3 ms·
This definition is so broad it basically encompasses all communication.
by weregiraffe 8mo ago
This definition is so broad it basically encompasses all communication.
- calgoo 8mo agoI mean, in a way, all communication is propaganda. Its one person or group trying to influence you with their information.
- bayindirh 8mo agoI don't think so. I strive to lay the facts out neutrally so people can decide what to do with that information, even if the outcome is not ideal for me. Preventing non-ideal outcomes is not about lying, but not doing things you might regret in the future. This is why I'm no politician, though.
- squigz 8mo agoHow would you define it?
- ben_w 8mo agoAll communication that is primarily used to influence or persuade an audience to further an agenda, yes. There's also debate and ego-less teaching for the sake of truth-seeking.
- weregiraffe 8mo agoWell, since nobody is ego-less, no truth is universally accepted, and debate is a means to pursue an agenda, what are we left with?
- ben_w 8mo ago> and debate is a means to pursue an agenda Scount mindset: the discovery of the truth to the best of our ability without fear or favour. The metaphor is: A scout who tells the general his troops are strong when they are weak, that the enemy is weak when it is strong, is a bad scout. The opposite is a soldier mindset: a soldier who fears to fight when ordered, no matter the strength of the enemy, isn't a good soldier. You can call the search for truth an agenda in its own right if you wish, but it lacks the "primarily used to influence or persuade" aspect of propaganda.
- weregiraffe 8mo ago>Scount mindset: the discovery of the truth to the best of our ability without fear or favour. That's a mind-slave mindset. Why is the scout working for the general and not for himself?
- ben_w 8mo agoWhy do you see the negative in everything, even metaphors? There's no slavery here. There's not even "slavery" even in actual scouts working for actual generals. And a general needs the same *mindset*, even if they must also engage in performative ho-rah-ing to the troops. A general may need to order their troops to die for the greater good, they may need to lie to the troops to up morale, but if a general lets themselves believe they're strong when they're weak, they're bad at being generals. If they don't listen to their scouts, if they shoot the messenger, they're bad at being generals.
- GoblinSlayer 8mo agoFor the sake of truth seeking you will selectively teach information that your ego deems true.
- ben_w 8mo agoSome are as you say. My ego prefers to be the kind of person who ends up at truth over being one who has fooled themselves into thinking they have already found it, which makes changing my mind easier than others find it. I am pleased to say, others have also remarked that I am closer to this ideal than others they know.
- weregiraffe 8mo ago>My ego prefers to be the kind of person who ends up at truth over being one who has fooled themselves into thinking they have already found it, which makes changing my mind easier than others find it. Yeah, that's what everyone says.
- ben_w 8mo agoThey really don't. One of my childhood life-lessons, which took far too many examples to internalise, was all the people who are very happy to follow the crowd because it is the crowd. In fact, what you're doing now suggests my approach is so alien to you that you yourself are right now not only not even telling yourself this but also labelling yourself as someone who does not say this.
- epiccoleman 8mo agoI've got an Orwell book on my shelf whose title, at least, has the same thesis! https://archive.org/details/AllArtIsPropagandaCriticalEssays/page/n149/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/AllArtIsPropagandaCriticalEssays...