4 ms·
Just before this particular parade gets rolling, let's all take a moment to reflect that "market failure" has a particular meaning to the dismal scientists. An
by jacques_chester 14y ago
Just before this particular parade gets rolling, let's all take a moment to reflect that "market failure" has a particular meaning to the dismal scientists.
And it's not "I don't like the outcomes".
There are some cases where a market in water is absolutely the best way to balance usages. It's important to understand that we are not just talking about the construction of infrastructure for municipal supply -- that's an example of a public good where market failure can occur.
We're talking about balancing the demand of different uses for water. Municipal supply vs agriculture vs industry vs environmental flows. This is the kind of hyper-distributed problem that markets are very good at solving.
- rayiner 14y agoI'm well aware what market failure means. And I'm referring to it in the technical sense. The economist response to water privitization is not uniform, and the consequences of market failure in the area would be catestrophic.
- jacques_chester 14y agoThe thing is that the way it's allocated now is ... well, it's awful. Or at the very least: completely accidental. He holds up the Ruhr as a good example. It isn't; it just means that the input into allocations is purely political. Democracy has notorious failure modes too. Here in Australia, for example, we have been having an unending fight over the waters of the Murray-Darling basin since before Federation. How do you balance between providing drinking water to Adelaide, a city of 1.2 million people; and the production of food in the vast irrigated projects upstream? Right now: through god awful bunfights. It simply doesn't work. There's been attempts to introduce a market in water rights, but it's hampered by the fact that a person holding rights in South Australia simply has no way to stop someone in Victoria taking that water out of contention. The dispute only exists because the water isn't fully private property.
- arethuza 14y agoIs there anywhere where water itself is fully private property? I'm just curious how that works when it comes to a river. [NB Not being snarky - I genuinely want to know how it works to "own" water in something like a river which by its very nature doesn't stay in one place]
- jacques_chester 14y agoWhat has been tried in Australia is allocation rights -- X litres of water per year. The problem is that the market doesn't have coverage of the whole supply. Plus you actually need derivatives to deal with the fact that ... um ... river flow varies from year to year. So some rights have to be more secure (and more expensive) than others. The key though is that for the system to work it has to be enforceable against people upstream. Otherwise it's pointless. We don't have that. That rivers cross borders is not a Federal responsibility is a known bug in our constitution.
- glesica 14y agoSo how exactly do we know that the political failure modes, in this case, would be worse than the market failure modes? Last I checked, formalized, real existing markets are extremely vulnerable to political manipulation by both public and private actors/participants (using the public actors as proxies). So we trade in political volatility for political volatility plus market volatility (positive, though perhaps small)? That doesn't sound like a good deal to me... In addition, how on earth are you going to make water fully private? If I look up and open my mouth when it's raining will the police bludgeon me? What about if i set a bucket outside (some municipalities already punish this, actually)? Will a representative of Goldman Sachs insist on weighing me before and after I go rafting, lest I take more water than I paid for home in my stomach and soaking wet clothes? I'm not being (entirely) hyperbolic here, look at intellectual "property" as an example. It isn't a perfect fit, of course, since water is finite. However, the blunt-instrument style enforcement is, I suspect, an excellent model for what would happen if water were to be made 100% private property. How many people have been sued for minor infractions? How many times has the government drastically overstepped its authority to enforce IP laws? How many lawyers have grossly abused the court system to enrich themselves on the backs of innovative companies that accidentally violated vague patents? These things happen partly because IP laws are really, really hard to enforce adequately and evenly. I see no reason why enforcement of water "ownership" would end up any differently.