2 ms·
Cal Newport has the funniest definition of "mastering" and strangest definition of "world’s most efficient studiers" (another blog post of his from a couple yea
by tokenadult 14y ago
Cal Newport has the funniest definition of "mastering" and strangest definition of "world’s most efficient studiers" (another blog post of his from a couple years ago)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2658927 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2658927
I have ever seen. The shtick is getting old. Gee-whiz posts about a dilettante ramping up to a beginner's knowledge of a subject with little time and effort have nothing to do with the really challenging learning tasks in this world.
I'll be impressed when I see a headline like "Middle East diplomatic issues resolved by undergraduate who completed one course in international relations" or something like that. Show me someone who has solved a genuinely hard problem before proclaiming a new breakthrough in learning. For a refreshing change of pace from the usual blog post on quick-and-dirty learning, see Peter Norvig's "Teach Yourself Programming in Ten Years"
http://norvig.com/21-days.html http://norvig.com/21-days.html
or Terence Tao's "Does one have to be a genius to do maths?"
http://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/does-one-have-to-be-a-genius-to-do-maths/ http://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/does-one-have-to...
for descriptions of the process of real learning of genuinely challenging subjects.
- tom_b 14y agoI have several concerns about the original article, but if the point of this guest post on Newport's blog is "look, I was able to grind through the MIT requirements in a year with reasonable success" it is not particularly damning that all the person achieved is a beginner's knowledge in several courses. Hopefully readers realize that this is not necessarily such a wonderful achievement while simultaneously respecting the effort made. My bigger concern is that the overt focus on "time-compressed" learning is that it will devolve to pure hucksterism with no attempt to move beyond anecdote to real research and thought as to how teaching (either by self-directed methods or to students in a traditional way) can be improved. People seem so interested in short-cuts. I personally want to an "efficient studier," but what I mostly mean is that I do not want to waste time using bad learning methods or materials. We do know that improvements in the learning process are out there - better books, spaced repetition for recall, better guidance and opportunity for early learners than they get in schools in subject-specific areas, etc. These types of posts along with my reading of immersive learning experiences (like your own math programs, dual language programs, "programming school" opportunities) has me thinking about the innate value that immersion offers to the learner. Would linear algebra learners be better off to spend 4 weeks focused on only that subject with a professor/mentor, a textbook, and deliberate practice than a single semester of normal lecture instruction?