascinate or teach you.
- silentbicycle 18y agoI actually would have put it in the mixed column, but I added that later and didn't move it. I run across some interesting things on the side, but at the same time, I have many, many books I've been meaning to read, etc., and I also know all too well where this comic is coming from: http://xkcd.com/386/ http://xkcd.com/386/
- newt0311 18y agoYet, the basic point holds. On the whole, the Internet makes people and organizations vastly more productive. Furthermore, morphine and opiates are regularly used when the benefits outweigh the costs (like for anesthesia) so thats not a very effective counterexample. If one wants to start regulating parts of technology, they must ask the question of whether the expected gains from said regulation would outweigh the costs. With narcotics, its easy: addiction is very expensive, especially for the addicts and productive and non-productive uses are generally easy to tell apart (medical use of morphine v. junkies for example). OTOH, technology is difficult to separate and the side-effects from flash games, irc, et al. are not that significant.
- arjungmenon 18y agoAll of this begs the question: What is the meaning of life? If you think of it, everything people do is quite remarkably purposeless. Why does life exist? Why do you exist???????
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- initself 18y agoWow, now that's a really fantastic post. Make me want to shut down my computer and do some yoga. I think my computer use is giving me a chronic cough, too. I don't smoke or drink ever.
- ajju 18y agoWonder what pg thinks of the article. There are some clear parallels with his "Disconnecting distraction" (although that was more prescriptive and didn't indict technology as...directly). Plus the author mentions the "noprocrast" option on HN.
- c00p3r 18y agoThere are to many words to explain that every attempt to escape from so-called reality will cause a big problem, and digital illusions produces the same effect.It seems like the problem is in choosing wrong direction. One probably should spent ones resources (ones time at first) to discover beauties of this world. Illusions are very limited because of limits of ones mind. BTW, The Matrix movie was released almost 10 years ago. =)
- dejb 18y ago> Intelligence is going down as fewer and fewer books are being read As far as I am aware measurable intelligence is increasing. I would also think that the internet has lead to a general increase in reading and intellectual thought.
- edw519 18y agoBut hey -- it's not like TV gave you the shakes, or made you sick or killed you. It does, just slower. (Great essay, Daniel. If you write code as well as you write prose, you are a hacker's hacker.)
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoThanks Edw. Somebody posted it over on reddit and you should see some of the comments. Makes me sound like some guy living in a cave eating twigs and berries. I wonder how much of the response to an article comes from situational cues -- knowing the author, being part of a community and such -- and how much is actually predicated on how good the article is? The guy who submitted in on reddit had a really low score. I'm assuming he's not one of the "in crowd" over there. It would be interesting to wait a month or two and then have a high-profile person over there submit the same article to see if the reaction would be different. I'm betting it would be. Hey. Still working on my hacking skills. Been slinging code for 20 years and I don't think I'll ever reach uber-coder status like some of the other guys on here.
- edw519 18y agoNegative feedback on reddit is like getting fired by Henry Ford: a badge of honor. Not sure if I liked your essay so much because or who you are of if I agreed with it so much. More likely, it stands on its own merit. You made an argument, used metaphor in a way that a fellow hacker could truly appreciate, and while you were at it, taught a little bit when we weren't looking. People like you, pg, Joel, etc. are using blog to breathe new life into an old artform, the essay. Keep up the great work!
- crocus 18y agoDon't take it personally. Reddit has a culture of flaming. The same thing would have happened no matter who submitted it. They're just like that there.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoAnd what does it matter? If technology manages to solve scarcity people won't have to do any chores any more. If it doesn't we'll cope or die off. Either way being a luddite apologist doesn't really help anyone.
- gravitycop 18y agoIf technology manages to solve scarcity When has it ever failed to do so? http://www.juliansimon.com/writings/Ultimate_Resource http://www.juliansimon.com/writings/Ultimate_Resource people won't have to do any chores any more. http://www.marshallbrain.com/manna5.htm http://www.marshallbrain.com/manna5.htm "So how do I earn the credits?" I asked. "Earn?" Linda asked back. "No no no..." said Cynthia. "Do you give me a job? The reason I am here is because I have no job," I said. "No. You see, it's all free. By being a shareholder, you already own your share of the resources. The robots make products from the free resources you and everyone else already owns. There is no forced labor like there is in America. You do what you want, and you get 1,000 credits per week. We are all on an endless vacation."
- homme 18y agoAnd what does it matter? Oh, are there consequences... http://cyber.eserver.org/unabom.txt http://cyber.eserver.org/unabom.txt
- kragen 18y agoThe article says: Help is on the way, however. The American Civil War saw the first use of morphine for pain relief. It's impossible to overstate what a difference it made. The opiates were truly miracle drugs. This is a really remarkable level of historical inaccuracy. To quote from http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/pagerender.fcgi?artid=46725&pageindex=1 http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/pagerender.fcgi?artid=46725... : There is general agreement that the Sumerians, who inhabited what is today Iraq, cultivated poppies and isolated opium from their seed capsules at the end of the third millenium [sic] B.C. They called opium “gil,” the word for joy, and the poppy “hul gil,” plant of joy. It appears that opium spread from Sumeria to the remainder of the old world. At first opium may have been employed as a euphoriant in religious rituals, taken by mouth or inhaled from heated vessels (4). Knowledge of its use may initially have been confined to priests representing gods who sealed the sick and gods of death as well. It was given along with hemlock to put people quickly and painlessly to death, and it came to be used medicinally. The Ebers Papyrus (ca. 1500 B.C.), for example, includes the following description of a “remedy to prevent excessive crying of children" (see ref. 2, p. 35): "Špenn, the grains of the špenn (poppy)-plant, with excretions of flies found on the wall, strained to a pulp, passed through a sieve and administered on four successive days. The crying will stop at once." This remedy and others containing opium (such as spongia somnifera, sponges soaked in opium used to relieve pain during surgery) were dangerous because they varied in potency and rate of absorbance. Consequently, many physicians were wary of using them. ... In 1806, Sertürner (8, 9) isolated the active ingredient in opium and named it morphine... The same paragraph of the "Technology is Heroin" article also makes the error of calling cocaine an opiate.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoHistory of Drug Use and Drug Users in the United States. http://www.a1b2c3.com/drugs/gen003.htm http://www.a1b2c3.com/drugs/gen003.htm Halfway down the page, the section is titled "Opiates: The New Nineteenth Century Habit" Also "Opium in the Civil War: Marching Through the Opium Fog" http://www.4thus.com/opium http://www.4thus.com/opium Obviously opiates were around before then. Geesh. They were natural substances. The point of that section is about the social evolution of drugs. And yes, Cocaine is not an opiate. It made a better example -- the available graphics were better -- so it was used. It was an editorial decision. It's an essay, not a science book. The article is about the social parallels that led to drugs being severely restricted and how it compares/contrasts with modern entertainment technology taking more and more of our time and energy. Counter-arguments based against this thesis are welcome. (speaking as the author) Your comment looks a bit like nit-picking, at least to me.
- mhartl 18y agoIt's not that technology is heroin, it's that heroin is technology. And technology cuts both ways.