21 ms·
http://talks.golang.org/2012/splash.slide#48 http://talks.golang.org/2012/splash.slide#48
Time for honesty: What bullshit.
- Go codebases by non experts are p
http://talks.golang.org/2012/splash.slide#48 http://talks.golang.org/2012/splash.slide#48
Time for honesty: What bullshit.
- Go codebases by non experts are peppered with magical incantation (sleeps, etc.) to avoid the dreaded "all goroutines are sleep". Of course "they are doing it wrong", but that is the germinal point.
- A concurrent Go program will likely behave differently given 2 bits (just 2 lousy bits) of difference in the object binary. (runtime.GOMAXPROCS(1) vs runtime.GOMAXPROCS(2)). Imagine someone touching those 2 bits in a "large codebase". It is practically impossible to do the same thing in a large Java codebase and fundamentally change the programs runtime behavior. (Happens all the time in Go.)
- It is very difficult to reason about a Go routine's behavior in a "large codebase" without global view and a mental model of the dynamic system e.g. which go routine is doing what and who is blocking and who is not. Pretty much defeats the entire point of "simple" concurrency, to say nothing of "scaling". Programming in Go's variant of cooperative multithreading is actually more demanding than preemptive multithreading. Cute little concurrency pet tricks aside, Go concurrent programming actually requires expert level experience. "You are doing it wrong". Of course. Point.
- There is nothing, absolutely nothing, that you can do in Go that you can not do via libraries in Java. Sure, the cute syntactic go func() needs to be replaced with method calls to the excellent java.util.concurrent constructs, but the benefits -- high performance, explicit-no-magic-code -- outweigh the cute factor in this "programmer's" book.
- On the other hand, there are plenty of things you can do in Java that are simply impossible to do in Go.
- Once we factor in the possibility for bytecode engineering, then Java is simply in another higher league as far as language capabilities are concerned. (Most people who rag on Java are clearly diletantes Java programmers.)
If Go actually manages to be as effective as Java for concurrent programming at some point in the future (when they fix the somewhat broken runtime) then the Go authors are permitted to crow about it. Until that day, go fix_the_runtime() and defer bs().
One thing that programming in Go has made me realize is just how awesomely Sun/Gosling, et al. hit that "practical programming" sweet spot. No wonder the modern enterprise runs on Java and JVM.
It just works. (But it is "boring" because it's not bling anymore. Oh well, kids will be kids.)
> Go codebases by non experts are peppered with magical incantation (sleeps, etc.) to avoid the dreaded "all goroutines are sleep".
I'm confused. This is indicative of a deadlock, where no goroutine can make progress. Sleeps would mask the symptoms, yes, but would never actually solve a deadlock, the program would just do nothing for a longer period of time. What Go codebase(s) are you referring to?
> A concurrent Go program will likely behave differently given 2 bits (just 2 lousy bits) of difference in the object binary. (runtime.GOMAXPROCS(1) vs runtime.GOMAXPROCS(2)). Imagine someone touching those 2 bits in a "large codebase". It is practically impossible to do the same thing in a large Java codebase and fundamentally change the programs runtime behavior. (Happens all the time in Go.)
If you are trying to find a low number of bits, you can just use 0. GOMAXPROCS can be set via an environment variable, the function is just to override that value.
More to the point, I am convinced that you are wrong. You are saying that in a Java class file, there are no 2 bits I could change that would impact the behaviour of a program, and that is plainly false.
> It is very difficult to reason about a Go routine's behavior in a "large codebase" without global view and a mental model of the dynamic system e.g. which go routine is doing what and who is blocking and who is not.
I guess this could be true if you engineer a system where every goroutine depends on every other goroutine. But it isn't true for code I've seen. As an example, the http library in Go has a goroutine that accepts TCP connections, and a goroutine for every accepted TCP connection. This knowledge is not necessary to use it, and is not necessary if a different part of your program is using it, because it is exposed behind an abstraction (http.Handler). To paraphrase the OP, Go enables simple programming. It doesn't forbid bad programming.
> There is nothing, absolutely nothing, that you can do in Go that you can not do via libraries in Java.
Depending on what you mean by "do", I believe Turing would have something to say on this matter: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_completeness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_completeness
> On the other hand, there are plenty of things you can do in Java that are simply impossible to do in Go.
Depending on what you mean by "do", I either agree with you, or think you are mistaken. If you mean things that you can syntactically write down, like a Giraffe is-a Animal, or an Apple is-a Fruit, then yes, that is impossible to write down in Go. If you mean a problem that can be solved in Java that cannot be solved in Go, then I think you are mistaken.
> Once we factor in the possibility for bytecode engineering, then Java is simply in another higher league as far as language capabilities are concerned.
Why is this in another league? You can use assembly from Go, meaning you can generate code and jump to it if you really want to. Not sure why this would be considered a special feature of Java, or even why you think Java pioneered this. Bytecode is just a portable assembly, but its just as portable to build per-platform assembly emitters (like compilers do).
> Most people who rag on Java are clearly diletantes Java programmers.
Right. That makes sense to me; no one who knows anything about Java would ever criticize it. Sarcasm aside, this demonstrates a fallacy in reasoning.
> If Go actually manages to be as effective as Java for concurrent programming at some point in the future
It isn't more effective now? News to me.
> when they fix the somewhat broken runtime
Sorry, remind me what this is referring to?
> It just works. (But it is "boring" because it's not bling anymore. Oh well, kids will be kids.)
This is dangerous thinking. This is the cry that the native programmers raised when Java was born. Try and keep that in mind.
> > when they fix the somewhat broken runtime
> Sorry, remind me what this is referring to?
I think he may be talking about the conservative gc which causes memory to effectively leak a lot on 32 bit machines.
http://code.google.com/p/go/issues/detail?id=909 http://code.google.com/p/go/issues/detail?id=909
Well, that's the same in any concurrent application. If you don't think about race conditions while coding, you shouldn't be using a concurrent language.
This is the same for anything. For example, a webserver written in C++ that uses pthreads might have a #define that determines the number of threads in the thread pool. If the default is 1 and nobody changes this in development, it should not break when someone changes it to 2 or 3, otherwise the code is wrong.
As for your argument about Java, there's nothing you can do in Java that you can't do in assembly. This argument is invalid. Go's strength is in making complex things simple. For example, if you wanted to build a distributed system (across machines), in Go you just use "net/rpc" it would handle it for you. In Java, you'd have like 3 layers of abstract classes that define a serializable type, you'd make some kind of listener class that receives responses from an RPC call, and do tons of other boilerplate. In Go, you just make a function call. That's it.
What exactly can't you do in Go that you can do in Go? Maybe generics, but that just complicates code unnecessarily most of the time. Sure, I've done my share of generic programming, but I've also written non-trivial, several thousand LOC programs in Go, and my Go code was much simpler and easier to read.
BTW, Java sucks for concurrent programming. I hate that stupid Runnable interface (or whatever they call it these days). I'd much rather have a bunch of functions that can be called synchronously, or in a go-routine and have simple checks in place to eliminate race conditions.
Several thousand lines is at least 10x too small to be relevant to a discussion about programming large applications effectively.
In Java, you'd have like 3 layers of abstract classes that define a serializable type, you'd make some kind of listener class that receives responses from an RPC call, and do tons of other boilerplate.
Or you just add Akka to your pom and pass messages between actors. (If using Scala, the syntax is tightened up very nicely.)
> There is nothing, absolutely nothing, that you can do in Go that you can not do via libraries in Java
Agreed, however there are things I really don't want to do in Java as even using the wonderful selection of libraries and tooling out there they are like sandpapering your face and repeatedly ramming it into a salt bath.
By the time I've set up Eclipse, Maven, Jetty/Glassfish and a reasonable framework, I could have actually finished the task in Go. To be 100% honest, I could probably do it whilst maven is puking in the Eclipse log window.
vim gofile.go
go run gofile.go
That is practical programming.
Go is excellent for prototyping ideas, which is why it is my "language of choice" at the moment. But your argument falls flat when considering deploying "large scale" systems, which have multiple dimensions of ceremony before hitting production.
> The child process approach is viable, but in fairness you should note that shared address space provides efficiencies that the RPC approach does not. This approach is IMO quite interesting in context multi-core and certain problem domains, but as a general mechanism it is a 'hack'.
As to the lack of a shared address space, I thought I had communicated that when I said "It might require you to restructure to reduce chattiness", but yes, there are performance advantages to having a shared address space.
You should note that there are security disadvantages to having a shared address space with a sandboxed plugin written in a relatively low-level language (bytecode). I won't post several links to exploits of the Java sandbox in the last year alone, but I am sure you can google for them.
This mechanism is most certainly not a hack. This is the approach that Chromium and the other multi-process browsers (all the modern ones?) use for sandboxing. It seems far more effective to me to push responsibility for security to the OS, rather than the language runtime.
> A full featured runtime reflection mechanism that does not drop "static info" on the floor
Package reflect is fully featured. It just requires you to have a value, or type to actually reflect upon. The tradeoff being that Go can do dead-code elimination and Java cannot. Same thing for Class.forName.
> @MetaInfo() ... Arguably not easy on the eye but necessary and enabling.
I think you are referring to annotations. Yes, Go doesn't have these on methods, functions, or types. But it has these for struct fields (tags); this gives you 90% of the functionality, without muddying up the syntax.
> Bytecode injest (beyond dynamic linking) -- the JVM is your oyster.
Sure. See my note about all of these points below.
> and related Instrumentation
Go has a CPU profiler, a memory allocation profiler. In tip, it has a data race detector. It can expose this data over an HTTP interface so you can profile a running server http://golang.org/pkg/net/http/pprof/ http://golang.org/pkg/net/http/pprof/.
> It is borderline fanaticism to insist on comparing Go to Java, and unfair to Go. Effective advocacy of Go should focus on its strengths (syntax) and not attempt to gloss over its inherent limitations. It is a capable and viable language within well defined limits. Java and JVM are in another league. Accept it and move on.
You continually give me solutions that are impossible to implement in Go, but not the corresponding problems. Like I said, there are things that are syntactically impossible to write down in Go. If you want me to give you a list of things that are impossible to do in Java, I can do that (structural typing, value types, methods on values, multiple top level definitions in a single file, first class functions, efficient array slicing come to mind). I have not done that because it is a nonsensical thing to do. That would be like me saying Javascript is superior to Java because Java does not have prototypical inheritance.
The only useful example I've heard is sandboxed plugins. That is a problem, not a solution. All the things you've listed are solutions. If you actually want to have a conversation about how to solve problems in Go, then list problems, not a laundry list of features that Java has that Go does not.
> If a new 'headius' feels up to it, Go on JVM would be a very interesting new language for the JVM ...
Why? If I want more performance than gc gives me, then I use gccgo. What would Go on the JVM give me?
Also, on an unrelated note, I find it a little sad and pathetic how both you and 0xABADC0DA have to resort to insults to get your point across.