3 ms·
>> Her debut, Kiss, has been out for more than a month — and is fantastic, living up to all its inspirations and more — but as of Oct. 10, not even 100,000 peop
by prostoalex 14y ago
>> Her debut, Kiss, has been out for more than a month — and is fantastic, living up to all its inspirations and more — but as of Oct. 10, not even 100,000 people bought it.
Translation: I'm a self-proclaimed expert in music. When the public disagrees with my assessment of specific music products, it should be lambasted.
- Confusion 14y agoDownvoted for unwarranted ad hominem sneering, which does not address the point made at all. BTW, she's hired by reputable publications to write music reviews, because they feel she is capable of expertly writing music reviews.
- illuminate 14y agoThe entire article is based on the false premise that taste is not subjective, that the author's tastes are shared with the rest of America (an obviously false assumption, considering the end-result), and that the singer is entitled to stardom. "she's hired by reputable publications to write music reviews, because they feel she is capable of expertly writing music reviews" Her worth as a corporate blogger is irrelevant to her smug irritation that America isn't investing itself in Youtube celebrities as much as she is.
- guywithabike 14y agoI think you missed the entire point of the article. The author clearly explains why she believes that the above statement is the case, why Carly was so popular but failed to become a lasting commercial success. You can agree or disagree on her reasoning, but leveling a Hacker News-style personal attack on her adds nothing to the discussion.
- prostoalex 14y agoThe discussion of Ms Jepsen's singing talent is well-supported. The description of single "Kiss" as "fantastic, living up to all its inspirations and more" comes out of the blue.