3 ms·
Lack of secure boot also makes it impossible for remote third parties (e.g. netflix, content providers, or enterprise IT departments) to trust client software.
by rdl 14y ago
Lack of secure boot also makes it impossible for remote third parties (e.g. netflix, content providers, or enterprise IT departments) to trust client software.
Even windows secure boot doesn't provide protection against a targeted attack, but conceivably a combination of EFI secure boot and a bug-free well implemented OS (heh) could provide enough protection for DRM on video content, basic enterprise computing (with non-hostile users), etc.
I still think none of this crap really belongs on the client; it is however an awesome fit on the server, which is an area people haven't really explored enough.
- batgaijin 14y agoThe DRM for video content just doesn't make sense to me - who is it really for? Will it stop most people? Yes. Will it stop the 0.01% qualified individuals who then share it with everyone else? No!
- rdl 14y agoThey will essentially never be able to stop the release groups from releasing stuff, but they can presumably prevent casual ripping by end users, then use the heavy hammer of RICO to go after the groups (DrinkOrDie...). They need to make the value spread between pirate and legit as wide as possible, but rather than making better DRM (to make pirated sw less useful, but also make legit software less useful), IMO they should just focus on making legit software fundamentally more useful when legitimately licensed. I know Steam essentially got me to stop pirating games by integrating their social features, easy library management, etc. Mac App Store sort of does that for most Mac software, too. But there's also the issue of price point -- even if I bought every game I wanted, that's probably <$1000/yr. It's easy to consume >$1000/yr in movies/tv, music, and "internet content", and even easier to pirate, with less value on top of the raw content.
- shykes 14y ago> I still think none of this crap really belongs on the client; it is however an awesome fit on the server, which is an area people haven't really explored enough. Agreed. I remember reading an IBM research paper about combining TPM and virtualization on the server, and getting excited about the possibilities. I wonder what happened to that project. EDIT: found it! http://domino.watson.ibm.com/library/cyberdig.nsf/papers/4427173615992B74852570BC005E7117/$File/rc23778.pdf http://domino.watson.ibm.com/library/cyberdig.nsf/papers/442...
- rdl 14y agoVMware has some TPM features built in (although basically limited to remote-attest that it's a legitimate VMware ESX server). Intel also had some demo stuff, but the problem is Intel's security software group was kind of a revolving door spinning at a 3-6 month rotational speed.