3 ms·
"New York City Police Department: Riding a bike outside of a bike lane is illegal." Just because some unelected government bureaucracy believes something doesn
by jrockway 14y ago
"New York City Police Department: Riding a bike outside of a bike lane is illegal."
Just because some unelected government bureaucracy believes something doesn't make it a law. Who has gone to jail for ripping a Blu-Ray to their iPad? Nobody. Therefore, we don't really know if it's illegal or not. The copyright office has an opinion and have decided not to specifically make the act legal (which is the only authority they have). Fair use, copyright law, "the right of the people to be secure in their ... effects against unreasonable searches..." are all part of the legality equation here, and until this is tested in court, we won't know what is or is not legal.
As far as I can see, the cat is already out of the bag and people don't care what the law is. They can space shift, and will. End of story. (Incidentally, it seems that it's perfectly legal to space-shift pirated media. So maybe just get that instead?)
(It's kind of like how pot is illegal federally, but many states allow people to grow, buy, and sell it. Yup, it's illegal. Too bad nobody cares.)