3 ms·
> that's like saying we were going 10kmh, it's nbd that we accelerate to 1000kmh since we were gonna hit the wall anyways Devil's advocate: folks will take tha
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
> that's like saying we were going 10kmh, it's nbd that we accelerate to 1000kmh since we were gonna hit the wall anyways
Devil's advocate: folks will take that wall a lot more seriously at 1,000 km/h.
"At Jena and Auerstedt the backwardness of the Prussian Army became apparent. By 1806, Prussian military doctrines have been unchanged for more than 50 years—tactics were monotonous, and the wagon system was obsolete" [1]. They had been obsolete for some time. But they didn't break until they hit Napoleon's army.
Similarly, we have a lot of social plumbing that became–with the benefit of hindsight–obsolete with social media. It was possible to ignore, however, because the rate of change was slow. Now it isn't.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Jena%E2%80%93Auerstedt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Jena%E2%80%93Auerste...
- squeefers 9mo ago> Similarly, we have a lot of social plumbing that became–with the benefit of hindsight–obsolete with social media like what? because weve been able to send messages to each other on a computer since the 50s... or do you mean tiktok and twitter specifically?
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> we’ve been able to send messages to each other on a computer since the 50s Not what we colloquially refer to as social media.
- squeefers 9mo agosocial media in uk law = any website with a message feature. social media in common parlance = anything from whatsapp and discord to youtube and tiktok, even sometimes aliexpress. anything with a doomscroll feature. anything showing videos, messaging between users allowed or not. its common usage is confused, the same as the common usage of trolling has strayed from its original meaning because normies picked it up and started using it to mean anyone abusing someone from an online account.
- ben_w 9mo ago> because weve been able to send messages to each other on a computer since the 50s... My first partner was born in the 70s and didn't even have a landline growing up. Here's some stuff I think counts as "plumbing" (i.e. infrastructure) of social connections, which has been lost since the 50s: • Local newspapers (everywhere, I think?), where an actual editor could (and to a limited extent was held responsible if they didn't) filter out the conspiracy theories. • Village churches (that might be mainly a UK-specific thing, IDK?) and other similar local community groups, where your local decisions couldn't be brigaded and overwhelmed by fans of a billionaire living on a yacht, as those fans would need to travel to your village personally and most people couldn't be bothered. Now, even when the groups still exist and meet, they can be brigaded. • Yellow pages getting replaced with Facebook et al insisting that their ad system is the only way any small business could possibly get their name out, when a significant fraction of ads are outright scams.
- squeefers 9mo agoi feel like peter hitchens saying this, but i agree the british social life is decaying. i thought you meant something else by social plumbing. i cant argue other than i dont think the village churches actually do prevent brigading, locally anyway, and its that small minded middle-englander mindset that the internet actually smashes. my nan was all bout dat life, and they ostracized hetero divorcees, and you can imagine what they thought of gay people... so if you agree with them its fine, but if its your only choice of social group its not so great. ill take the point there is very little public space where people can even assemble to create a group in the first place though
- ben_w 9mo ago> i thought you meant something else by social plumbing. Check the names, for all I know JumpCrisscross did mean something else. :) > my nan was all bout dat life, and they ostracized hetero divorcees, and you can imagine what they thought of gay people... so if you agree with them its fine, but if its your only choice of social group its not so great. I'm not claiming the old way was perfect (IIRC my gran was a generation that thought it scandalous to change denomination), just that it wasn't so easily manipulated from different continents. Back then it took a lot of effort over an extended period to do what can now be had for a few dollars of LLM tokens, and 5 years ago could've been had for tens of thousands of dollar-pound-euros spent on people gig-economy-ing tweets while they work at something like Amazon's Mechanical Turk.