50 ms·
Speaking more generally, there's a case to be made that the author's intent of what a work "really means" is not necessarily any more sound than that of any oth
by justin66 14y ago
Speaking more generally, there's a case to be made that the author's intent of what a work "really means" is not necessarily any more sound than that of any other reader. What the author was thinking when he wrote it is not the point, the meaning of the thing itself is. I tend to agree.
On the other hand, the bit that Philip Roth was upset about was not really about the meaning of the text. It was about someone's opinion of what he was thinking when he wrote the text. I can understand why he feels that he knows more about what he was thinking when he wrote the text than anyone else does.
I haven't seen anything that would indicate that he fails to recognize that everyone is entitled to their own interpretation of the meaning of the text.