5 ms·
"Wiley, with the Justice Department in support, dismiss those scenarios, and say Congress would be in a position to ensure libraries in particular do not suffer
by greenyoda 14y ago
"Wiley, with the Justice Department in support, dismiss those scenarios, and say Congress would be in a position to ensure libraries in particular do not suffer from any high court ruling against them."
It's strange that the Justice Department would have a reason to have an opinion in this court case at all. And why would our executive branch be siding with the publishing business and against the average citizen on this case?
- tzs 14y agoWhy do you find it strange that the department in charge of enforcement of the laws of the United States would have an opinion on a case concerning the interpretation of one of those laws?
- rhizome 14y agoBecause interpretation is a matter for the judiciary particularly, and a matter of policy to the rest of the department.
- tptacek 14y agoThat's not always true. For instance, the US Code refers to the US Copyright Office for judgements about fair use.
- greenyoda 14y agoBecause this was a civil lawsuit (Wiley v. Kirtsaeng; a corporation suing an individual for damages), not a law enforcement issue.
- mtgx 14y agoBecause Obama got convinced that he needs to be a lot "tougher" on copyright issues - meaning, of course, siding with the publishers, studios and labels.
- rayiner 14y agoA little known fact is that the Justice Department is required to defend Congress's laws. Congress put the import restriction provisions into the law, and the Justice Department is required to argue in favor of them.
- gergles 14y agoPeople love to say this, but nobody has ever been able to show me anything supporting this idea that they are 'required to' defend anything. Please cite the legal authority behind this statement. (As an example: they're not defending DOMA, which was Congress' law.)
- rayiner 14y agoIt's in the Constitution: http://www.heritage.org/constitution/#!/articles/2/essays/98/take-care-clause http://www.heritage.org/constitution/#!/articles/2/essays/98... The non-enforcement of DOMA is based on the President's obligation to not enforce unconstitutional laws: http://www.justice.gov/olc/nonexcut.htm http://www.justice.gov/olc/nonexcut.htm More generally, the Department of Justice is the Attorney General's office, and the Attorney General is the Government's lawyer. Congress is the primary organ of government. Like any lawyer, the Attorney General has a responsibility to vigorously represent his or her client except to the extent it's illegal (unconstitutionality is illegality). This includes arguing for interpretations of the law that favor the client.
- gergles 14y agoSorry, I don't buy this line of reasoning. The President's (and, by extension, the whole Executive branch's) duty is to 'faithfully execute' the laws. I can't see how a rational person would read this clause as pushing some sort of obligation on the Executive to defend laws against challenges in the judicial system. That moves beyond 'execution' by several steps. (That said, I appreciate the pointer and can see how people could interpret the clause in that way. I disagree that it is a correct interpretation, but there's plenty of room for different opinions.)
- csense 14y ago> It's strange that the Justice Department would have a reason to have an opinion in this court case No, it's not. The entertainment industry has at its disposal some of the finest politicians money can buy.