3 ms·

Not a great use case for Claw really. I'm sure ChatGPT can one shot a Python script to do this with yt-dlp and give you instructions on how to set it up as a se

Not a great use case for Claw really. I'm sure ChatGPT can one shot a Python script to do this with yt-dlp and give you instructions on how to set it up as a service

qudat 7mo ago
I mean that’s sort of where I think this all will land. Use something like happy cli to connect to CC in a workspace directory where it can generate scripts, markdown files, and systemd unit files. I don’t see why you’d need more than that. That cuts 500k LoC from the stack and leverages a frontier tool like CC
- hmokiguess 7mo ago
  Yeah that’s a good point. I use a fork of https://github.com/tiann/hapi https://github.com/tiann/hapi with Tailscale for this very reason and it works well
- kzahel 7mo ago
  We think alike! https://github.com/kzahel/claw-starter https://github.com/kzahel/claw-starter Systemd basic script + markdown + (bring whatever agent CLI) That's I think basically what you describe. I've been using it for the past two days it's very very basic but it's a I think it gives you everything you actually need sort of the minimal open claw without a custom harness and 5k loc or 50k or w/e. The cool thing is that it can just grow naturally and you can audit as it grows
simonw 7mo ago
You've gotta run it somewhere though - that's the harder part.
- enraged_camel 7mo ago
  Not to mention, the whole point is to not end up with a bunch of one-off Python scripts for every little thing that occurs to you, right?
  - jmholla 7mo ago
    Why not? Why not have your agent write and automate those one off scripts instead of burning tokens on repeated actions?
Barbing 7mo ago
ChatGPT can do it w/o draining your bank account etc. I’d agree… But for speed only, I think it’s “your idea but worse” when the steps include something AND instructions on how to do something else. The Signal/Telegram bot will handle it E2E (maybe using a ton more tokens than a webchat but fast). If I’m not mistaken.
phil21 7mo ago
Yeah it’s all the stuff beyond the one-shotting of the script that make it useful though. You just get the final result. The video you requested saved. No copy pasting, no iterating back and forth due to python version issues, no messing around with systemd or whatever else, etc. Basically the difference between a howto doc providing you instructions and all the tools you need to download and install vs just having your junior sysadmin handle it and hand it off after testing. These are miles apart in my mind. The script is the easy part.
tovej 7mo ago
Why do you beed ChatGPT for this, this is like two or three lines of code. That you then add to cron. This is one minute of human work.

Not a great use case for Claw really. I'm sure ChatGPT can one shot a Python script to do this with yt-dlp and give you instructions on how to set it up as a service

qudat 7mo ago

I mean that’s sort of where I think this all will land. Use something like happy cli to connect to CC in a workspace directory where it can generate scripts, markdown files, and systemd unit files. I don’t see why you’d need more than that. That cuts 500k LoC from the stack and leverages a frontier tool like CC

hmokiguess 7mo ago
Yeah that’s a good point. I use a fork of https://github.com/tiann/hapi https://github.com/tiann/hapi with Tailscale for this very reason and it works well
kzahel 7mo ago
We think alike! https://github.com/kzahel/claw-starter https://github.com/kzahel/claw-starter Systemd basic script + markdown + (bring whatever agent CLI) That's I think basically what you describe. I've been using it for the past two days it's very very basic but it's a I think it gives you everything you actually need sort of the minimal open claw without a custom harness and 5k loc or 50k or w/e. The cool thing is that it can just grow naturally and you can audit as it grows

simonw 7mo ago

You've gotta run it somewhere though - that's the harder part.

enraged_camel 7mo ago
Not to mention, the whole point is to not end up with a bunch of one-off Python scripts for every little thing that occurs to you, right?
- jmholla 7mo ago
  Why not? Why not have your agent write and automate those one off scripts instead of burning tokens on repeated actions?

Barbing 7mo ago

ChatGPT can do it w/o draining your bank account etc. I’d agree… But for speed only, I think it’s “your idea but worse” when the steps include something AND instructions on how to do something else. The Signal/Telegram bot will handle it E2E (maybe using a ton more tokens than a webchat but fast). If I’m not mistaken.

phil21 7mo ago

Yeah it’s all the stuff beyond the one-shotting of the script that make it useful though. You just get the final result. The video you requested saved. No copy pasting, no iterating back and forth due to python version issues, no messing around with systemd or whatever else, etc. Basically the difference between a howto doc providing you instructions and all the tools you need to download and install vs just having your junior sysadmin handle it and hand it off after testing. These are miles apart in my mind. The script is the easy part.

tovej 7mo ago

Why do you beed ChatGPT for this, this is like two or three lines of code. That you then add to cron. This is one minute of human work.